No: 49 - Thursday 1^st November 2012

C O N T E N T S

Notice

Unopposed Motions

Procedure Roll Warning List

Further Procedure Roll Warning List

Calling List

Undefended Consistorial Causes

Decrees

Single Bills & Inner House Motions

Starred and Unstarred Motions

Outer House Rolls

Inner House Rolls

N O T I C E

The installation of Margaret Elizabeth Scott, QC, as a Senator of the College of Justice will take place in the First Division Courtroom on Friday 2^nd November 2012 at 10.00am.

_____________________

UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on Wednesday 31^st October 2012

PD95/12 Ian Aitkenhead v HSBC Insurance (UK) Ltd	H B M Sayers
PD1231/12 Eric Brown v Royal and Sun Alliance Insurance plc	H B M Sayers
PD1678/11 William Dyer v Polskie Towarzystwo Ubezpieczen SA	H B M Sayers
PD1014/12 Vija Erliha v Lightbody of Hamilton Ltd	Digby Brown LLP
PD2954/10 John Freel v Barr Construction Limited	Digby Brown LLP
PD132/12 Mary Gormley v Ian Carrigan	Morton Fraser LLP
PD1521/12 Taranjeet Kataria &c v Angel Group Limited	Anderson Strathern LLP
PD155/12 Cyril Lees v William Denny & Brothers Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD1506/12 Pauline Lochrie v Sandra Wilson	Digby Brown LLP
PD1528/12 Anne MacKinnon v Thomas Hadfield t/a Ben Nevis Inn	McClure Naismith
PD1866/11 Ian McAree v North Ayrshire Council	Thompsons
PD305/12 Thomas Peggie v Forbo-Nairn Limited	Digby Brown LLP
PD1237/12 Patricia Pelosi v Sarah Miller	Digby Brown LLP
PD1648/11 Qudsia Shahid v William Hamilton & Sons &c	Bonnar & Co
PD427/12 Gary Unett v Phil McNally	Thompsons
A218/11 Crocket the Ironmonger v Richardson & Starling Ltd &c	bto
A336/07 Domicilliary Care (Glasgow) Ltd v Advocate General	Balfour + Manson LLP
A212/11 Michael Duthie v Vetco Gray UK Ltd &c	Mackinnons
A536/11 Andrew Eastcroft v Premium Homes Limited &c	Digby Brown LLP
A174/12 Nigel Firth &c v MacPhee & Partners &c	The Alistair Dean Law Practice Limited
A293/12 Rebecca Jones &c v GB Oils Ltd	Ledingham Chalmers
A294/12 Rebecca Jones &c v GB Oils Ltd	Ledingham Chalmers
A1767/00 M McKee v West Glasgow Hospitals Uni NHS Trust	Thompsons
A877/09 Andrew Mackay v Linda Jamieson	Balfour + Manson LLP
A689/10 Rox Hotel LLP v Norman Watt	Paull & Williamsons
A895/08 Dawn Stone v Executry Services Scotland Ltd &c	Lindsays
PD1038/11 Alessia Abagnale v NFU Mutual Insurance	Thompsons
PD1669/11 Richard Ayling v NHS Highland &c	NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
PD1345/12 Aaron Bain v Mathers (Inverurie) Limited	Lefevre Litigation
PD688/11 Lauren Brown v Direct Line Insurance plc	Thompsons
PD835/12 Michael Burns v Tayport Harbour Trust Limited	Balfour + Manson LLP
PD2553/10 Iain Cameron v BHC Limited &c	Simpson & Marwick
PD1922/10 Elizabeth Cantley v Fairfield Shipbuilding &c	Thompsons
PD2530/11 Stephen Darroch v Gilbert Irvine	Morisons LLP
PD158/12 William Dorans v MacKenzie & Moncur Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD2403/11 Frank Ferrie v Allianz Insurance plc	Simpson & Marwick
PD1462/11 Robert Haley v Orion Street Lightings Ltd	Thompsons
PD1249/12 Ross Henderson v Zurich Insurance plc	Thompsons
PD2442/11 Karin Kinnaird v Stephen Maginnis &c	Simpson & Marwick
PD1778/12 Keith Loynes v The Scottish Salmon Co Ltd	Russell Jones & Walker
PD983/12 Robert McBride v George Christie Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD454/12 Stephen McGlinchey v Gael Force Marine Equipment Ltd	Thompsons	bto
PD2225/11 Stephen McKeown v Inverclyde Council	DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
PD1047/12 Margaret McQuilken v B & M Retail Limited	Thompsons
PD1314/12 George Montgomery v Westcrowns Contracting Services	Digby Brown LLP
PD2468/11 John Rorison v North Ayrshire Council	Lefevre Litigation
PD201/09 John Scott v Glasgow City Council &c	Thompsons
PD2278/11 Nicola Sloan v David Strang	Simpson & Marwick
PD1255/12 Juliet Smith v Kenneth Thomson &c	DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP
PD1629/12 Lorna Stewart v Keith Clark &c	DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
PD1220/12 Steven Sutherland v Gist Limited	Thompsons
PD2613/11 William Tolme v UCS &c	Thompsons

