Issue 36           Monday 15th October 2012

 

C O N T E N T S

 

 

 

Page No.

 

 

Erratum

2

Unopposed Motions

3 – 7

Single Bills & Inner House Motions

8 – 9

Starred and Unstarred Motions

9 – 12

Outer House Rolls

13 – 15

Inner House Rolls

16

High Court of Justiciary

17

 

E R R A T U M

 

 

The undernoted cases published erroneously in Rolls of Court No. 34 as calling on Wednesday 17th October 2012 will call on Thursday 18th October 2012

 

 

Hearing on Expenses

At 10.30am

 

1

CA165/08 Gillespie Investments Ltd v John McLean Thomson Gillespie

 

Semple Fraser

Party

 

2

CA166/08 Gillespie Investments Ltd v Thomas Graham Gillespie

Semple Fraser

Party

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________
UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

 

 

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on Friday 12th October 2012.

 

A159/06 AC White & c v David Telford

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

A995/08 Tim Amatt &c v South Ayrshire Council

 

McClure Naismith LLP

 

A292/12 Donald Bain v Foruno Leasing Ltd &c

 

BBM Solicitors

 

A118/12 Anne Collie v UK Insurance Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

A72/12 Jayne MacLennan &c v Grampian Health Board

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

A556/11 Derek Wilson &c v Conveyancing Direct &c

 

Anderson Strathern LLP

 

PD2023/11 Ronald Anderson v Hall Russell Ltd &c

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

PD1716/12 Debi Ballantine-Brown v City of Edinburgh Council

 

City of Edinburgh Council

 

PD1248/12 Derek Bond v Peterhead Golf Club &c

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD1584/12 Martin Carrigan v David Howie

 

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

PD40/12 Edith Kidd v Rolls Royce Plc

 

Thompsons

 

PD1068/12 Hazel MacFarlene v Chaucer Syndicates Ltd

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

PD646/12 Douglas McIntosh v Roman Pazdzior &c

 

Harper Macleod LLP

 

PD648/12 Duncan McIntosh v Roman Pazdzior &c

 

Harper Macleod LLP

 

PD1451/11 Susan Mwapaura v P Hutchison &c

 

Anderson Strathern LLP

 

PD2470/11 William Newall v CIS General Insurance Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

PD2600/10 Carol Omand v East Dunbartonshire Council

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

PD331/12 Alexander Patrick v Glasgow City Council &c

 

Thompsons

 

PD1867/11 Alexander Rankin v Rolls Royce Plc

 

Thompsons

 

PD1452/12 Mark Skeffington v UK Insurance Ltd

 

Brodies LLP

 

PD1325/12 James Tarbet v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders

 

Thompsons

 

PD1371/12 George Tomaszewski v Cape Industrial Services Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

PD2223/11 Alan Watson v George Hendry &c

 

Thorntons Law LLP

 

PD32/12 Sharon Watson v Greggs Plc

 

Thompsons

 

A292/11 Jacqueline Fraser &c v Bell Ingram Ltd

 

bto

 

A467/11 George Holdsworth &c v Alastair Robb

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

A553/10 Derek Lewis &c v Michael Blanchard

 

Harper Macleod LLP

 

A565/10 Angela O’Hara v Fife Health Board

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

A419/12 Provident Insurance Plc v Norhayatie Ahmat

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

A417/12 Provident Insurance Plc v Nur Ramli

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

A416/12 Provident Insurance Plc v Zakiah Sharif

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

A267/12 Wendy Scott v Skyfire Insurance Co Ltd

 

Brodies LLP

 

A298/11 Stephenson Construction (Scotland) Ltd v Gary Craig &c

 

Morisons LLP

 

A698/10 The Scottish Association for Marine Science v The ERDC Group

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD1053/09 William Allison v Doosan Babcock Energy Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

PD756/12 Pamela Bell v James McGregor

 

bto

 

PD1412/12 Scott Blacklock v JN Wood & Sons, t/a JN Wood & Sons

 

Lyons Davidson Scotland LLP

 

PD1905/11 Joan Bryans &c v Turner Access Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

{D948/10 William Campbell v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders &c

 

Thompsons

 

PD1050/12 Susanne Dowson v Lothian & Borders Fire & Rescue Board

 

Thompsons

 

PD2003/11 Paul Fawcett v Derek Brown &c

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

PD2281/11 Melanie Girvan v Chartis Insurance UK Ltd

 

Gildeas Ltd

 

 

PD469/12 Stephanie Gray v Liberty Syndicate Management Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

