No. 47 – Tuesday 30^th October

C O N T E N T S

Unopposed Motions

Calling List

Single Bills & Inner House Motions

Starred and Unstarred Motions

Outer House Rolls

Inner House Rolls

UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on Monday 29^th October 2012

A135/11 John Fitzgerald &c v Tayside Health Board	Digby Brown LLP
A142/12 Derek Hekelaar v Lee Douglas	bto
F68/11 Sharon Williams v Timothy Williams	Balfour + Manson LLP
PD1370/12 Robert Anderson v Strathclyde Fire & Rescue	Thompsons
PD1078/12 Jennifer Brankin v Alasdair Bayne	Digby Brown LLP
PD1069/12 George Cameron v Falkirk Council	Simpson & Marwick
PD1310/12 Ruaraidh Campbell v Elizabeth MacNeill	Digby Brown LLP
PD1499/12 Chesters Est as Guard of S Chesters v Jacqueline Davidson Chalmers	DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
PD812/12 Andrew Cockburn v Aviva Insurance UK Limited	Simpson & Marwick
PD236/12 Ronald Cresswell v Asda Stores	H B M Sayers
PD1413/12 Margaret Drain v The Rickmond Fellowship Scotland Ltd	Digby Brown LLP
PD2217/08 Maher El-Hadidi v Christopher Goodgrove &c	Digby Brown LLP
PD1214/12 James Fagan v Fife Council	Simpson & Marwick
PD2701/11 Derek Francis v NHS Lothian Uni Hospitals Division	NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
PD2651/11 Kevin Graham v Glasgow City Council	Thompsons
PD1687/12 James King v Burntisland Fabrications Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
PD997/12 Alexandra Logan v Jannie Crombie	Digby Brown LLP
PD1161/12 Kevin Maughan v Dust Control Solutions Limited	H B M Sayers
PD1857/12 Grant McIntosh v Eastern Western Motor Group	Digby Brown LLP
PD31/11 Brian Watt v Les Taylor Contractors Limited	McClure Naismith
A490/04 Agnes Bonar v Union Insulation Co Ltd &c	Thompsons
A278/04 Nir Dror v Hannah Dror	bto
A702/10 Heather Caldwell &c v Lanarkshire Acute Hospital NHS	RF Macdonald
A551/11 Mark Reid v Zurich Insurance plc	Simpson & Marwick
A429/08 Svetlana Ritchie v Lanarkshire Health Board	Balfour + Manson LLP
A323/09 Andrew Speight &c v A & WM Urquhart	bto
A799/09 The Congregation of Partick Free Church v The Congregation	Simpson & Marwick
PD170/11 Brian Dempsie v Strathclyde Fire Board	Simpson & Marwick
PD1241/12 Jacqueline Donachie v WH Smith plc	Thompsons
PD1842/10 Peter Johnston v Advocate General for Scotland	Digby Brown LLP
PD985/09 Kenneth Leigh v Advocate General for Scotland	Thompsons
PD2599/11 David Lindsay v Strathclyde Fire & Rescue	Thompsons
PD1813/11 Linda Mitchell v Highland Health Board	Thompsons
PD2228/12 Gavin Scott v Glasgow City Council	Thompsons
PD1550/12 James Tinney v UK Insurance Limited	Brodies LLP
A263/11 Frances Chadburn v Terence Brennan &c	DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP
A340/11 Graham Chesney v South Lanarkshire Council	Simpson & Marwick
A1/10 Lynn Dunbar v Greater Glasgow & Clyde NHS Board	Anderson Strathern LLP
A408/12 Michael McAinsh v Axa Insurance UK plc	H B M Sayers
A772/06 Elizabeth Morgan v Evelyn Gourlay	Anderson Strathern LLP
A759/07 Bernard O’Rourke v Greater Glasgow & Clyde NHS Board	RF Macdonald
PD2673/11 Elinor Carr v Aberlour Child Care Trust Ltd	Digby Brown LLP
PD1346/12 James Drake v RHI Refractories UK Limited	Digby Brown LLP
PD2003/11 Paul Fawcett v Derek Brown &c	Balfour + Manson LLP
PD1566/12 Suzanne Ferguson v GGHB	Anderson Strathern LLP
PD148/11 Ross French v Strathclyde Fire Board	Simpson & Marwick
PD2047/11 Thomas Gardiner v Forth Ports plc	Allan McDougall
PD1041/09 Gerard Gordon v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders &c	Thompsons
PD2320/11 Michael Gordon v Subsea 7 (Singapore) Pte Ltd	Paull & Williamsons
PD1715/12 Courtnay Johnston v Paul Munro &c	Brodies LLP
PD2117/11 James Law v West Dunbartonshire Council &c	Thompsons
PD1838/11 Kin McArthur v Manorview Hotels Limited	Bonnar & Co
PD412/12 James McGoran v O’Brien Properties Limited	Russell Jones & Walker
PD1433/2 Euphemia Mulholland v Glasgow City Council	Glasgow City Council (Corporate Services)
PD1324/11 Irina Okk v Couper Seafoods Limited	Simpson & Marwick
PD1680/12 Mandy Ramage v Christopher Dean	Digby Brown LLP
PD1614/11 Thomas Robinson v Mersen Scotland Holytown Limited	Bonnar & Co
PD1457/12 Zoe Smith v Andrew Thomson	Digby Brown LLP
PD2049/11 Nicola Wilson v Aberdeen City Council	Simpson & Marwick