___________________

PROCEDURE ROLL WARNING LIST

The undernoted causes will be put out on the Procedure Roll in the near future. Intimation should be given as soon as possible to the Keeper of the Rolls of any cause in this list which has settled, or is likely to settle:-

1	P575/12 Pet: Brian Cook for interdict	Simpson & Marwick	Party
2	A309/09 Murray Fleming &c v Callum Hastie	Morton Fraser LLP	Hughes Walker
3	A445/11 Andrew Dunn v Maureen Roxburgh	Party	Morisons LLP
4	A101/11 Veronica McLeod &c v Tayside Health Board	Party	RF Macdonald

FURTHER PROCEDURE WARNING LIST

Further procedure is required in the undernoted cases. Accordingly the cases will be put out By Order in the near future.

1	F41/11 Margarita Crighton v Alan Crighton	SKO Family Limited	Turcan Connell
2	P395/12 John Bowden for judicial review	Balfour + Manson LLP

_______________

COURT OF SESSION

CALLING LIST

Thursday 1^st November

1	David Cochrane, 41 Culmuir Terrace, Croy AG Allianz Insurance plc, 57 Ladymead, Guilford, Surrey	Thompsons
2	Paul Harkness, 58 Loancroft Avenue, Baillieston, Glasgow AG Glasgow City Council, City Chambers, George Square, Glasgow	Balfour + Manson LLP
3	Alexander Holmes, 12 Woodlands Drive, Milton, Invergordon, Ross-shire AG (First) Maersk Oil North Sea UK Limited, Maersk House, Braham Street, London and another	Balfour + Manson LLP
4	Norman David Howison, 8 Darluith Park, Brookfield, Johnstone, Renfrewshire AG Sandra Anne Kelly or Howison, 8 Darluith Park, Brookfield, Johnstone, Renfrewshire	Wright Johnston & MacKenzie
5	Denis Kane, 15 Henderson Court, Motherwell AG North Lanarkshire Council, Civic Centre, Windmillhill Street, Motherwell	Balfour + Manson LLP
6	Michelle McAllister, 41 Windhill Road, Mansewood, Glasgow AG The University of Glasgow, University Avenue, Glasgow	Brodies LLP
7	(First) Farhad Naseri, 76 Mellerstain Drive, Glasgow and others AG (First) Chartis Europe Limited, The Chartis Building, 58 Fenchurch Street, London and another	Waterman’s Solicitors
8	Rodger Price, trading as Rodger Price Photography, 12 Braemar Crescent, Carluke, South Lanarkshire AG The Motherwell Football and Athletic Club Limited, trading as Motherwell Football Club, Fir Park, Motherwell	Thompsons
9	Maureen Elizabeth Leslie, 23 Nelson Mandela Place, Glasgow, Liquidator of 3G Design Engineering Limited, having its Registered Office at Unit 1B, Block 16, Burntbroom Court, Queenslie Industrial Estate, Glasgow AG Barbara Pettitt, Red Lion Cottage, High Street, Ayton, Berwickshire	Cannons
10	Robert Morrison MacLeod, First Floor Flat, Royal Buildings, Main Street, Tobermory, Isle of Mull AG Mishnish Enterprises Limited, Royal Buildings, Main Street, Tobermory, Isle of Mull and another	Cannons