PD181/12 Duncan Grover v David Gray

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD2588/11 John Haston v Ineos Manufacturing Scotland Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

PD2394/11 Roberta Howcroft v Angus Council

 

Allan McDougall

 

PD1234/12 Sophie James v WH Smith Plc

 

Brodies

 

PD340/09 Denise Macfadden &c v Fairfield Shipbuilding

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD1645/12 John McCabe v BRB (Residuary) Ltd &c

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD2414/11 Alan McMahon v Greater Glasgow & Clyde Health Board

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

PD1727/12 Alexandra Millar v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders

 

Thompsons

 

PD1338/12 Andrew Nicoll v Robert Terras Junior Ltd &c

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD1736/12 Anne Revells &c v Gerard McGougan

 

HBM Sayers

 

PD907/12 Gordon Robertson v Scottish Ministers &c

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

PD504/11 Catherine Simpson &c v David Smith

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

PD1337/12 Ian Spinks v Paul Creighton

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

PD1977/11 Margaret Szmitz v Fife Council

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD763/12 James Wallace v McKie & Baxter Ltd &c

 

Thompsons

 

PD1270/12 Derek Wood v Enterprise Engineering Services Ltd &c

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

A495/07 Margaret De Hauteville-Udny v Paull & Williamsons

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

A289/10 Elizabeth Bowie &c v Pfizer Inc &c

 

DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP

 

A307/10 Florence Donnelly v Pfizer Inc &c

 

DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP

 

A275/10 Janet Hill v Pfizer Inc &c

 

DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP

 

 

A266/10 Margaret Lettin v Pfizer Inc &c

 

DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP

 

 

A311/10 William Muir v Pfizer Inc &c

 

DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP

 

 

A278/00 George Robertson v Pfizer Inc &c

DWF Biggart Baillie DWF LLP

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________

Tuesday 16th October

 

EXTRA DIVISION

 

SINGLE BILL

 

1

XA31/11 Gaelle Mukarampi for leave to appeal Upper Tribunal (AIT)

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

 

INNER HOUSE STARRED MOTION

At 10.00am

 

1

XA72/12 James Duff v Robert Forbes

Bto

Party

 

 

INNER HOUSE MOTIONS

 

1

XA149/11 Barbara Chiware for leave to appeal Upper Tribunal

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

2

XA38/12 Benjamin Sharp for leave to appeal against a decision of the EAT

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

3

XA141/11 Ezekiel Cheruiyot for leave to appeal Upper Tribunal

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

4

XA136/11 Farhad Safi for leave to appeal Upper Tribunal

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

5

XA142/12 Arthur Gemmell v WG Mitchell (Three) Ltd

 

Party

 

 

6

XA88/12 Javed Arabkhel for leave to appeal decision of Upper Tribunal (IAC)

 

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

7

XA140/11 Mohammed Abdo for leave to appeal Upper Tribunal

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

8

XA121/11 Nasir Mehmood for leave to appeal Upper Tribunal

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

9

XA60/11 Oluwatoyin Dada against a decision of the Upper Tribunal (IAC)

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

 

 

 

LADY DORRIAN

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

30mins

PD1335/12 Derek Quigley v First City Building (Glasgow) LLP &c

 

Bonnar & Co

Simpson & Marwick

 

10mins

PD1978/11 Anne McLaughlin v First Glasgow Ltd

Simpson & Marwick

Digby Brown

 

 

 

 

LORD HODGE

 

STARRED MOTION

 

30mins

CA81/12 John Carew-Reid v Lloyds Banking Group Plc &c

Party

Anderson Strathern

 

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

P1074/12 Note:  Baxter Investments Ltd for orders re audit

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn

 

 

2

P1075/12 Note:  Clyde View Ltd for orders re audit

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP

 

 

3

P1076/12 Note:  Dean Park Developments Ltd for order re audit

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP

 

 

4

P1078/12 Note:  Park Terrace Investments Ltd to order re audit

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP

 

 

5

P1073/10 SI Hotels Glasgow Investments Ltd to ext admin

 

Dickson Minto

 

 

6

P1077/10 Note:  Woodside Terrace Investments Ltd for order re audit

Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP

 

 

 

 

 

LORD GLENNIE

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

F127/11 Jillian Adie v James Adie

 

Johnson Legal Solicitors

 

 

 

2

F21/12 Therese Chalmers v Paul Chalmers

Harper Macleod LLP

 

 

 

3

A128/12 Mohamed Siddique v Fife Council

Party

 

 

 

 

 

LORD TYRE

 

STARRED MOTION

 

