No.
152 – Monday 22nd April
C
O N T E N T S
|
|
|
|
The
following motions were granted, unopposed, on Thursday 18th April 2013
|
A263/11
Frances Chadburn v Terence Brennan &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
A579/12
City Refrigeration Holdings (UK) Ltd v Dawn Construction |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
|
|
A578/12
City Refrigeration Holdings (UK) Ltd v 3Dried Ltd |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
|
|
A561/12
Ian George Ross v Jonathan Ross &c |
Francis
Gill & Co |
|
|
A221/11
Maureen Leslie v Rupinder Jain |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
A138/12
Ali Masri v Firstgroup Plc |
Thompsons |
|
|
A234/12
Terrance McGeadie v Glaxosmithkline Plc |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
A273/12
Janette McVicar v Gareth Davies &c |
Morton
Fraser LLP |
|
|
A199/13
National Farmers Union Insurance v Catriona MacCallum |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
A513/12
Andrew Porter &c v Dr Ruth Murray &c |
Maclay
Murray & Spens LLP |
|
|
A21/13
Susan Reid v Forth Valley Health Board |
NHS
Scotland Central Legal Office |
|
|
A502/10
Caroline Rose v Dr Stein Bjornsson &c |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
A422/11
Scott Wilson Railways Ltd v McLaughlin & Harvey Ltd |
Dundas
& Wilson CS LLP |
|
|
A245/12
Seasons Holidays Plc v Cornelius Ruitenberg |
Dundas
& Wilson CS LLP |
|
|
F58/09
Margaret Watters or English v Ian English |
Wright,
Johnston & Mackenzie LLP |
|
|
PD2650/12
Nicola Anderson v Grampian Police Joint Board |
Allan
McDougall |
|
|
PD2745/10
Steven Anderson &c v Ship Investors (London) Ltd &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2244/11
Hannah Bain &c v Cape Darlington Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2594/12
George Blackadder v D Blake & Co Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1538/12
Joseph Boyle v Ronald G Graham Roofing & Building Ltd |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD983/11
Alan Brown v Pauline Campopiano |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1424/05
James Brown v UCS Ltd &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1373/12
Aneta Brzozowska v Strathmore Foods Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD509/12
John Burns v AG |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD403/13
Charles Caddis v R & D Construction Group Ltd &c |
bto |
|
|
PD431/13
Billy Cairns v DSM Nutritional Perosuxra (UK) Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2358/12
David Carr v Petrofac Facilities Management Group Ltd &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD624/13
David Caulfield v Barclay Curle Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD362/13
Ann Cunningham v Athanase Mukeya |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1728/12
Margaret Davidson v Keane Premier Healthcare Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1045/12
Kelly Dempsey &c v Fraser Hughes &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2649/12
Anne Dewar v Dundee City Council |
Allan
McDougall |
|
|
PD871/12
Garry Dolan v The Advocate General For Scotland |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2404/12
Billy-John Doonan v Scomac Catering Equipment Ltd |
Aitken
Nairn |
|
|
PD800/12
Susan D’Orleans v Interserve Engineering Ltd |
bto |
|
|
PD1149/12
Mary Dunne v Cape Darlington Ltd &c |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD178/13
Ghislaine Duthart v South Lanarkshire Council |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD589/13
John Evans v Lloyd’s Register of Shipping Trust Corporation |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1377/12
Stewart Ferguson v David Robb t/a Landfill Services |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD422/13
David Flynn v John McConnachie Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2181/12
Thomas Forbes v The Station Hotel |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD111/13
Melissa Foster v Stuart Fraser |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
PD2368/12
Herbert Greig v City of Aberdeen Council |
Lefevre
Litigation |
|
|
PD220/13
Stuart Halbert v Rolls-Royce |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2535/12
Clea Halliday v Direct Line Insurance Plc |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD1553/12
Walter Hogg v Border Construction Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1376/12
Graham Hoggan v David Robb t/a Landfill Services |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD301/13
Trudy Hossain v AXA Insurance UK Plc |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2615/11
Robert Irvine v Blythswood Shipbuilding Co Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD93/13
Robert Irvine v East Dunbartonshire Council |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD874/12
Ellen Jackson &c v Kings And Co Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2025/12
Derek Jamieson v James Boyce |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD630/12
Duncan Kellock v Advocate General of Scotland |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD819/11