___________________

UNDEFENDED CONSISTORIAL CAUSES

Divorce application (Simplified Procedure) awaiting determination

1	Carl Jason Burnage, 17 Blacklands Place, Glasgow AG Rosina Slaven Pye or Burnage, Flat 24, 100 Wester Cleddens Road, Bishopbriggs, Glasgow

Divorce Decree Granted under Simplified Procedure on Thursday 1^st November 2012

1	David Ferguson v Ann Ferguson
2	Charles Linskaill v Suzanne Linskaill

____________________

Friday 2^nd November

EXTRA DIVISION

SINGLE BILLS

1	A220/11 Kivuwatt Ltd v Dane Associates Ltd	Semple Fraser
2	P1136/12 Pet: Lindsay Bryce + 9 others to admit as solicitors	Law Society of Scotland

INNER HOUSE STARRED MOTION

at 10.00am

3

XA143/12 ALP v SC for an order to adopt DLP

Party

INNER HOUSE MOTION

4	XA146/11 Aaron McAllister v Mental Health Tribunal &c	Beveridge & Kellas
5	XA17/12 Alan Cameron against a decision of the Lands Tribunal for Scotland	Drummond Miller LLP

LORD DRUMMOND YOUNG

UNSTARRED MOTION

1

A264/11 Paul Motion &c v William Binnie &c

Francis Gill & Co

LORD KINCLAVEN

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	P1147/12 Note: HMA to recall restraint order re A. Doyle	Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
2	P1148/12 Note: HMA to recall restraint order re D. Glover &c	Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
3	P806/12 Pet: William Beggs for judicial review	Drummond Miller LLP
4	PD1144/12 Pet: HMA for registration of restraint order (Sealskill) Ltd	Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
5	P1145/12 Pet: Pet: HMA for registration of restraint order re D. McHugh &c	Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service

LORD MALCOLM

STARRED MOTION

20mins

CA75/12 Martin & Co (UK) Ltd v Carrie Little

Simpson & Marwick

Allan McDougall

LORD BOYD OF DUNCANSBY

STARRED MOTION

30mins

F5/12 Olessia McDonald v Robert McDonald

Russel + Aitken

Turcan Connell

LORD

STARRED MOTION

10mins	F77/12 Carol Bruce v Neil Bruce	Brodies LLP	Thorntons Law
10mins	F54/12 Neil Bruce v Carol Bruce	Brodies LLP	Thorntons Law
30mins	A125/12 Northern Rock (Asset Management) plc v Jane Steel &c	BBM Solicitors	Dundas & Wilson CS LLP
30mins	A406/11 Spring Salmon & Seafoods Ltd v The Advocate General for Scotland	Russel + Aitken	Office of the Advocate General
30mins	PD2458/11 Michael Leonard v The Loch Lomond and Trossachs National Park	Bonnar & Co	Harper Macleod LLP
40mins	PD2121/11 Rosemary Cairns v Northern Lighthouse Board &c	Simpson & Marwick	Thompsons

CONTINUED MOTION

1

A521/11 Riaz Din v Avonfort Ltd &c

Allan McDougall

MacRoberts

OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

LORD BRACADALE

Wednesday 7^th November

By Order (Adjustment)

