No.
95 – Monday 14th January
C
O N T E N T S
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The
following motions were granted, unopposed, on 10th January 2013
|
PD1544/11
Brian Anderson v Anglian Timber Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD256/12
Brigida Fairnie v Lothian NHS Board |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD506/12
Martin Kirkwood v Advocate General |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD142/12
John McGoff v Servis Air UK Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2333/11
Douglas Miller v Atholl Houses Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1112/12
Mark Murphy v Subsea 7 Singapore Pte Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1672/10
Steven Nelson v Hochtief (UK) Construction Ltd |
Thorntons
Law LLP |
|
|
PD1224/12
John Norton v Hall Russell Ltd &c |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
Oksana
Semionova v Direct Line Insurance plc |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2501/11
Margaret Smart v Susan Turner t/a Taste Café |
Thompsons |
|
|
A68/10
Thomazina Adams &c v Baird & Co &c |
Dundas
& Wilson CS LLP |
|
|
A12/09
Aiden Bell v Highland Health Board |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
A518/12
Anne Cunningham v Lindsay Duncan & Black |
TLT
Scotland Ltd |
|
|
A363/12
Glengate Garage Ltd &c v Ian Marsden |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
A465/12
Graeme P Chatham Ltd v Ace European Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
A584/12
Edward Hannah v Procter & Gamble UK |
Lefevre
Litigation |
|
|
A52/12
Midland Provincial Finance Ltd v Walker Fraser Steele LLP |
Cannons
Law Practice |
|
|
A238/11
Petrowell Ltd v Bel Valves Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
A257/12
James Roy v Your Lawyers Ltd |
Bonnar
& Co |
|
|
A493/11
The National House Building Council v Evan Mackintosh |
Tods
Murray LLP |
|
|
A683/09
Elin Willemse &c v Michael French &c |
Wright
Johnston & Mackenzie LLP |
|
|
F48/10
Pamela Jackson v Harry Hopper |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
|
|
PD1723/12
David Anderson v James Cowie & Co Ltd |
Bonnar
& Co |
|
|
PD2118/12
William Anderson v Charles Gray (Builders) Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2218/12
John Bell v Gladedale Group Holdings Ltd &c |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD2176/12
Paulien Brown v GVA Grimley Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2418/12
John Charles v Telford Grier Mackay & Co Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2513/11
Malcolm Davidson v James Anderson |
Morisons
LLP |
|
|
PD2010/12
Gordon Donnachie v Tayside Public Transport Co Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2373/12
Thomas Frew v TBAC Ltd &c |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD446/12
Alexander Heron v Western Buses Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2187/12
Andrew Johnston v DHL Exel Supply Chain Ltd |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
PD279/09
Kathleen Kirkham v Link Housing Group Ltd |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD2173/09
Jean Kyle v Asda Stores Ltd |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD313/09
Irene Little &c v Fairfield Shipbuilding & Engineering |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1900/12
Michael Mahon v Lindsey Wilson |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2083/12
Mhairi Martin v Provident Insurance plc |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1541/12
Paul McGhee v Glasgow City Council |
Glasgow
City Council (Corporate Services) |
|
|
PD1914/12
David McLaren v Michael Burns |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1038/12
Margaret Moore v Inverclyde Community Healthcare |
Digby
Brown |
|
|
PD2353/12
James Rasmusen v Blythswood Shipbuilding Co Ltd &c |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2553/12
John Reay v UCS |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1933/12
Vanessa Salthouse v Direct Line Insurance plc |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2513/12
Heather Scott v The Glasgow Housing Association Ltd &c |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
PD568/11
Peter Shannon v Cleveland Bridge UK Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1769/12
Dawn Simpson v Churchill Insurance Co Ltd |
Harper
Macleod LLP |
|
|
PD2212/12
Alan Small v Stagecoach Group plc |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2498/12
David Stevenson v Agriparts (Stirling) Ltd |
Aitken
Nairn |
|
|
PD2380/12
Heather Still v Geoffrey Bowler |
bto |
|
|
PD2267/12
George Tait v John Brown & Co (Clyde) Ltd &c |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD269/12
John Tregoiing v CIS General Insurance Ltd |
HBJ
Gateley |
|
|
PD1807/12
Greg Whyte v International Insurance Co of Hannover Ltd |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD114/12
Brian Wylie v Danaher UK Industries Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD62/12
