Thursday 25th April 2024
Issue No. 149
C O N T E N T S
| Notices |
|---|
| Fixing Notice |
| Further Procedure Warning List Personal Injury |
| Calling List |
| Walling List |
| Notice |
| Outer House Rolls |
| Inner House Rolls |
N O T I C E
Parties should liaise with the Keeper’s office prior to enrolling a motion seeking to assign or re-assign a date for a hearing in the Outer House (this excludes commercial and family actions).
Please can parties communicate with the Keeper’s office inbox: keepers@scotcourts.gov.uk
This change is being implemented to avoid overloading of the court rolls, and to avoid hearings in actions which are not being case managed, being assigned for unsuitable dates and times.
UPDATED N O T I C E
OPPOSED AND STARRED MOTIONS
The procedure for the allocation of opposed and starred motions will now be as follows:
When an opposition to a motion or an automatic starred motion is lodged during term time, the Keeper’s Office will allocate the motion to call 2 days ahead from the enrolment of the opposed or starred motion.
Can all parties please ensure their respective counsel are available prior to the enrolment of any opposed or starred motion.
Parties should liaise with the Keeper’s office in relation to the allocation of these motions. Following the allocation of the motion, the clerk will liaise with parties to agree the time the motion will call. This is to ensure an opportunity is provided for representations to be made about the format of the hearing.
All communications with the Keeper’s Office should be made to:
keepers@scotcourts.gov.uk
_______________
F I X I N G N O T I C E
The Keeper’s office is currently fixing the following for Personal Injury Proofs and Ordinary Action Proofs:
Personal Injury 4 day Proofs - 26th November 2024
Personal Injury Proofs requiring more than 4 days - 10th June 2025
Ordinary Action Proofs requiring more than 4 days - 30th July 2024
_______________
FURTHER PROCEDURE WARNING LIST
PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS
Following a trawl of Personal Injury cases lodged within the Offices of the Courts of Session, the following cases have been identified as requiring further procedure in the undernoted cases. Within some of the undernoted cases, intimation has been given to the Keeper of the Rolls regarding the case has settled.
Accordingly the cases will be put out By Order in the near future.
| 1 | PD471/16 Gerard Glynn &cv BHC Ltd | Digby Brown LLP | DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
| |
| 2 | PD399/17 Daniel Bates v Craig Stack | Slater & Gordon Scotland Ltd | DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
| |
| 3 | PD58/18 Fatmah Albuloushi v John Barr | Digby Brown LLP | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP
| |
| 4 | PD309/18 Barry Millar v Onesubsea UK Ltd | Balfour + Manson LLP | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP
| |
| 5 | PD263/19 Fiona Allan &c v Leonardo Bora &c | Slater & Gordon Scotland Ltd | DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
| |
| 6 | PD453/19 Ann Byrne & v Babcock Rail Ltd
| Digby Brown LLP | Brodies LLP | |
| 7 | PD473/19 Gina Brown &c v John Woodward | Balfour + Manson LLP | DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
| |
| 8 | PD38/20 Susan Wylie v Thomas McGuigan &c
| Jackson Boyd LLP | DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP | |
| 9 | PD141/20 Barry Watson v DTT Deliveries Ltd | Slater & Gordon Scotland Ltd
| DWF LLP | |
| 10 | PD241/20 Tracey McDowall &c v Julie Banks &c
| Digby Brown LLP | CMS | BTO Solicitors LLP
|
| 11 | PD306/20 Keith Appleby v Alfred CoiCiola &c | Balfour + Manson LLP | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP
| |
| 12 | PD359/20 Elaine Caird v Barchester Healthcare Ltd | Digby Brown LLP | DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
| |
_______________
COURT OF SESSION
CALLING LIST
Thursday 25th April
| 1 | COS-PD152/24 Gordon Skinner v Sarval (Hartshill) Ltd
| Balfour + Manson LLP
|
| 2 | COS-PD119/24 Raymond Hally &c v Balhousie Care Ltd | Jackson Boyd LLP |
_______________
COURT OF SESSION
WALLING LIST
Thursday 25th April
| 1 | Petition | (FIRST) IAN MACKENZIE PENMAN CONDIE, CA and (SECOND) GREIG HONEYMAN, WS, as trustees of the Rennie Family Trust for an order under Section 306 of the Companies Act 2006 ordering a meeting of the shareholders of William Rennie & Co Limited
| Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP
|
| 2 | Petition | (FIRST) IAN MACKENZIE PENMAN CONDIE, CA, (SECOND) GREIG HONEYMAN, WS, and (THIRD) VICTORIA JANE MURRAY, as executors nominate of the estate of the late Mrs Flora Rennie for Orders under Sections 125 and 306 of the Companies Act 2006 in connection with A & G Cairncross Limited
| Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP |
| 3 | Petition | Lewis O’Connor for Judicial Review of a decision by the University of Glasgow’s Senate Appeals Committee dated 7 March 2024 | Balfour + Manson LLP |
_______________
N O T I C E
INNER HOUSE
All substantive business in the Inner House i.e. hearings not dealing with procedural business as defined by Rule 37A.1(2) of the Court of Session Rules will be conducted in person, however the court may allow parties to be heard remotely on cause shown. A party seeking a remote, or hybrid, hearing should apply to do so by motion.