Ronald Kerr v Michelin Tyre Plc |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2117/11
James Law v West Dunbartonshire Council &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD911/12
John Lenzi v North Lanarkshire Council |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD413/13
Alan Leslie v Dunecht Estate &c |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2599/11
David Lindsay v Strathclyde Fire & Rescue |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2456/12
Alasdair MacGregor v Enjoy East Lothian Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1752/12
Shenaz Malik v Destination Skin Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1161/12
Kevin Maughan v Dust Control Solutions Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD212/13
Christopher McDaid v Trucktec Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD157/13
Emma McGoldrick v Riverstone Insurance Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD433/13
Andrew McKenzie-Smith v Clarenco LLP |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD378/13
Duncan McNeil v Advocate General For Scotland &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD149/12
Michael McNulty v Lend Lease Construction (EMEA) Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1414/12
Grant Mercer v W & H Contracts &c |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD517/13
Maurice Miller v UCS |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2365/12
John Murphy v Northeast Aircargo Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD409/13
Lorna Nelson v Greater Glasgow & Clyde NHS Board |
NHS
Scotland Central Legal Office |
|
|
PD1224/12
John Norton v Hall Russell Ltd &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD407/13
Paul Robson v The Berwick & District Motor Club Ltd |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD1708/12
Derek Rooney v The Verve Ltd &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1717/12
Paul Russell v Derichebourg Multiservices Ltd |
Morton
Fraser LLP |
|
|
PD552/12
James Sandford v Morris & Spottiswood &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD217
3/12 Dorothy-Ann Scott v Jack Parkes |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD376/12
David Spink v Bett Homes Ltd &c |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD2545/12
David Stalker v Western Buses Ltd |
Morisons
LLP |
|
|
PD599/13
William Stewart v Hall Russell Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2468/12
James Ure v Scottish Water Ltd |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD1123/11
Diana Webster v Chartis Europe Ltd |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD2680/11
Elaine Whiteford &c v Shanks & Co Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD610/13
Matthew Wishart v Forbo-Nairn Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD538/13
John Young v Adrian Hermiston |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
The
following motions were granted, unopposed, on Friday 19th April 2013
|
A739/09
CDP Developments LLP v James Roy Barclay Penny &c |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
A59/13
Marion Leitch or Bryce v Lynn Harrison &c |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
|
|
A455/04
David Melvin v Wilfred Scholes |
Blacklocks |
|
|
A694/07
Faith Nicholson &c v Fife Council |
Ledingham
Chalmers LLP |
|
|
A835/05
James Rapp v The Townhead Surgery &c |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
|
A683/10
West Register (Public Houses II) Ltd &c v Scottish Power |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
PD2643/12
Colin Anderson v North Lanarkshire Council |
Lefevre
Litigation |
|
|
PD161/13
Caroline Brodie v Carolyn Dempster t/a Café Wander |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1445/12
Doinne Bushnell v CIS General Insurance Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD401/13
Anne Campbell v John Purcell &c |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD2194/12
Cameron Cawdron v Karen McGrory |
bto |
|
|
PD2621/12
Stanley Chrystall v John Allison t/a J D Allison & Son |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD222/13
Cal Clark v Ruaridh Fleming |
Harper
MacLeod LLP |
|
|
PD2135/12
Muriel Conlin v Boots UK Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD612/12
John Elliot v Ship Investors (London) Ltd &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD457/13
Robert Ferguson v Robertson & Ross Solicitors Ltd |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD2372/12
Barrie Ferguson v South Lanarkshire Building Supplies Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD148/13
David Gibson v The Scottish Ministers |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
|
PD7
3/13 Patricia Gilmartin v Guardian Care Homes (One) Ltd |
HBJ
Claim Solutions LLP |
|
|
PD2518/12
John Grant v Alexander Hendrie &c |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD531/05
Richard Gray v Corus UK Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2475/12
Thomas Hay v Leslie Heatherington &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD247/12
James Hood v Lord Wallace Of Tankerness QC |
