Wednesday 16th May 2012

 

Issue No. 169

 

 

 

C O N T E N T S

 

 

 

 

 

 

Unopposed Motions

Calling List

Single Bills & Inner House Motions

Starred and Unstarred Motions

Outer House Rolls

Inner House Rolls

High Court of Justiciary

 

 


 

UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

 

 

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on Tuesday 15th May 2012

 

 

PD944/11 James Carroll v Balfour Beatty Construction Ltd

 

Digby Brown

 

PD2423/11 John Cole v The Advocate General for Scotland

 

Allan McDougall

 

PD1014/10 Christine Docherty v UK Insurance Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

PD221/12 Susan Gilgun v Hillcrest Housing Association Limited

 

Lefevre Litigation

 

 

PD1267/11 Alexander Gorman v Arran Builders Limited

 

Digby Brown

 

PD614/11 James Irvine v The City of Edinburgh Council

 

Digby Brown

 

PD1656 James McConnell v Harland & Wolff Plc &c

 

Thompsons

 

PD1028/11 Robert Paterson v Cape Insulation Ltd &c

 

Thompsons

 

PD893/11 Deborah Rogers v Scottish Water

 

Thompsons

 

PD2095/11 Renata Wilson v Mulakh Raj t/a St Mirren Food Store &c

 

Digby Brown

 

PD139/12 Claire Borland v Zurich Health Insurance Plc

 

Thompsons

 

PD1074/11 Samantha Butchart v Abertay Housing Association

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

PD1483/11 Ninian Henderson v The Advocate General for Scotland &c

 

Thompsons

 

PD260/11 Michael Logan v Absolute Furnishings Limited

 

Lawford Kidd

 

PD957/11 Robert Smillie v British Polar Engines &c

 

Digby Brown

 

 

PD335/11 Christopher Stewart v John Moulds (Kilmarnock)

 

Lawford Kidd

 

A95/12 Linda Donaldson v Bank of Scotland Plc &c

 

BBM Solicitors

 

A524/08 Laurna Johnson v Grampian Health Board

 

R F Macdonald

 

A674/09 Roy Laing v Edward Caird

 

Thompsons

 

A764/08 Quikway Air Services Inc v Computaplane Limited &c

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

A764/08 Quikway Air Services Inc v Computaplane Limited &c

 

HBM Sayers

 

PD601/12 James McAllister v Kevin Lafferty &c

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD2491/11Gerard Smith v Mahle Engine Systems Limited

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD1094/11 David Graham v Gladedale Timber Systems

 

Brodies LLP

 

PD474/12 Justin O’Neil v Skene Group Limited

 

HBM Sayers

 

PD458/12 Ian Philips v George McNaughton & Son (Plant Hire)

 

bto

 

PD264/11 Barbara Sweeney &c v Greater Glasgow Health Board

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

PD2408/11 Owen Tower v Mahle Engine Systems UK Ltd

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

A654/10 Alan Campbell &c v NHS 24

 

Anderson Strathern LLP

 

PD2125/11 John Ridley v Interlink M74 JV &c

 

Thompsons

 

A375/11 D G Pryde Ltd v Ursula Cameron

 

Morton Fraser

 

A530/11 Colin Fraser v Christine Robertson &c

 

Stuart & Stuart

 

A352/11 Alan Grandison v Lothian Health Board

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

A564/11 Lorraine Littlejohn &c v Lanarkshire Health Board

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

A157/94 Julie McLean v Argyll & Clyde NHS Trust

 

Lindsays

 

A600/11 Kerry Anne McNiven v The Medical Centre &c

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

A146/12 Northern Rock (Asset Management) Plc v Louise Johnstone &c

 

Morisons LLP

 

A706/10 Sirius International Insurance Corporation (PUBL) v Dundas & Wilson

 

Brodies LLP

 

A152/11 James Warren (Jewellers) Limited v Archibald Campbell & Harley &c

 

Brodies LLP

 