1

A181/12 Gordon Drummond v Sheila Drummond

TLT Scotland Ltd

Thorley Stephenson SSC

By Order

1

PD450/12 David Johnston v Highland Council

Thompsons

Ledingham Chalmers LLP

LORD HODGE – H Fraser Clerk

Monday 5^th November

Starred Motion

1

CA114/11 Soccer Savings (Scotland) Ltd v Scottish Building Society

Macroberts LLP

DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP

Tuesday 6^th November

And four ensuing days

Proof before Answer

1

CA18/12 Patersons of Greenoakhill Ltd v Biffa Waste Services Ltd

Pinsent Masons LLP

Dundas & Wilson CS LLP

Tuesday 6^th November

Continued Preliminary Hearing

Between 9.30am and 10am

1	CA70/12 Stephen Dunn &c v HB (SC) Ltd	HBJ Gateley	TLT Scotland Ltd
2	CA72/12 Bernard Crampsie &c v HB (SC) Ltd	Morton Fraser LLP	TLT Scotland Ltd
3	CA71/12 Dean Drury &c v HB (SC) Ltd	HBJ Gateley	TLT Scotland Ltd

Wednesday 7^th November

By Order

Between 9.30am and 10am

1

A82/05 Stephen Findleton v Quarriers

Party

Simpson & Marwick

Thursday 8^th November

By Order

Between 9am and 10am

1

CA56/10 William Sim v David Howat &c

Campbell Smith WS LLP

Morisons LLP

LORD GLENNIE - D.J. Morrison, Clerk

Wednesday 7^th November

By Order (Adjustment)

1

A128/12 Mohammed Siddique v Fife Council

Party

DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP

Thursday 8^th November

Continued Motion

1

P153/01 Pet: James Duff under section 82 of the Bankruptcy Act

Party

bto

By Order

1

PD1028/12 Louise Morton v Fochabers Medical Practice

Balfour + Manson LLP

MDDUS

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling by order in terms of Rule of Court 43.6(7)

1

PD1922/10 Elizabeth Cantley v Fairfield Shipbuilding &c

Thompsons

DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP

Friday 9^th November

By Order

1

PD249/12 David Muir v Reid Furniture

Waterman’s Solicitors

Simpson & Marwick

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.6(7)

1

PD1228/12 Kamlesh Ravalia v Arjo Wiggins Fine Papers Ltd

Thompsons

Simpson & Marwick

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Cases calling by order in terms of Rule of Court 43.10(3)

1	PD2033/11 James McKendrick v Cartsburn Investments Ltd &c	Thompsons	Simpson & Marwick
2	PD279/06 John Mullan v Cartsburn Investments Ltd	Thompsons	Simpson & Marwick

LORD KINCLAVEN – R. Martin, Clerk

Wednesday 7^th November

By Order

1

A57/11 Amanda Coupar v Lanarkshire Health Board

Anderson Strathern LLP

RF Macdonald

Thursday 8^th November

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling by order in terms of Rule of Court 43.10(3)

1	PD499/06 William Brown v Tayside Health Board	Thompsons	RF Macdonald
2	PD2713/10 Williamina McMaster v Weir Construction (1990) Limited	Thompsons	Simpson & Marwick

Friday 9^th November

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling by order in terms of Rule of Court 43.6(7)

1	PD981/12 Lachlan Arnold v The Able Group UK &c	Balfour + Manson LLP	H B M Sayers
2	PD6/12 Alison Gifford v NHS Shetland	Thompsons	NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
3	PD1245/12 Geraldine Allan v Amlin UK Ltd	Thompsons	Brodies LLP

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling by order in terms of Rule of Court 43.10(3)

1

PD2163/11 Samuel Leckie v Royal Mail Group Ltd

Brodies LLP

Morton Fraser LLP

LORD BRAILSFORD

Monday 5^th November

By Order

At 9.15am

1

P330/12 Pet: A G (AP) for enforcement

Simpson & Marwick

Allan McDougall

Wednesday 7^th November

By Order

At 10am

1	P686/12 Pet: HM for order re Child Abduction	Party	Drummond Miller LLP
2	F97/12 Jacqueline Doyle v Daniel Doyle	Brodies LLP	Drummond Miller LLP