Procedural hearings in the Inner House, such as leave/permission to proceed hearings, will be conducted virtually or dealt with on the basis of written submissions, however the court may allow the hearing or part thereof to be conducted in person “on cause shown”. A party seeking an in person or hybrid procedural hearing should apply to do so by motion.
OUTER HOUSE
All first instance hearings in the Outer House including proofs, debates and judicial review hearings will be conducted in-person, however the court may allow parties or their witnesses to be heard remotely on cause shown. A party seeking a remote, or hybrid, hearing should apply to do so by motion.
Procedural hearings in the Outer House, including applications for permission to proceed in judicial review petitions, and preliminary and procedural hearings in the Commercial court, will be conducted using Webex or dealt with on the basis of written submissions, however the court may allow the hearing or part thereof to be conducted in person “on cause shown”. A party seeking an in person or hybrid procedural hearing should apply to do so by motion.
_______________
OUTER HOUSE ROLLS
LORD ERICHT – C Wright, Clerk
Court 10 - Parliament House
Wednesday 1st May
Judicial Review – Oral Hearing
| COS-P96/24 Pet: Alan Houston for Judicial Review | Party | | |
By Order
In terms of Rule of Court 43.6(3)
| COS-PD533/23 Patrice Keogh &c v Abellio Scotrail Ltd | Thompsons | Kennedys Scotland | |
By Order
| A252/20 Jorg Mahler &c v Dennis Rose &c | DWF LLP | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP | |
By Order
| A42/22 Brian Ferrier v Lothian Health Board | Anderson Strathern LLP | NHS Scotland Central Legal Office | |
Thursday 2nd May
By Order
| A63/21 WM Louden & Sons Ltd v Barratt Edinburgh Ltd | DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP | |
By Order
| PD53/17 William Thain v LLC Realisations Ltd | Thompsons | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP | |
By Order
| P332/22 Pet: Dumfries & Galloway Housing Partnership Ltd for an order for Specific Performance | Brodies LLP | Pollock & McLean | |
LADY CARMICHAEL – E Hunter, Clerk
Court 8 - Parliament House
Wednesday 1st May
Starred Motion
| COS-F6/24 Brian Thomson v Michael Bradley | Harper MacLeod LLP | Balfour + Manson LLP
| |
Thursday 2nd May
By Order
at 9.30am
| COS-F20/23 Mohammed Malki v Shifa Ajlani | Party | Anderson Strathern LLP | |
Friday 3rd May
Procedural Hearing
at 9.30am
| COS-F83/23 Ryan McIntosh v Karla McIntosh | Harper MacLeod LLP | TC Young LLP | |
LORD FAIRLEY – A McNeill, Clerk
Parliament House
Monday 29th April
Continued Judicial Review – Oral Hearing
| COS-P868/23 Pet: Simon McLean for Judicial Review | Drummond Miller LLP | Brodies LLP | |
LADY POOLE – S Alexander, Clerk
Court 10 - Parliament House
Wednesday 1st May
By Order
In terms of Rule of Court 43.6(3)
| COS-PD556/23 Philomena Logan &c v Western Buses Ltd | DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP | |
By Order
| COS-PD462/22 John McCormick v Advocate General | Digby Brown LLP | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP | |
By Order
| COS-PD246/23 Dominic Carr v Eastern Western Motor Group Ltd | Thompsons | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP | NHS Scotland Central Legal Office |
Thursday 2nd May
Procedure Roll
| COS-A196/22 W v Fife Council | A & WM Urquhart | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP | |
Friday 3rd May
By Order
In terms of Rule of Court 43.6(3)
| COS-PD71/23 Lewis Stephen v Scott Mitchell | Digby Brown LLP | Keoghs Scotland LLP | |
LORD BRAID – D Allen, Clerk
Court 6 - Parliament House
Tuesday 30th April
Preliminary Hearing
between 9.00am and 9.30am
| COS-CA7/24 Barry Stewart &c as Joint Liquidators of One Call Holdings Ltd v Mario Formisano | BBM Solicitors Ltd | Harper MacLeod LLP | |
Continued Preliminary Hearing
between 9.30am and 10.00am
| COS-CA5/24 Synergy Prime Ltd v Scottish Power Energy Retail Ltd | Harper MacLeod LLP
| DLA Piper Scotland LLP
| |
| COS-CA6/25 Fulcrum Hub Ltd v Scottish Power Energy Retail Ltd | Harper MacLeod LLP | DLA Piper Scotland LLP
| |
Wednesday 1st May
Procedural Hearing
between 9.00am and 10.00am
| COS-CA106/23 UK Agricultural Lending Ltd v Duncan Orr | Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP
