Monday 28^th May 2012

No.177

C O N T E N T S

Unopposed Motions

Single Bills & Inner House Motions

Starred and Unstarred Motions

Outer House Rolls

Inner House Rolls

High Court of Justiciary

UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on Friday 25^th May

A824/09 Arlene Manson v Alan Turner	Balfour + Manson LLP
PD2541/11 David Hunter v Jonathan MacDonald	Brodies LLP
PD2674/10 Bryan Kerr v Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Plc	HBM Sayers
A492/11 Stephen Hindle v FirstGroup Plc	Thompsons
F5/10 Yasmin Nadeem v Asif Nadeem	Aitken Nairn
PD71/12 Evelyn Harvey &c v Crudens (Milton Keynes) Ltd	Thompsons
PD175/12 Helen Kane v West Lothian Council	Thompsons
PD1495/10 Andrew Neish v Baker Hughes (BJ) Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD181/10 Gordon Nicoll v National Insurance & Guarantee Corp &c	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD721/12 Thomas Nisbet v Gilbert Birdsall Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
PD3126/10 Ian Prott v Jonathan Mackenzie	Thompsons
PD1294/11Isobel Reeves v UK Insurance Ltd	Morton Fraser LLP
PD1749/11 Sarah Ritchie v Elizabeth Harvey &c	Russel Jones & Walker
PD2852/10 Josephine Spence &c v Blythswood Shipbuilding &c	Thompsons
PD271/12 Kenneth Thomson v Liverpool Victoria Insurance Co Ltd	Thompsons
A468/11 Allan Downs v East Renfrewshire Council	Simpson & Marwick
A37/12 Lewis Grant v Chartis Europe Ltd	bto
A708/10 Robert Hunter v Pauline Corr or Hunter	Edinburgh Law
A3940/01 Karen Miller v The Yorkhill NHS Trust	Drummond Miller LLP
PD771/12 James Barbour v Lloyds TSB Scotland Plc	Russel + Aitken
PD1083/11 Georgina Black v Roy Richmond &c	Brodies LLP
PD2287/11 Gilbert Black v Scott Mactaggart & Co Ltd	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD2628/11 Lisa Burke v Glasgow City Council	Bonnar & Co
PD500/10 Dorothy Chilton &c v Alstom Ltd &c	Simpson & Marwick
PD665/05 George Clark v Mitsui Babcock :Energy Ltd	Thompsons
PD1482/11 Arthur Craig v Texspeed (Scotland) Ltd	A & W M Urquhart
PD2781/10 Iain Cramb v Rhona Kidd &c	Harper MacLeod LLP
PD2437/11 Claudia Cunningham v Cis General Insurance Ltd	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD215/12 Sarah Dalton v Clyde Importers Ltd	Thompsons
PD1617/11 Douglas Dickson v Stuart Kinsman &c	Simpson & Marwick
PD2173/11 Grant Dunbar v Neptune Deeptech Symons Ltd	bto
PD2174/11 Alex Durrand v Klaus Wedemeyer	Digby Brown LLP
PD354/12 Steven Fitzpatrick v Caledonian Bottlers Plc	bto
PD2535/11 Lindsay Freck v AJG Parcels Ltd	Thompsons
PD258/12 Andrew Gardiner v CCG (Scotland) Ltd	Thompsons
PD264/10 Colin Hunter v O-I Manufacturing UK Ltd	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD2313/11 Gordon Hyland v The City of Edinburgh Council	City of Edinburgh Council
PD2521/10 Campbell Lauffer v Argyll & Bute Council	Simpson & Marwick
PD45/12 Charles Lornie v Arjo Wiggins Fine Papers Ltd	Thompsons
PD113/12 Andrew Mackie v Thomas Dow	Digby Brown LLP
PD113/12 Andrew Mackie v Thomas Dow	Anderson Strathern LLP
PD2237/11 Jeanie Mckendrick &c v Scottish Power UK Plc	Digby Brown LLP
PD617/12 William Miller v Hobart Place Investments Ltd &c	Simpson & Marwick
PD317/12 James Murie &c v Hugh Thompsons	Digby Brown LLP
PD855/11 Ronald Murray v Musgrae Partners GB Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
PD2274/10 Philip O’Sullivan v MMA Insurance Plc	A & W M Urquhart
PD2120/11 Lesley Pallas v Scottish Ministers	Dundas & Wilson
PD305/12 Thomas Peggie v Forbo-Nairn Ltd	Digby Brown LLP
PD2455/11 Charles Robertson v DHL Services Ltd	Bonnar & Co
PD2582/11 William Rollo v Dingbro Ltd	Digby Brown LLP
PD783/12 Kathryn Soriani v NHS Dumfries and Galloway	NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
PD3114/10 Susan Stewart &c v The Church of Scotland &c	Digby Brown LLP
PD268/12 Elizabeth Wallace v The University of Glasgow	Thompsons
PD728/12 Carol Williamson v Jacqueline Brown	Brodies LLP
A172/05 Abacus Estate Ltd v Bell Street Estates Ltd &c	HBJ Gateley
A31/12 Kenneth Patullo v Pik Lee	Balfour + Manson LLP