F38/11 Margaret Boyle v Charles Boyle

 

Morton Fraser

 

F63/11 Susan Gibson v Scott Gibson

Turcan Connell

 

 

PD1723/11 Kim Allardyce v Ageas Insurance Limited

 

Thompsons

 

 

PD152/12 Finlay Anderson v DHL Excel Supply Chain Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

PD531/12 Victoria Brown v Tayside Contracts

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD2450/11 Michael Bryan v Cartsburn Investments &c

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD2303/11 Paul Cullen v Asda Stores Limited

 

HBM Sayers

 

PD156/12 John Dillon v UCS &c

 

Thompsons

 

PD978/11 Terence Edmiston v Fife Council

 

Thompsons

 

PD1205/11 Jonathan Edmundson v David McGuigan &c

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD2299/11 Audrey Embleton v Glasgow Old People’s Welfare Association

 

Digby Brown

 

PD2003/11 Paul Fawcett v Derek Brown &c

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

PD1961/11 Michelle Fleming v Tesco Stores Limited

 

Thompsons

 

PD91/12 Suzanne Fowler v Tesco Underwriting Limited

 

Thompsons

 

PD1362/11 Frank Gillan v Nagel Limited

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD148/12 Emma Hanson v Chatis Europe Limited

 

Thompsons

 

PD599/12 Moya Harper v Stacey Duncan

 

Harper MacLeod

 

PD192/12 Martin Hogg v Kettle Produce Limited

 

Thompsons

 

PD563/12 Jacqueline Innes v UK Insurance Ltd

 

Harper MacLeod

 

PD31/12 David Jackson v First Central Insurance Company Limited

 

Brodies LLP

 

PD2268/11 Susan Jarosz v Heriot Watt University

 

Digby Brown

 

PD136/12 Joseph Kerr v Logistics Limited

 

Thompsons

 

PD2546/11 Charles Langford v David Philip (Commercials) Ltd

 

Digby Brown

 

PD98/12 Charles Lawrence v Asda Stores Limited

 

Digby Brown

 

PD2067/11 Patricia Liddell &c v Albion Motors Limited

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD525/12 James Little v Aulds Delicious Desserts Ltd

 

bto

 

PD2543/11 Peter McClean v Gemma McCoag

 

Harper MacLeod

 

PD1834/11 Graham McNee v Chivas Brothers Ltd

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD167/12 Avril Muir v Rhys Davies & Sons Limited

 

Digby Brown

 

PD485/12 Kelly Nisbet v Tivoli Manufacturing Limited

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

PD1271/11 Blair Paterson v Peter Paterson &c

 

bto

 

PD397/12 Anne Peacock v Stephen Graham

 

Digby Brown

 

PD1557/11 Alexander Pollock v O-I Manufacturing UK Limited

 

Thompsons

 

PD201/12 Barry Ridley v AXA Insurance UK Plc

 

Thompsons

 

PD1889/11 Davinder Singh &c v Leaf Builders Limited

 

Thompsons

 

PD197/12 Andrew Stewart v Simon Williams

 

Brodies LLP

 

PD264/12 Eric Stuart v Peter M Drummond Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

PD522/12 Margaret Watt v UCS &c

 

Thompsons

 

PD244/12 Neil Winston v Zurich Insurance Company &c

 

Simpson & Marwick

 

 


COURT OF SESSION

 

 

CALLING LIST

 

Wednesday 16th May

 

 

1

Gillian Black, 54 Deanpark Avenue, Balerno AG QBE Insurance (Europe) Limited, 5 Barnton Way, Norwich.

 

Thompsons

2

Tom Brodie, 5 Invergordon Avenue, Glasgow AG Advantage Insurance Company Limited, Conquest House, Collington Avenue, Bexhill‑on‑Sea, East Sussex.

 

Thompsons

3

Robert Brown, 42 Wharfeadale Road, Corby, Northamptonshire AG Airdun Limited, Indiset Company Limited, Unit 10 West Mains Industrial Estate, Falkirk.