Isabel Ziakis v Optical Express Ltd &c |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
|
A478/10
Margaret Clark &c v Merck & Co &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A417/10
David Hamilton v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull &Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A384/10
Janette Hamilton v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A418/10
Elizabeth Hodge v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A455/10
Elizabeth Innes v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A339/10
Giovanna Ionta v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A382/10
Ann Jackson v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A465/10
Jane Kelly v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A266/10
Margaret Lettin v Pfizer Inc &c |
|
|
|
A311/10
William Muir v Pfizer Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A401/10
Patricia Pinterich v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A278/10
George Robertson v Pfizer Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A427/10
Robin Miep v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A397/10
Agnes Taylor v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
A440/10
Mavis Waugh v Merck & Co Inc &c |
Burness
Paull & Williamsons LLP |
|
|
PD259/12
Victor Deans v Cape Darlington Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1920/12
Alice Duncan v Esure Insurance Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD550/11
Kristen Fitzsimmons v The Time Capsule Monklands Trust |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD705/12
Charles Fyfe v John Maclean & Sons Electrical Ltd |
Lefevre
Litigation |
|
|
PD2493/11
Thomas McBride v C Crimin (Electrical Contractors) Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD553/10
Elizabeth McKenna v Reid Furniture Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2998/10
Richard McKeown v Gyplock Ltd &c |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
PD1416/12
Ava Meldrum v Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance plc |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD634/12
Andrew Penny v Highland Offroad |
Thorntons
Law LLP |
|
The
following motions were granted, unopposed, on 11th January 2013
|
A4/13
Gillian Hardie v Greater Glasgow Health Board |
Gildeas
Ltd |
|
|
A184/10
Glenmorangie plc v Normand & Thomson (Hillend) Ltd |
bto |
|
|
PD2666/12
Jack Armitage v Raymond Munro &c |
bto |
|
|
PD2102/12
Grzegorz Dwojak v Farmer Autocare Ltd |
Beveridge
& Kellas |
|
|
PD495/12
Argy-Joy Kho v Southern Cross Healthcare Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2605/11
Robert McIntosh v Chemcem Scotland Ltd &c |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1084/12
Kenneth Palmer v Diageo Distilling Ltd &c |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
PD2251/12
Calum Penny v Raymond Munro &c |
bto |
|
|
PD1701/11
Margaret Sloan &c v Arnott Young & Co |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD3108/10
Charlene Smith v Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance plc |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2453/11
William Stephens v The City of Edinburgh Council |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1049/11
Ken Talbot v First Scotrail Ltd &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2334/12
Gordon Whitelaw v Stirling Council |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1208/12
Melissa Wilson v Tesco Stores Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
A292/12
Donald Bain v Foruno Leasing Ltd &c |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
|
|
A270/12
Agnes Baird v Lanarkshire Health Board |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
A403/11
James McColl v Gordon Bathgate &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
A153/12
Margaret Russell &c v Ayrshire & Arran Health Board |
NHS
Scotland Central Legal Office |
|
|
A372/12
Edward Trainer v Gordon Foggo Bathgate &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2118/12
William Anderson v Charles Gray (Builders) Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1186/121
Lisa Barry v City Building (Glasgow) LLP |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD2004/12
James Cameron v JB Foods (Scotland) Ltd |
bto |
|
|
PD1584/12
Martin Carrigan v David Howie |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD2327/12
Jacqueline Chapman v Kerrie Morrison &c |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD994/11
Sheena Dunn v The National Guarantee Corporation |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1214/12
James Fagan v Fife Council |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1267/11
Alexander Gorman v Arran Builders Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1141/12
Karen Grattan v Derek Penman |
Russell
Jones & Walker |
|
|
PD1971/12
Keith Lynn v Bryony Morgan |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2321/12