_________________

Tuesday 29^th May

EXTRA DIVISION

SINGLE BILLS

1*	Pet: Janet Low for Appt of Trustees Re Jennifer Smith	Allingham & Co (Solicitors) Ltd
2	Irene Lamont v Teresa Mooney	Party
3	Stewart MacCallum &c v Margaret Sneddon &c	Simpson & Marwick
4	Margaret Sneddon v Stewart MacCallum	Brodies LLP

INNER HOUSE MOTION

1	Rose Clark v Quantum Claims Compensation Specialists Ltd	Bonnar & Co
2	University College Union Against a Decision of the EAT	Maclay Murray & Spens

LORD HODGE

STARRED MOTION

1 hour

Pet: Royal Bank of Scotland for Cross Border Merger

Dundas & Wilson

LORD MALCOLM

CONTINUED MOTION

30 min

Shetland Line (1984) Ltd v The Scottish Ministers

Maclay Murray & Spens

LADY STACEY

STARRED MOTION

All day

Pet: Scottish Ministers Re S266 Proc Crime R Stirton ETC

Thorley Stephenson SSC

Party

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Pet: Waga Sadeq Mahdi for Judicial Review	Office of the Advocate General
2	Pet: Alan Susskind for Suspension and Interdict	Harper MacLeod LLP
3	Pet: Cameron Fyfe for Suspension and Interdict	Harper MacLeod LLP
4	Pet: David McIndoe for Suspension and Interdict	Harper MacLeod LLP
5	Pet: Gerard Bonnar for Suspension and Interdict	Harper MacLeod LLP
6	Pet: Harvie Diamond for Suspension and Interdict	Harper MacLeod LLP
7	Pet: James Herald for Suspension and Interdict	Harper MacLeod LLP
8	Pet: Kevin Hughes for Suspension and Interdict	Harper MacLeod LLP
9	Pet: Richard Freeman for Suspension and Interdict	Harper MacLeod LLP
10	Pet: Rui Bai for Judicial Review	Office of the Advocate General
11	Pet: Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Ltd for Judicial Review	Shepherd & Wedderburn

LORD DOHERTY

Tuesday 29^th May

ADVISING

(No Appearance of Counsel Necessary)

1

PD125/11 Duncan McDougall v Emtec Building Services &c

Digby Brown LLP

HBM Sayers

Simpson & Marwick

LORD

STARRED MOTIONS

10 min	John McGoff v Servis Air UK Ltd	Digby Brown LLP	Balfour + Manson LLP
20 min	Brian McConville v John Hillhouse (Plant Hire) Ltd	Digby Brown LLP	Wright Johnston & Mackenzie LLP
20 min	Pet: Oluwasegun Oke for Judicial Review	Morton Fraser LLP	Office of the Advocate General
30 min	Colin Hunter v O-I Manufacturing	Thompsons	McClure Naismith LLP
30 min	Emma McCallum v Travel Dundee Ltd	Drummond Miller LLP	Balfour + Manson LLP
30 min	Paul Motion &c v William Binnie &c	bto	Francis Gill & Co
30 min	Paul Motion &c v William Binnie &c	Francis Gill & Co	bto
1 hour	Joan Pentland-Clark v Patrick Wilson &c	Party	Thorntons Law LLP	Balfour + Manson LLP
1 hour	Sandra MacGregor v Farmfoods Ltd	Drummond Miller LLP	Brodies LLP