____________________

COURT OF SESSION

CALLING LIST

Tuesday 30^th October

1	Eva Anna Allan, 22 Stamperland Gardens, Clarkston, Glasgow and others AG Doosan Power Systems Limited, Doosan House, Crawley Business Quarter, Manor Royal, Crawley, West Sussex	Thompsons
2	Lawrence Connor, 69 Haldane Terrace, Dundee AG Dundee City Council, a local authority constituted under the Local Government Etc (Scotland) Act 1994 having their headquarters at City Chambers, 21 City Square, Dundee	Allan McDougall
3	Claire Degnan, 1/2 7 Calderpark Terrace, Glasgow AG Acromas Insurance Co Ltd, Acromas Motor Claims, PO Box 276, Broadstairs, Kent	Digby Brown LLP
4	Gordon Donnachie, 5 Lawers Road, Dundee AG Tayside Public Transport Co Ltd (t/a National Express Dundee), 44-48 East Dock Street, Dundee	Digby Brown LLP
5	David Duncan, Flat 1/1 Saughton Mains Bank, Stenhouse, Edinburgh AG Asda Stores Ltd, Asda House, Southbank, Great Wilson Street, Leeds	Balfour + Manson LLP
6	Robert Fyall, 3 Langholm Crescent, Glenrothes, Fife AG Tullis Russell Papermakers Ltd, Rothesfield, Markinch, Glenrothes, Fife	Thompsons
7	Robert Gibson, 4 Hecklegirth, Annan AG Alberti Ltd, 9 Allenbrook Road, Rosehill Industrial Estate, Carlisle	Thompsons
10	Ewan Grant, 37 Corton Lea, Ayr AG Chartis Europe Ltd, 58 Fenchurch Street, London	Thompsons
11	James Guthrie, 11 Castle Street, Rosehearty AG Maritime Developments Ltd, having a place of business at Wilson Street, Peterhead	Russell Jones & Walker
12	Edward Hannah, 28 Libertson Street, Carntyne, Glasgow AG Procter & Gamble UK, The Heights, Brooklands, Weybridge, Surrey	Lefevre Litigation
13	Anna Kotlarz, 34A Whinhill Terrace, Banff, Aberdeenshire AG Morrisons Ltd, Kepak Buchan, Markethill Road, Markethill Industrial Estate, Turriff, Aberdeenshire	Thompsons
14	Elzbieta Kurek, 4 Bruce Road, Bathgate AG Vion Food Scotland Ltd, 7 Bain Square, Kirkton Campus, Livingston	Digby Brown
15	Andrew Kyle, Bloque 8 1 E, La Recoleta, Calle Ciclon, Punta Prima, Torrevieja, Alicante 03185, Spain AG Computer Cab (Edinburgh) Ltd, 2-6 Spitfire House, Cargo Terminal, Turnhouse Road, Edinburgh Airport, Edinburgh	Balfour + Manson LLP
16	Anne Langley, 55 Redcroft Street, Danderhall, Dalkeith AG Catherine Flockhart, 54 Boswall Parkway, Edinburgh	Digby Brown LLP
17	Colin Bernard McLauchlan, 34 Links View, Port Seton, Prestonpans, East Lothian AG Scottish Agricultural Industries Ltd, c/o KPMG, Saltire Court, 20 Castle Terrace, Edinburgh and another	Digby Brown LLP
18	Graham McLean, 31 McLaren Crescent, Glasgow AG Strathclyde Partnership for Transport, having a place of business at Consort House, 12 West George Street, Glasgow	Allan McDougall
19	Vanessa Salthouse, Dalton Old School, Dalton, Lockerbie AG Direct Line Insurance plc, 14-18 Cadogan Street, Glasgow	Thompsons
20	Paul Smith, 14 Cumnock Place, Dundee AG Bluebird Buses Ltd, 10 Dunkeld Road, Perth	DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
21	Elizabeth Bruce-Snell, Flat 2/1, 5 Craigbo Road, Glasgow AG Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Underwriting at Lloyd’s Ltd, having its registered office at 25 Fenchurch Avenue, London	Russel + Aitken LLP
22	Kevin Traquair, 20 Whitehills Court, Lochmaben, Dumfriesshire AG Hewden Stuart Limited, Saltire Court, 20 Castle Terrace, Edinburgh	Digby Brown
23	John Wilkie, 4C Cumbrae Crescent, Coatbridge AG Luddon Construction Limited, Balmore House, 1497 Balmore Road, Glasgow	Bonnar & Co