Thursday 8^th November

By Order

At 9.15am

1

F180/09 Anne Marie Hraira v Chedhli Hraira

TLT Scotland Ltd

Thorley Stephenson SSC

LORD MALCOLM - K. Todd, Clerk

Monday 5^th November

and 5 ensuing days

Proof before Answer

1

CA149/11 Royal Bank of Scotland plc v James O’Donnell &c

HBJ Gateley

MBM Commercial LLP

Tuesday 6^th November

By Order

Between 9.30am and 10am

1	CA10/12 ALO Properties Ltd v Bell Russell & Co	bto	Simpson & Marwick
2	CA9/12 Hornbuckle Mitchell Trustees Ltd &c v Bell Russell & Co	bto	Simpson & Marwick

Thursday 8^th November

Preliminary Hearing

Between 9.30am and 10am

1	CA100/12 Collinswell Land Ltd v Stewart Milne Group Ltd	Tods Murray LLP	Lindsays
2	CA101/12 Alexander Williamson v Stewart Milne Group Ltd	Tods Murray LLP	Lindsays

Friday 9^th November

Procedural Hearing

Between 9am and 9.30am

1

CA41/12 Ashtenne Caledonia Ltd v Energetics Design & Build Ltd

Brodies LLP

Semple Fraser

By Order

Between 9.30am and 10am

1

CA44/12 South Lanarkshire Council v Costain Building &c

Dundas & Wilson CS LLP

Pinsent Masons LLP

LORD MATTHEWS - L. Curran, Clerk

Friday 9^th November

By Order

At 10am

1

A189/11 Ronald Hastings v Mark Hutchison

Morton Fraser LLP

Party

LORD WOOLMAN – N. Marchant, Clerk

Tuesday 6^th November

By Order

1

CA51/12 Donald Houston &c v Clifford & Deborah Isherwood

MBM Commercial LLP

Morisons LLP

Wednesday 7^th November

and Thursday 8^th November

Debate

1

CA88/11 Alexander Smith &c v Kearney Donald Partnership &c

Blackadders LLP

Simpson & Marwick

LORD BOYD OF DUNCANSBY – T Kell, Clerk

Wednesday 7^th November

By Order (Adjustment)

1

A181/12 Gordon Drummond v Sheila Drummond

TLT Scotland Ltd

Thorley Stephenson SSC

Thursday 8^th November

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

Cases calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.6(7)

1	PD1078/12 Jennifer Brankin v Alasdair Bayne	Digby Brown LLP	Harper Macleod LLP
2	PD1014/12 Vija Erliha v Lightbody of Hamilton Ltd	Digby Brown LLP	bto
3	PD639/12 Jane Clark v Alister McKie &c	HBJ Gateley	Simpson & Marwick

Friday 9^th November

By Order

1	PD393/12 Laura McCormack v City of Edinburgh Council	Digby Brown LLP	Ledingham Chalmers LLP
2	PD1544/11 Brian Anderson v Anglian Timber Ltd	Thompsons	DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

By Order

1

A345/11 William Ferguson &c v Messrs Henderson Loggie &c

Anderson Strathern LLP

Simpson & Marwick

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling by order in terms of Rule of Court 43.10(3)

1

PD2269/11 Martin Gourley v AXA Corporate Solutions Assurance SA

Thompsons

H B M Sayers

TO BE ALLOCATED

Tuesday 6^th November

Proof

8	PD304/09 Daniel Murray v Contractor Task Ltd (in liq)	Andersons	bto
4	F15/12 Elizabeth Hall v Stuart Hall	Morisons LLP	Drummond Miller