 

Thompsons

4

Contact Nominees (Jersey) Limited, PO Box 496, Charles House, Charles Street, St Helier, Jersey AG Leslie Wolfson & Co, a partnership formed under the law of Scotland, and Howard Beach, AlanCarlton, Stephen Silver and Nicholas Taylor, the partners thereof, as such partners and as individuals, all having a place of business at 19 Waterloo Street, Glasgow.

 

Maclay Murray & Spens

5

Gerald Fallon, Isla View, 27 Knowes View, Clydebank AG (1) Kendrick Computing Plc, 14 James Street, London and another.

 

Thompsons

 

6

Charles Fyfe, 210 Hilton Avenue, Aberdeen AG John MacLean & Sons Electrical (Dingwall) Limited, Peterseat Park, Peterseat Drive, Altens, Aberdeen.

 

Lefevre Litigation

7

Patrick McGrail, Flat 0/2, 2 Larchfield Place, Scotstoun, Glasgow AG Shipbreaking Industries Limited, No. 2 Lochrin Square, 96 Fountainbridge, Edinburgh.

 

Thompsons

8

Daniel Mottershead, 21 Reid Place, Glenrothes, AG Sabre Insurance Company Limited, Sabre House, 150 South Street, Dorking.

 

Thompsons

9

Thomas Nisbet, Eden Villa, Victoria Road, Eyemouth AG Gilbert Birdsall Limited, South Farm, South Road, Belford, Northumberland.

 

Digby Brown

10

Mary Ann Sanchez, 41 Gracemount House Drive, Edinburgh AG Lothian Health Board, Waverly Gate, 2 – 4 Waterloo Place, Edinburgh.

 

Waterman’s Solicitors

11

Helen Gillian Shiels, 26/2 Causewayside, Edinburgh AG Lothian Health Board, Ellen’s Glen House, 72 Carnbee Avenue, Edinburgh.

 

Anderson Strathern LLP

12

Elizabeth Mary Spence, 23 Bennachie Avenue, Inverurie, Aberdeenshire AG Co‑Operative Group Limited, New Century House, Corporation Street, Manchester.

 

Thompsons

13

John Jason Stewart, 3 Admiral’s Way, Westhill, Culloden, Inverness AG Allianz Insurance Plc, Personal Injury Claims, Allianz Insurance, 500 Avebury Boulevard, Milton Keynes.

 

Thompsons

14

Alexander Kennedy Thomson, 65 Whin Park, Cockenzie, East Lothian AG (1) Clyde Sturtevant Limited, Caroline Court, Lakeside, Doncaster, South Yorkshire and others.

 

Thompsons

 

 

 

__________________
Thursday 17th May

 

SECOND DIVISION

 

INNER HOUSE MOTION

 

1

Andrew Cusick against a decision of the EAT

Maclay Murray & Spens

 

 

 

 

 

LORD HODGE

 

PETITION DEPARTMENT

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

Note:  D Menzies for remuneration re:

Ross & Bonnyman Ltd

 

Paull & Williamsons LLP

 

 

2

Note:  J Palmer for remuneration re:  United Brands Limited

 

Biggart Baillie LLP

 

 

3

Pet:  J Cartwright for ext admin re:  Front Door Investments Ltd

 

Brodies LLP

 

 

 

 

LORD GLENNIE

 

PETITION DEPARTMENT

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

Pet:  Guevara Leacock for Judicial Review

 

McGill & Co

 

 

2

Pet:  William Bronksy & another for Non‑Harassment Order

 

Party

 

 

3

Pet:  William Bronnsky & another for Interdict

 

Party

 

 

4

Pet: Alphaeus Ngonga for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller

 

 

5

Pet:  Thamer Rashid for Judicial Review

 

Allan McDougall

 

 

6

Pet:  Uchemma Akporobaro for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller

 

 

7

Pet:  Uchemma Akporobaro for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller

 

 

 

 

LORD PENTLAND

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

40 min

Pet:  Robertson Property Limited & others for Judicial Review

 

Morton Fraser

Simpson & Marwick

 

40 min

Pet:  Upland Development Limited for Judicial Review

 

Simpson & Marwick

Morton Fraser

 

 


JUDGE BECKETT, Q.C.