________________

Wednesday 31^st October

EXTRA DIVISION

SINGLE BILLS

1

XA28/11 K Parveen &c for leave to appeal under Tribunal (AIT)

Drummond Miller LLP

INNER HOUSE MOTIONS

2	P371/12 Pet: A & R Robertson & Black for recall of a decision of Scot Sols	Balfour + Manson LLP
3	XA131/12 Amina Mohammed for leave to appeal against a decision of the Upper Tribunal	Drummond Miller LLP
4	XA149/12 Richard Saville-Smith for leave to appeal a decision of SLCC	Party

LORD DRUMMOND YOUNG

STARRED MOTION

20mins

PD1925/12 John Lennon v David Bonnar

Simpson & Marwick

Digby Brown LLP

LORD HODGE

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	P1091/12 Pet: Horizon (Lochend) LLP (in admin) for rectification	Dundas & Wilson CS LLP
2	P1084/12 Pet: JKM Property Services Ltd to ext admin	BBM Solicitors

LORD KINCLAVEN

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	P888/12 Pet: Ako Rash for judicial review	Office of the Advocate General
2	P666/12 Pet: Bruce Borthwick &c for interdict	Stuart Kidd WS
3	P961/12 Pet: Esk District Salmon Fishery Board for judicial review	Thorntons Law LLP
4	P889/12 Pet: Lucia Zifungo for judicial review	Drummond Miller LLP
5	P854/12 Pet: Mohammad Ibrahim for judicial review	Office of the Advocate General
6	P993/12 Pet: Muktar Saleh for judicial review	Drummond Miller LLP
7	P956/12 Pet: Soran Hassan for judicial review	Office of the Advocate General
8	P1332/11 Pet: Rubik Kudzhoyan for judicial review	McGill & Co
9	P838/12 Pet: Salar Osman for judicial review	Office of the Advocate General

LORD WOOLMAN

STARRED MOTION

30mins	CA170/11 Mountwest 838 Limited v Backmuir Trading Limited	Drummond Miller LLP	Davidson Chalmers	Drummond Miller LLP
		Davidson Chalmers

LORD STEWART

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1

A42/05 Shetland NHS Board v Brian Kelly

RF Macdonald

By Order (Adjustment)

1	A1012/08 Comhairle Nan Eilean Siar v J M Architects Ltd	MacRoberts	CMS Cameron McKenna (Scotland) LLP	Dundas & Wilson CS LLP
		Simpson & Marwick

LORD BOYD OF DUNCANSBY

STARRED MOTION

20mins

PD1578/12 Pamela Preston v Lothian Buses plc

Simpson & Marwick

LORD

STARRED MOTIONS

20mins	PD1678/11 William Dyer v Polskie Towarzystwo	DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP	H B M Sayers
30mins	A595/10 Angela O’Hare v Fife Health Board	Balfour + Manson LLP	Central Legal Office
30mins	PD1582/12 Annete Lillig v Ian Fowlie	Digby Brown LLP	H B M Sayers
30mins	PD360/11 Helen Whitham v Central Building Contractors	Digby Brown LLP
1hr	A690/08 Iain Hawthorne &c v Peterkins Solicitors	Brodies LLP	Simpson & Marwick