Slater
& Gordon Lawyers |
|
|
PD300/12
Hilary Laverick v TLP Estates & Properties Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2472/12
Elizabeth Love v North Glasgow Housing Association Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2472/12
Elizabeth Love v North Glasgow Housing Association Ltd |
bto |
|
|
PD2188/12
Albert Macbeth v The Forestry Commission |
Allan
McDougall |
|
|
PD2604/12
Edward McGloan v UCS |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
PD377/13
Andrew McGrath v Crittal Windows Ltd |
bto |
|
|
PD332/12
Mark McIntyre &c v Caledonia Joinery Co Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2536/11
Elizabeth McManus &c v UCS |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1102/12
Tadhg McMullan v WM Morrison Supermarkets Plc |
Slater
& Gordon Lawyers |
|
|
PD43/13
Lorna McRae v Aviva Insurance UK Ltd |
Bonnar
& Co |
|
|
PD273/12
Leonard Mitchell v RJT Excavations Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD700/13
Gerald Moir v James Donaldson &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2596/12
Owen Murdoch v West Lothian Council |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2108/09
John Murphy v JGK Ltd &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD678/12
Murray Nicholson v Project Border Ltd |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
PD499/13
Hugh O’Donnell v Advanced Ripening Technologies Ltd &c |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD2106/12
James Parker v William Reid & Sons (Wireworkers) Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1832/12
Caroline Paterson v Simon Blair |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD29/13
Margaret Quinn v North Lanarkshire Council |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD344/13
Caroline Robertson v UK Insurance Ltd |
Harper
MacLeod LLP |
|
|
PD17/13
Mary Robertson v Enterprise Control Engineers Ltd |
Waterman’s
Solicitors |
|
|
PD109/13
Gary Ross v Perth & Kinross Council |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD406/06
Ronald Samuel v Hall Russell Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD991/12
Stuart Sayle v Reliance Secure Task Management Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2071/12
Andrew Sims v Strathclyde Partnership For Transport |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2317/12
Stanley Thomson v Cummings &c |
Russel &
Aitken LLP |
|
|
PD2596/11
William Thomson v Cape Darlington Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1405/12
Thomas Walker v Matthew Sinclair &c |
Digby Brown
LLP |
|
|
PD269/13
Deanna Williams v The Vivat Trust Ltd |
Allan
McDougall |
|
|
PD543/13
David Williamson v Tesco Insurance |
Thompsons |
|
________________
Tuesday
23rd April
EXTRA
DIVISION
|
1 |
XA96/10
Roy Bremner v Elizabeth Bremner |
Campbell
Smith WS LLP |
|
|
INNER
HOUSE STARRED MOTIONS
|
At
10.15am |
XA9/13
Stewart & McIsaac for leave to appeal against a decision of the SLCC |
Balfour
& Manson |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
|
At
11.15am |
XA4/13
Michael Bulla for leave to appeal against a decision of the SLCC |
Party |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
INNER
HOUSE MOTIONS
|
1 |
XA38/13
Javid Akhond for leave to appeal decision of Upper Tribunal (IAT) |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
|
2 |
XA27/13
Mam Saine for leave to appeal against a decision of Upper Tribunal |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
|
3 |
XA158/12
William Beggs against the decision of the Scottish Info Comm |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
|
LORD
HODGE
PETITION
DEPARTMENT
|
1 |
P51/13
Note: M Atkins &c for approval of
accounts (Allan Roofing) |
Halliday
Campbell WS |
|
|
|
2 |
P150/13
Note: M Atkins &c for orders re
Allan Roofing Ltd |
Halliday
Campbell WS |
|
|
|
3 |
P1283/12
Pet: Thomas Hamilton for
disqualification order |
Shepherd
& Wedderburn LLP |
|
|
|
4 |
P1221/12
Pet: Johnstone & Clark (Engineers)
Ltd to wind up |
Maclay
Murray & Spens LLP |
|
|
LORD
GLENNIE
STARRED
MOTION
|
1
hour |
PD852/12
Patrick Ferguson v Jacks 1 Civil Engineering Ltd &c |
Brodies
LLP |
HBM
Sayers |
Simpson
& Marwick |
LORD
KINCLAVEN
UNSTARRED
MOTIONS
|
1 |
A265/13
Jean Bishop v NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
|
2 |
PD2574/10
David McNeill v The Scottish Ministers |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
|
LORD
MALCOLM
UNSTARRED
MOTIONS
|
1 |
CA38/13
Service Temps Inc v Innes Macleod &c |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
|
2 |
CA38/13
Service Temps Inc v Innes Macleod &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
LORD
TYRE
UNSTARRED
MOTION
|
1 |
A1032/08
Balfour + Manson v Dr James Melvin |
Party
Litigant |
|
|
LORD
DOHERTY
UNSTARRED
MOTION
|
1 |
F127/10
Amina Asif v Ejaz Iqbal |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
LORD
BOYD OF DUNCANSBY
PETITION
DEPARTMENT
UNSTARRED
MOTIONS
|
1 |
P233/13
Pet: Arshad Bibi for appointment of a
new trustee |
Boyd
Solicitors |
|
|
|
2 |
P64/13
Pet: Zoubir Bouchachi for judicial
review |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
|
|
3 |