30mins

P635/12 Pet:  Zodwa Mbali for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

 

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

UNSTARRED MOTION

 

1

A234/12 Terance McGeadie v Glaxosmithkline Plc

Party

 

 

 

 

 

LORD BOYD OF DUNCANSBY

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

P325/12 Pet:  Allergan Ltd for Judicial Review

 

Burness LLP

 

 

2

P1066/12 Note:  HMA for warrant of inhibition re L MacLean &c

 

Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Services

 

 

 

3

P1091/09 Pet: Law Society for Scot for interdict v John O’Donnell

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

4

P1064/12 Note:  Jennifer McCrorie for contempt order

 

Russel & Aitken LLP

 

 

5

P872/12 Pet:  Allan Pryde for removal of trustees and interdict

 

Campbell Smith WS LLP

 

 

6

P529/12 Pet:  Scottish Ministers for recovery order re Y Kelbie

Francis Gill & Co

 

 

 

 

 

LORD

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

1hr

PD1887/11 William Auld v Taylor & Fraser Ltd

 

Morisons

Bonnar & Co

 

40mins

A2852/00 Ecclesiastical Insurance v Lady Whitehouse-Grant-Christ

 

Simpson & Marwick

Party

 

30mins

A490/11 Peter Dean v Lynn Jafri

Drummond Miller LLP

Harper Macleod LLP

 

 

25mins

PD1875/11 John Cowan v The Hopetoun House Preservation Trust

Russell Jones & Walker

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________

OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

LORD BRACADALE - A. Galloway, Clerk

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

By Order (Adjustment)

 

1

A569/11 G M Henderson & Partners Ltd &c v Jeremiah Laurenson &c

 

BBM Solicitors

Dundas & Wilson CS LLP

The Law Agency (Scotland) Ltd

 

 

 

LORD BRAILSFORD

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

By Order

Rule of Court 24.2(4)

 

1

F94/12 Thomas McWalter v Victoria McWalter

bto

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

 

LORD MALCOLM - K. Todd, Clerk

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

Preliminary Hearing

At 9.00am

 

1

CA43/12 Whyte and Mackay Ltd v Blyth & Blyth Consulting Engineers Ltd

McClure Naismith LLP

Simpson & Marwick

 

 

By Order

between 9.30am and 10.00am

 

1

CA18/11 David Wright v Colin Watt

Harper Macleod LLP

Party

 

 

 

 

LADY STACEY – I. Martin, Clerk

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

Judgment

(No appearance of Counsel necessary)

 

1

P1801/05 Pet:  Scottish Ministers in respect of a Recovery Order in terms of Section 266 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 Russel Stirton and Alexander Anderson

 

Morton Fraser

Trainer Alston

Party

 

 

Robertson & Ross

Scottish Legal Aid Board

 

 

 

 

LORD TYRE – K O’Hare, Clerk

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

By Order

Rule of Court 24.2(4)

 

1

PD2323/10 Feruza Nuritova v University of Dundee

Thompsons

HBM Sayers

 

 

 

2

PD1530/11 David Collins v Breedon Aggregates Scotland Ltd

 

Anderson Strathern

bto

 

3

PD1370/11 Christine Marshall v Sheila McLymont &c

Russel + Aitken

Simpson & Marwick

 

 

 

 

 

LORD BOYD OF DUNCANSBY – G Scott, Clerk

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

By Order

 

1

A31/11 John Cairns &c v Scottish Power Plc

Ledingham Chalmers

Brodies LLP

 

 

 

 

TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

First Hearing

at 10.00am

 

1

 

P635/12  Pet:  Zodwa Mbali for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

 

Procedure Roll

 

1

A135/11 John Fitzgerald &c v Tayside Health Board

Digby Brown LLP

RF Macdonald

 

 

 

 

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

FIRST DIVISION

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

Starred Inner House Motion

At 10.00 am

 

1

XA140/12 Mohammed Shafi v Mohammed Yasin

RSC Solicitors

Party

 

 

 

 

SECOND DIVISION

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

Starred Inner House Motion

At 10am

 

1

XA67/11 Appeal by North Lanarkshire Council against a decision of the Scottish Ministers

Simpson & Marwick

SGLD

Brodies LLP

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________

HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY

 

 

Wednesday 17th October

 

CRIMINAL ADVISING ROLL

At 10.00am

 

NOTE OF APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE

 

Daniel Carr v HMA

 

 

 

NOTE OF APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION

 

Grant MacNeill

 

 

 

 

APPEAL BY STATED CASE

 

Allison Cairns v Procurator Fiscal

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________