| Balfour + Manson LLP
| |
| COS-CA107/23 UK Agricultural Lending Ltd v Duncan Orr | Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP
| Balfour + Manson LLP
| |
| COS-CA108/23 UK Agricultural Lending Ltd v John Orr | Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP
| Balfour + Manson LLP
| |
| COS-CA18/24 Duncan Orr &c v UK Agricultural Lending Ltd | Party | Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP | |
Starred Motions
between 10.00am and 11.30am
| CA74/22 Elite Sports Group Ltd v The Rangers Football Club Ltd | Burness Paull LLP | Anderson Strathern LLP | |
Thursday 2nd May
Starred Motion
between 9.30am and 10.00am
| COS-A345/23 ARB Aviation Ltd v James Watt &c | Brodies LLP | Gilson Gray LLP | |
Friday 3rd May
Preliminary Hearing
between 9.30am and 10.00am
| COS-CA1/24 Papel Payment Services Provider LLC v Monitox Ltd | MBM Commercial LLP | CMS
| |
Debate (1 day)
| COS-CA31/23 Forthwell Ltd v Pontegadea UK Ltd | Brodies LLP | Burness Paull LLP | |
LORD SANDISON – L Morgan, Clerk
Court 12 - Parliament House
Tuesday 30th April
Preliminary Hearing
between 9.00am and 9.30am
| COS-CA20/24 Love Investment Properties Ltd v Primark Stores Ltd | Brodies LLP | Addleshaw Goddard (HBJ Gateley) | |
Preliminary Hearing
between 9.30am and 10.00am
| COS-CA15/24 Glenfiddich Wind Ltd v Dorenell Windfarm Ltd | Brodies LLP | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
Preliminary Proof (4 days)
| A204/21 Gillian Cowie v Vitality Corporate Services Ltd &c | Balfour + Manson LLP | Burness Paull LLP | |
Wednesday 1st May
By Order
between 9.30am and 10.00am
| A410/14 James McArthur &c v Arthur Horsey &c | Kennedys Scotland | Aberdein Considine & Co | |
Thursday 2nd May
Preliminary Hearing
between 9.00am and 9.30am
| COS-CA118/23 Aidan O’Neill &c v The Lord Advocate &c | Balfour + Manson LLP | Anderson Strathern LLP | Office of the Advocate General |
Preliminary Hearing
between 9.30am and 10.00am
| COS-CA17/24 Rutland Court Real Estate Ltd v Anderson Strathern | Davidson Chalmers Stewart LLP | Burness Paull LLP | |
Friday 3rd May
Case Management Hearing
between 9.00am and 10.00am
| COS-PD209/21 Paula Walker v Kevin McKeown | Drummond Miller LLP | Party | |
LORD RICHARDSON – S Alexander, Clerk
Court 7 - Parliament House
Tuesday 30th April
Procedural Hearing
between 9.30am and 10.00am
| COS-A398/23 Death Do Us Apart LLP v Blazing Star Productions Ltd &c | Harper MacLeod LLP | Burness Paull LLP | |
LORD LAKE – D Bowie, Clerk
Parliament House
Wednesday 1st May
Judicial Review – Procedural Hearing
COS-P1185/23 Pet: Alson Mazrreku for Judicial Review
| Drummond Miller LLP | Office of the Advocate General | |
LORD STUART – C Munn, Clerk
Court 4 - Parliament House
Monday 29th April
Continued By Orders
at 10.00am
| PD2403/14 Alan Grimmond v Zimmer Ltd | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
PD2733/14 Alexander Bain v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD2040/15 Alistair Carr v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A908/15 Allan Brown (Deceased) v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A328/17 Ann McCarron v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD427/15 Anthony McCaffrey v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
| A10/16 Brian Hyslop v Zimmer Ltd | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
PD2220/15 Catherine Neil v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD1117/15 Christine Wallace v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD499/15 Constance Gilmour v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A11/16 David Hunter v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A15/16 Derrick Catchpool v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD243/15 Dieter Schmitz ( Deceased) v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD71/15 Elizabeth Donohoe v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD51/15 Elizabeth Livingstone v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A17/16 Elizabeth O’Donnell v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A19/16 Frederick O’Neill v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
| A51/16 Grace Cook v Zimmer Ltd | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
| PD175/15 Helen Moir v Zimmer Ltd | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