P211/13
Pet: Joseph Che for judicial review |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
|
4 |
P40/13
Pet: XIU Jie Cheng for judicial review |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
|
|
5 |
P249/13
Pet: Dunfermline Athletic Football
Club Ltd to wind up |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
|
|
6 |
P1332/11
Pet: Rubik Kudzhoyan for judicial
review |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
|
|
7 |
P1353/12
Pet: Stuart Oglesby for interdict |
Party |
|
|
|
8 |
P698/12
Pet: Sustainable Shetland for judicial
review |
Scottish
Government |
|
|
|
9 |
P1037/12
Pet: Yu Wang for judicial review |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
|
LORD
STARRED
MOTIONS
|
15
mins |
A391/07
Daniel Wilson v The City of Edinburgh Council |
Simpson
& Marwick |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
30
mins |
A391/07
Daniel Wilson v The City of Edinburgh Council |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
________________
LORD
HODGE – K. Todd, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
Continued
Motion
Between
9.30am and 10.00am
|
1 |
CA65/11
ICL Tech Ltd &c v Johnston Oils Ltd (A Lindsay) |
HBM
Sayers |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
LORD
GLENNIE – G McLeod, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
By
Order (Adjustment) Roll
|
1 |
A271/12
Jennifer Watson v Greater Glasgow Health Board |
Digby
Brown LLP |
NHS
Scotland Central Legal Office |
|
By
Order – Rule of Court 24.2(4)
|
1 |
A218/11
Crocket the Ironmonger Ltd v Richardson & Starling (Northern) Ltd &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
bto |
Dundas
& Wilson |
LORD
KINCLAVEN - R Martin, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
By
Order – Rule of Court 24.2(4)
|
1 |
PD1268/12
Douglas Chalmers v Chivas Bros Ltd |
Thompsons |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
2 |
PD544/12
Russell Wood v Glenshee Ltd |
Digby
Brown |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
LORD
BRAILSFORD - K Keir, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
By
Order
at
9.30am
|
1 |
F119/12
James Daniel v Andrew Howie &c |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
LORD
MALCOLM - K Todd, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
Preliminary
Hearing
Between
9.00am and 9.30am
|
1 |
CA99/12
Telefonica UK Ltd v The Board of Management Stow College |
Morisons
LLP |
Maclay
Murray & Spens LLP |
|
Procedural
Hearing
Between
9.00am and 9.30am
|
1 |
CA113/12
Intergate AG v Cadco Ltd |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
By
Order
Between
9.30am and 10.30am
|
1 |
CA162/11
Coventry Building Society v Andersons Solicitors LLP |
TLT
Scotland Ltd |
DWF
Biggart Baillie DWF LLP |
|
LORD
WOOLMAN - N Marchant, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
Procedural
Hearing
Between
9.00am and 9.30am
|
1 |
CA148/12
@sipp (Pension Trustees) Ltd v Insight Travel Services |
McClure
Naismith LLP |
Brodies
LLP |
|
Preliminary
Hearing
Between
9.30am and 10.00am
|
1 |
CA29/13
Morrison & Mutch Property v Forthflat Ltd |
Brodies
LLP |
The
Alistair Dean Law Practice Ltd |
|
LORD
TYRE – C Stark, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
By
Order – Rule of Court 24.2(4)
|
1 |
PD1773/12
Kevin Cuthbert v Dalcross Handling Ltd |
Digby
Brown |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
LORD
DOHERTY - R Broome, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
By
Order
|
1 |
A460/12
Marshall Ronald v The Duke of Buccleuch &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
Dumfries
& Galloway Council – Legal Services |
LORD
BOYD OF DUNCANSBY - P Weir, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
By
Order
|
1 |
A683/09
Elin Willemse &c v Michal French &c |
Wright
Johnston & MacKenzie LLP |
TC
Young LLP |
|
LORD
JONES – C Truby, Clerk
Wednesday
24th April
Continued
Motion
At
2.00pm
|
1 |
A739/09 CPD Developments v McMillan Kilpatrick |
Brodies
LLP |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
TO
BE ALLOCATED
Wednesday
24th April 2013
Hearing
|
1 |
P1416/11
Pet & Ans: Scottish Ministers for
a recovery re Arthur Martin |
Civil
Recovery Unit |
|
|
SECOND
DIVISION
Wednesday
24th April
By
Order
At
10.30am
|
1 |
XA153/12
Appeal by Josephine Brady against decision of Additional Needs Support
Tribunal |
Drummond
Miller |
Glasgow City
Council |
|
Summar
Roll (2 days)
|
1 |
A1030/08
Reclaiming Motion (Lord Brodie) in the cause Ann Thomson v The Scottish
Ministers |
Drummond
Miller |
Anderson
Strathern |
|
EXTRA
DIVISION
Wednesday
24th April
Advisings
(No
appearance of Counsel necessary)
|
1 |
P876/11 Mary Doogan &c for Judicial review of a
decision of NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Health Board |
Brodies |
NHS
Central Legal Office |
|
|
2 |
Application
for leave to appeal by Michael Karus against a decision of the Scottish Legal
Complaints Commission |
Leslie
& Co |
Anderson
Strathern |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
Procedural
Hearing
At
10.00am
|
1 |
XA11/12
William Beggs v Freedom of Information Commissioner |
Drummond
Miller |
Simpson
& Marwick |
Anderson
Strathern |
________________