Alexander McKee v Albion Automotive |
bto |
|
|
PD2015/12
Patrick McKenzie v Clyde Energy Solutions Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1543/12
Paul McLean v Charles River Clinical Services Edinburgh Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD788/11
Gary McLean v Nortek Aluminium Systems Ltd |
Bonnar
& Co |
|
|
PD1831/12
Alan Middleton v Acromas Insurance Co Ltd |
Lefevre
Litigation |
|
|
PD1831/12
Alan Middleton v Acromas Insurance Co Ltd |
Harper
Macleod LLP |
|
|
PD1033/12
Elizabeth Miller &c v Bett Homes Ltd &c |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD2100/12
Jerome Naish v Adam Little &c |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD1596/12
Francis Newman v First Aberdeen Ltd |
Allan
McDougall |
|
|
PD2529/12
Iain Nisbet v NHS Lanarkshire |
DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP |
|
|
PD1718/12
Julie Raeside v UK Insurance Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2274/12
Russell Shaw v Robinson Scotland Ltd |
bto |
|
|
PD1977/11
Margaret Szmitz v Fife Council |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
A683/10
West Register (Public Houses II) Ltd &c |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD1367/10
Christina Johnson &c v Blythswood Shipbuilding Co Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1501/12
Frances Lowe v Greenock Dockyard Co Ltd &c |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2036/11
James McLaren &c v Upper Clyde Shipbuilding |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD82/12
Ewan Reffin v BT plc |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
A531/12
Vicien Barron v Forth Valley Health Board |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
A52/10
Karen Casey (AP) v North Lanarkshire Council |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
|
|
A273/12
Janette McVicar v Gareth Davies &c |
Hughes
Walker |
|
|
A112/12
Patricia Polley v West Lothian Council |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
A50/12
Propinvest East Kilbride Ltd v Miller Construction (UK) Ltd |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
A108/10
Kelly Watt v Grampian Health Board &c |
Norma
Shippin |
|
|
PD566/12
Sandra Adams v Dobbies Garden Centres Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1191/12
Margaret Cameron &c v UCS &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1998/12
David Cochrane v Allianz Insurance plc |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD2032/12
Kevin Dunlop v First Central Insurance Services Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1167/12
Walter Fleming v Scottish Water Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD22383/12
Irene Goodrum v Dumfries & Galloway Health Board |
Andersons
Strathern LLP |
|
|
PD1516/12
Angus Grant v BRB (Residuary) Ltd &c |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD368/12
Helen Halpin v Thomas Cook Tour Operations Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1072/11
Sean Heaver v Stirling Council |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2364/12
James McGurk v Norbert Dentressangle Logistics Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD873/12
Henry McLean v JH Civil Engineering Ltd |
Bonnar
& Co |
|
|
PD1682/12
Alyson McMillan v Scottish Prison Service |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
|
PD2384/12
Janet Miller v Dumfries & Galloway Health Board |
Anderson
Strathern LLP |
|
|
PD2128/12
Alistair Nimmo v Scottish Water &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD500/12
Christopher Ogg v Tayside Contracts |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD567/12
John Rooney v Rolls Royce plc |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1617/12
Thomas Stanley v SGN Contracting Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD196/12
Jason Stewart v Ardagh Glass Ltd |
Thompsons
|
|
|
PD1700/11
Pat Walls v East Kilbride Thistle Social Club |
Thompsons
|
|
______________
Tuesday 15th January
EXTRA
DIVISION
|
1 |
P695/07
Pet: James Fisher for Judicial Review |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
|
|
INNER
HOUSE STARRED MOTION
At
10AM
|
1 |
XA136/11
Farhad Safi for leave to appeal Upper Tribunal |
Drummond
Miller |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
INNER
HOUSE STARRED MOTION
AT
11.30AM
|
1 |
XA108/12
Olusola Okunade for leave to appeal a decision of the Upper Tribunal |
Drummond
Miller |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
INNER
HOUSE MOTION
|
1 |
XA10/13
Abdur Mohammed for leave to appeal against a decision of the Upper Tribunal |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
|
2 |
XA7/13
Highland Council against a decision of the Scottish Ministers |
DWF
Biggart Baillie DWF LLP |
|
|
|
3 |
XA3/13
Mohammed Asif &c against decision of Scottish Ministers (Town &
Country Planning) |
Party |
|
|
|
4 |
XA77/12
Scottish Ministers for Opinion of the Court – special case re Angus Grower |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
|
5 |