Proof before Answer

11	A2391/02 Claire McKenna v South Glasgow University Hospitals NHS Trust &c	Russel + Aitken	NHS Scotland, Central Legal Office
6	A826/09 Norman Jones v James H S Stewart	Lefevre Litigation	Brodies LLP
3	A15/12 William Killoch v Zurich Insurance Plc	Thompsons	Simpson & Marwick

Tuesday 6^th November

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

Proof

4	PD582/07 Gordon Ashcroft v Upper Clyde Shipbuilding Ltd &c	Thompsons	DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP	Brodies LLP
		DLA Piper Scotland LLP
4	PD2370/10 Ann Ferns v John Miller & Sons &c	Thompsons	MacRoberts LLP	Simpson & Marwick
4	PD2023/11 Ronald Anderson v Hall Russell Ltd &c	Digby Brown LLP	Simpson & Marwick	Pinsent Masons LLP
		bto
4	PD2067/11 Patricia Liddell &c v Albion Motors Ltd	Thompsons	Simpson & Marwick
4	PD2121/11 Rosemary Cairns v Northern Lighthouse Board &c	Thompsons	Simpson & Marwick
4	PD2135/11 Dereck Sherratt v Advocate General for Scotland as representing The Ministry of Defence, Rosyth Royal Dockyard	Digby Brown LLP	Morton Fraser LLP	Andersons Solicitors LLP
4	PD2137/11 Stuart McLean v Skene Group Ltd	Digby Brown LLP	HBM Sayers

TO BE ALLOCATED

Wednesday 7^th November

First Hearing

1

P760/12 Pet: Juljian Hykaj for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

OAG

Procedure Roll

1

A64/11 Faith Clancy v Lothian Health Board

Brodies LLP

RF Macdonald

TO BE ALLOCATED

Thursday 8^th November

Hearing on Petition and Answers

2

P793/11 Pet: Cairn Energy plc for interdict

Balfour + Manson LLP

Patrick Campbell & Co

Proof

2

PD1617/11 Douglas Dickson v Stuart Kinsman &c

Thompsons

Simpson & Marwick

TO BE ALLOCATED

Friday 9^th November

Procedure Roll

1	A264/11 Paul Motion &c v William Binnie &c	bto	Francis Gill & Co
1	A330/11 Sean Clark &c v The Scottish Daily Record &c	Heggie Alexander	Balfour + Manson LLP
1	A263/11 Frances Chadburn v Terence Brennan &c	Simpson & Marwick	DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP	Dundas & Wilson CS LLP

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

(FIRST) EXTRA DIVISION

Tuesday 6^th November

Summar Roll (2 days)

XA130/11 Appeal from the Sheriffdom of Glasgow & Strathkelvin at Glasgow in the cause Lidl UK GmbH v The City of Glasgow Licensing Board

Harper Macleod

Glasgow City Council

Thursday 8^th November

Summar Roll (2 days)

P1022/11 Reclaiming Motion – (Lord Malcolm) – Petition of Midlothian Council for a permanence order in respect of SC

Thorley Stephenson

Anderson Strathern LLP

(SECOND) EXTRA DIVISION

Tuesday 6^th November

Summar Roll (2 days)

P788/11, P789/11 & P791/12 Reclaiming Motions – Lord Brailsford – in Petitions by – Comhairle Nan Eilean Siar constituted as Western Isles Islands Council AG The Scottish Ministers

Simpson & Marwick

SGLD

Wednesday 7^th November

Advising

(Appearance of counsel not required)

Reclaiming motion by defenders in the cause L. Batley Pet Products AG North Lanarkshire Council

Balfour + Manson LLP

Ledingham Chalmers

Thursday 8^th November

Summar Roll (2 days)

XA51/10 Appeal under section 37 of the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 by Fiona McBride against a decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal

Thorley Stephenson

Maclay Murray & Spens

Friday 9^th November

By Order

At 10.30am

P705/11 Pet: Redding Park Development Ltd for judicial review

Dundas & Wilson CS LLP

Morton Fraser LLP

__________________