PD2028/15 Ian Cooper v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD2009/15 Jackie Downes v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD2347/15 Jacqueline Ketchen v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD180/15 Jacqueline Whiteside v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A893/15 Janette Wilkie v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD2732/14 John Carmichael v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
| PD848/15 John Dalziel v Zimmer Ltd | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
PD2170/15 Karl Montgomery v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A18/16 Margaret Burnett v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD1802/15 Margaret Cusker v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A20/16 Margaret McGrory (Deceased) v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD2836/14 Marion Doherty v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
PD2329/14 Nancy McCormack v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
A52/16 Paul Robertson v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
| PD187/15 Philip Keen v Zimmer Ltd | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
PD1114/15 Rakesh Rehan v Zimmer Ltd & Greater Glasgow Health Board
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
| PD72/15 Roger Parton v Zimmer Ltd | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
PD36/15 Sandra Bolton v Zimmer Ltd
| Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP | |
| PD184/15 Vera Catton v Zimmer Ltd | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
| PD433/15 Sadie Calder v Biomet | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
| A296/16 Norman Brown v Biomet | Thompsons | Pinsent Masons LLP
| |
| A884/15 Alexander Reid v Wright Medical | Thompsons | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP
| |
| A204/18 David Brown v Wright Medical | Thompsons | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP
| |
| D1434/15 George Hocknull v Wright Medical | Thompsons | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP
| |
| PD1432/15 Rev Daniel Cheyne v Wright Medical | Thompsons | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP
| |
| A885/15 Sylvia Baird v Wright Medical | Thompsons | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP | |
Tuesday 30th April
Starred Motion
at 9.30am
| COS-F78/23 Elena Bythell v Shaun Bythell | SKO Family Law Specialists | Aberdein Considine & Co | |
Wednesday 1st May
By Order
at 9.30am
| F70/20 Saddah Hassan v Elham Gourti | Drummond Miller LLP | Murphy Robb & Sutherland Solicitors | |
Friday 3rd May
By Order
| COS-AD9/23 Pet: South Lanarkshire Council for Permanence Order for Authority to Adopt re: RLM | South Lanarkshire Council | Drummond Miller LLP | Hilland McNulty Ltd |
LORD MENZIES – E Brown/L Miller, Clerk
Court 7 - Parliament House
Wednesday 1st May
Case Management Hearing
| A251/21 Awfa Paulina v Serco Group Plc | The Conway Accident Law Practice | DWF LLP | NHS Scotland Central Legal Office |
By Order
In terms of Rule of Court 43.6(3)
| COS-PD318/22 Stephen Stott v Royal Mail Plc | Digby Brown LLP | Morton Fraser MacRoberts LLP | |
By Order
| COS-PD315/22 Alexander Montgomery v George Leslie Ltd | Thompsons | DWF LLP | |
Thursday 2nd May
Judicial Review – Substantive Hearing
COS-P1085/23 Pet: Manzoor Hussain for Judicial Review
| Drummond Miller LLP | Office of the Advocate General | |
Friday 3rd May
Case Management Hearing
| COS-A262/22 Douglas McMurdo &c v Scottish Ambulance Service | Drummond Miller LLP | NHS Scotland Central Legal Office | |
Procedural Hearing
| A374/19 Susan Drummond v Lothian NHS Board | DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP | NHS Scotland Central Legal Office | |
By Order
| COS-PD15/21 Shaun Edgar v Aberdeen City Council | Thompsons | Clyde & Co (Scotland) LLP | |
_______________
INNER HOUSE ROLLS
EXTRA DIVISION
Tuesday 30th April
Single Bill
| COS-XA1/24 Mervyn Wilson for leave to Appeal against a decision of the Scottish Legal Complaints Commission | Party | Brodies LLP | |
Wednesday 1st May
Continued Procedural Hearing
| COS-XA54/23 Saqib Deen for appeal against a Decision of Town and Country Planning | Party | SGLD | |
_______________