XA9/13
Stewart & McIsaac for leave to appeal against decision of SLCC |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
|
|
LORD
BRODIE
Tuesday
15th January
Judgment
(No
appearance of counsel necessary)
P483/12
George McGeogh for Judicial Review
Balfour
+ Manson LLP – Scottish Legal Aid Board
LORD
BRAILSFORD
|
1 |
A304/11
Commercial First Business Ltd v Landman LLP &c |
Blacklocks |
|
|
LORD
UIST
UNSTARRED
MOTION
|
1 |
A369/12
Michelle Devennie v Blairtummock Housing Association Ltd |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
LORD
BANNATYNE
PETITION
DEPARTMENT
UNSTARRED
MOTION
|
1 |
P1214/12
Pet: Thomas Hughes for exoneration & discharge re J Macintyre |
McClure
Naismith LLP |
|
|
LORD
JONES
UNSTARRED
MOTION
|
1 |
A455/04
David Melvin v Wilfred Scholes |
Blacklocks |
|
|
LORD
BURNS
PETITION
DEPARTMENT
UNSTARRED
MOTIONS
|
1 |
P1380/04
Pet: Andrew Bell for Judicial Review |
SGLD |
|
|
|
2 |
P1275/12
Pet: Elaine Sandison for orders under section 1 Admin Act |
Thorley
Stephenson SSC |
|
|
|
3 |
P769/12
Pet: Ranjit Singh for Judicial Review |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
|
|
4 |
P443/09
Pet: Ranna Singh for Judicial Review |
SGLD |
|
|
|
5 |
P248/11
Pet: Wendy Kelly for Judicial Review |
Wright
Johnston & Mackenzie LLP |
|
|
|
6 |
P3038/06
Pet: Faryad Din for Judicial Review |
SGLD |
|
|
|
7 |
P430/07
Pet: James Crawford for Judicial Review |
SGLD |
|
|
|
8 |
P744/11
Pet: Scottish Ministers for PPO re A Shade |
Civil
Recovery Unit |
|
|
LORD
STARRED
MOTIONS
|
20mins |
P26/13
Pet: Nursing & Midwifery Council to ex tint order K Stewart |
Harper
Macleod |
|
|
|
10mins |
PD2157/12
Lydia Hewitt v Luminar Leisure Ltd (in admin) |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
|
20mins |
PD2018/12
Theresa Murphy v The Advocate General |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
|
15mins |
PD1209/10
Lynn Wallace &c v The Grangemouth Dockyard Co |
Simpson
& Marwick |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
20mins |
PD2533/12
Michael Hale v Thomas Wood |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
__________________
LORD DRUMMOND
YOUNG – T Kell, Clerk
Wednesday 16th
January
By Order
(Adjustment)
|
1 |
A141/12
Theresa Stirling v Glasgow City Council |
Party |
Glasgow
City Council (Corporate Services) |
|
LORD HODGE - D.J.
Morrison, Clerk
Wednesday 16th
January
Motion
Between 9.30am
and 10am
|
1 |
CA5/13
Swellfix UK Ltd v Neil Glover &c |
Ledingham
Chalmers LLP |
|
|
By Order
|
1 |
A605/05
Valerie Clark v Greater Glasgow Health Board |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
Norma Shippin |
|
LORD MALCOLM - K.
Todd, Clerk
Wednesday 16th January
Procedural
Hearing
Between 9.30am
and 10.00am
|
1 |
CA6/12
CGIS (Westergate) Ltd v British Telecommunications plc |
Shepherd
& Wedderburn LLP |
HBJ
Gateley |
|
LORD WOOLMAN – N
Marchant, Clerk
Wednesday 16th January
Judgment
Appearance of
counsel not required
RPS RE II A LLP v CBS Outdoor
Ltd
Pinsent Masons LLP – DAC
Beachcroft Scotland LLP
LORD BANNATYNE –
Z Conway, Clerk
Wednesday 16th
January
By Order
Rule of Court
24.2(4)
|
1 |
A264/12
Bank of Scotland v Sabre Insurance Co Ltd |
Thompsons |
HBM
Sayers |
|
LORD DOHERTY – R
Broome, Clerk
Wednesday 16th
January
By Order
|
1 |
A215/10
James McSheffrey v Colin McColl &c |
Allan
McDougall |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
2 |
A222/10
James McSheffrey v Rosamond Rutherford |
Harper
Macleod LLP |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
LORD BOYD OF
DUNCANSBY – P Weir, Clerk
Wednesday 16th
January
Judgment
(Appearance of
counsel not required)
The Harbro Group Ltd v MHA
Auchlochan
Drummond Miller – TC Young
TO BE ALLOCATED
Wednesday 16th January
First Hearing
|
1 |
P1106/12
Pet: Robert Makutsa (AP) for Judicial
Review |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
Procedure
Roll
|
1 |
A576/11
Keyline Builders Merchants Ltd v Atlas Cranes UK Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
Burness
LLP |
|
INNER HOUSE ROLLS
FIRST DIVISION
Wednesday 16th
January
Procedural
Hearing
Between 9.45am
and 10.45am
|
1 |
A50/11
Reclaiming Motion - Lady Smith - Graeme M Fraser v Royal Bank of Scotland |
Party |
Dundas
& Wilson |
|
EXTRA DIVISION
Wednesday 16th
January
Inner House
Starred Motion
Between 10.00am
and 11.30am
|
|
XA149/11
Application for leave to appeal by Barbara Chiware against a decision of the
Upper Tribunal |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
Inner House
Starred Motion
11.30am and
1.00pm
|
|
XA141/11
Application for leave to appeal by Ezekiel Cheruiyot against decision of the
Upper Tribunal |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
Advising
(Appearance of
counsel not required)
XA136/07 Dr Prim Singh v
Biotechnology & Biological Sciences Research Council &c
Party – Wright Johnston &
Mackenzie
____________
CRIMINAL
ADVISING ROLL
Wednesday
16th January
At
10.15am
NOTE
OF APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION & SENTENCE
M R v
HM Advocate
________________