_________________
OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

LADY SMITH – L. Sexto, Clerk

Wednesday 30^th May

By Order

At 10.00am

1	AD1/12 Petition of JDM & FBM re LR	Digby Brown LLP
2	AD2/12 Petition of JDM & FBM re LR	Digby Brown LLP

LORD HODGE - D.J. Morrison, Clerk

Wednesday 30^th May

Preliminary Hearing

Between 9.00 and 9.30am

1

CA42/12 GTC Holdings Ltd v Mike Gough

Dundas & Wilson

Simpson & Marwick

By Order

Between 9.30am and 10.00am

1

A259/08 Kamaldeep Atwal v North Glasgow Uni Hospitals NHS Trust

Allan McDougall SSC

R F McDonald

LORD GLENNIE – Z. Conway, Clerk

Wednesday 30^th May

By Order

1

A717/10 Gerard Devaney & others v Harvie Diamond &c

Brodies LLP

HBJ Gateley

Maclay Murray & Spens LLP

LORD UIST – C. Stark, Clerk

Wednesday 30^th May

By Order (Adjustment)

1

A473/11 Patricia Kellett v C Hanlon (Plumbing & Heating) Ltd

Digby Brown

Andersons Solicitors LLP

LORD WOOLMAN – N. Marchant, Clerk

Wednesday 30^th May

Procedural Hearing

Between the hours of 09.30am and 10.00am

1

CA22/11 Strathlomond Water Ltd v Spring distribution (Scotland) Ltd

Brodies LLP

Morton Fraser LLP

Continued Preliminary Hearing

Between the hours of 10.00am and 10.30am

1

CA21/12 Restore A Stone (Scotland) Ltd v Mitchells Roberton &c

Balfour + Manson LLP

Dundas & Wilson CS

LADY STACEY – K. O’Hare/I. Martin, Clerk

Wednesday 30^th May

1

F100/10 Marie Johnston v David Paul Johnston

Andersons Solicitors LLP

Sheehan Kelsey Oswald

TO BE ALLOCATED

Wednesday 30^th May 2012

First Hearing

1

P311/12 Pet: Iziegbe Idemudia for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller

Office of the Advocate General

Proof

1

PD1104/11 Emma Irving v Advocate General for Scotland

Drummond Miller

Morton Fraser LLP

Procedure Roll

1	PD936/11 Patricia Ferguson v Alexander Murray &c	Bonnar & Co	bto	Brodies LLP
		HBM Sayers	Ledingham Chalmers LLP

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

EXTRA DIVISION

Wednesday 30^th May

Advising

(No appearance of counsel necessary)

1

Janette Murphy as Attorney of James Stewart Murphy v East Ayrshire Council

Lefevre Litigation

Andersons Solicitors LLP

SECOND EXTRA DIVISION

Wednesday 30^th May

Advising

(No appearance of counsel necessary)

A132/11 Appeal by Tayside Public Transport, t/a Travel Dundee under Section 37 of the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 against a decision of the EAT

Biggart Baillie

Balfour + Manson LLP

Procedural Hearing

At 10.00am

1

XA12/12 Statutory Appeal by Brian Kelly against a decision of the NHS Tribunal

Party Litigant

R F Macdonald

_________________

HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY

CRIMINAL ADVISING ROLL

Wednesday 30^th May

At 10.15am

NOTE OF APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION

Donna Murphy v HMA

_________________