___________________

OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

LORD DRUMMOND YOUNG – T. Kell, Clerk

Thursday 1^st November

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

Cases calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.6(7)

1

PD427/12 Gary Unett v Phil McNally

Thompsons

Gildeas Ltd

By Order

1	A536/11 Andrew Eastcroft v Premium Homes Ltd &c	Digby Brown LLP	Aitken Nairn	Simpson & Marwick
2	A166/12 Lorraine Molloy v Sabre Insurance Co Ltd	Thompsons	HBM Sayers

LORD HODGE - D.J. Morrison, Clerk

Thursday 1^st November

By Order

Between 10am and 10.30am

1

CA17/12 Centre for Maritime & Industrial v Ineos Manufacturing

Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP

Anderson Strathern LLP

LORD KINCLAVEN - R. Martin, Clerk

Thursday 1^st November

By Order

1	A350/11 Lynnet Leisure (Prop) Ltd v Brandon Homes Construction &c	Halliday Campbell WS	Dundas & Wilson
2	A347/11 Lynnet Leisure (Properties) Ltd v Alexander Murray &c	Halliday Campbell WS	Dundas & Wilson

LORD BRAILSFORD

Thursday 1^st November

FAMILY ACTION

In terms of Rule 49, a proof has been allowed in the following action

1

F72/12 Ian Wyness v Lydia Wyness

Lindsays

Thorley Stephenson

LORD MALCOLM - K. Todd, Clerk

Thursday 1^st November

By Order

Between 9.30am and 10am

1

CA136/11 Colin Fotheringham &c v RSM Tenon Ltd

Campbell Smith WS LLP

Dundas & Wilson CS LLP

Proof before Asnwer

at 10am

2

CA96/09 Walter Mitchell v Great Lakes Reinsurance (UK) plc

Lefevre Litigation

Burness LLP

LORD WOOLMAN – N. Marchant, Clerk

Thursday 1^st November

By Order

Between 9am and 9.30am

1

CA55/12 AGA Rangemaster Ltd v Stewart Technology Ltd

Maclay Murray & Spens LLP

HBJ Gateley

By Order

Between 9.30am and 10am

1

CA151/04 Wyman-Gordon Ltd v Proclad International Ltd

Tods Murray LLP

Brodies LLP

LORD STEWART – C. Scott, Clerk

Thursday 1^st November

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.6(7)

1

PD1249/12 Ross Henderson v Zurich Insurance plc

Thompsons

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

LORD BOYD OF DUNCANSBY – P. Weir, Clerk

Thursday 1^st November

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

Cases calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.6(7)

1

PD454/12 Stephen McGlinchey v Gael Force Marine Equipment Ltd

Thompsons

bto

LORD BURNS

Thursday 1^st November

By Order

1

A279/11 Irene Blyth &c v Philip Thornton &c

Allan McDougall

Russel + Aitken LLP

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

Case calling by order in terms of Rules of Court 43.10(3)

1

PD1089/11 Andrew Beverley v Christopher Webster

Russell Jones & Walker

Ledingham Chalmers LLP

TO BE ALLOCATED

Thursday 1^st November

First Hearing

2	P875/12 Pet: Frank Carberry for Judicial Review	Balfour + Manson LLP
2	P728/12 Pet: X for Judicial Review	Drummond Miller LLP
1	P943/12 Pet: Abdellah Richlove for Judicial Review	Drummond Miller LLP

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

FIRST DIVISION

Thursday 1^st November

Continued Procedural Hearing

At 10am

1

P1190/11 Reclaiming motion Jun Zou for Judicial Review

McGill & Co

Office of the Advocate General

SECOND DIVISION

Thursday 1^st November

Procedural Hearing

At 10am

1

XA118/12 Statutory Appeal - Ceva Freight (UK) Ltd against a decision of the EAT

Macroberts LLP

Pinsent Masons LLP

Continued Preliminary Hearing

At 10.30am

1

A1030/08 Ann Thomson v The Scottish Ministers

Drummond Miller LLP

Anderson Strathern LLP

By Order

At 10.30am

1

P951/10 Pet: Mary Johnstone Cunningham for Judicial Review

Blacklocks

Allan McDougall

Inner House Starred Motion

At 11.00am

1

XA102/12 Child Maintenance & Enforcement Comm v David Roy

Harper Macleod LLP

Party

_______________