 

UNSTARRED MOTION

 

1

Hanita Sammeroff v Ryanair Limited

 

Digby Brown

 

 

2

Sharon McGeever (AP) v Maureen Nicol

 

Beveridge & Kellas

 

 

 

 

LORD

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

20 min

Pamela Leman v The Highland Council

 

Digby Brown

Ledingham Chalmers

 

30 min

Anne Rudge v East Lothian Council

 

Russel + Aitken

Ledingham Chalmers

 

30 min

Colin Macrae v Hugh Macrae & Company

Thompsons

Dundas & Wilson

 

 

 

 

 

 

________________________
OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

LADY SMITH - K. O’Hare, Clerk

 

Friday 18th May

 

By Order

 

1

F144/06 Victoria McEleney v Mark McEleney

 

SKO

 

Beveridge & Kellas

 

 

 

LORD BRODIE - L. Sexto/I. Martin, Clerks

Friday 18th May

 

By Order

 

1

A750/07 Keith Bennetto v James Wallace &c

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

Campbell Smith LLP

 

 

 

LORD HODGE - D. Morrison, Clerk

 

Friday 18th May

 

Continued Motion

Between 9.00am and 10.00am

 

1

P229/12 Note: P Clark &c re Rangers Football Club Plc

 

Biggart Baillie LLP

Burness LLP

 

 


LORD UIST - P. Weir, Clerk

 

Friday 18th May

 

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.10(3)

 

1

PD1146/11 Patrick Doogan v Stuart Stevenson

 

Digby Brown LLP

Harper MacLeod LLP

 

 

 

 

LORD PENTLAND - C. Fyffe, Clerk

 

Friday 18th May

 

By Order

at 10.00am

 

1

P1108/09 Pet: Lorraine Kennedy for sequestration of estates/appoint judicial factor

 

Russel + Aitken

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.10(3)

 

1

PD1143/11 Marie Tillier v Fife Scottish Omnibuses Ltd

 

Bonnar & Co

Morisons LLP

 

 

 

LORD BANNATYNE - C. Reid, Clerk

 

Friday 18th May

 

By Order

 

1

A242/11 Anthony McElvogue v Michael Darus

 

McKay & Norwell

Andersons Solicitors LLP

 

 


JUDGE BECKETT, Q.C. - C. Stark, Clerk

 

Friday 18th May

 

By Order

In terms of Rule of Court 313(9)

 

1

PD1170/11 Brian Hubbocks v Advocate General

 

Bonnar & Co

Morton Fraser LLP

 

 

 

TO BE ALLOCATED

 

 

Friday 18th May

 

First Hearing

 

1

P239/12  Pet:  Rui Bai for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller

 

 

1

 

P233/12  Pet:  Thamer Rashid for Judicial Review

 

Allan McDougall

 

 

 

1

P238/12 Pet: Stella Adu for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

Procedure Roll

 

1

A759/08 Patrick Conroy v Greater Glasgow Health Board

 

Thompsons

R F McDonald

 

First Hearing

 

1

P484/12 Pet:  TP Order re Child Abduction

 

Wright & Crawford

 

 

 


Continued First Hearing

 

1

P140/12 Pet: James Stevenson for Judicial Review

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

Scottish Government

 

 

__________________

 

 

 

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

SECOND DIVISION

 

 

Friday 18th May

 

Summary Roll (1 day)

 

1

XA96/11 Appeal from the Sheriffdom of Lothian & Borders at Edinburgh in the cause Prim Singh v Brian Napier

 

Party

HBM Sayers

 

 

 

FIRST EXTRA DIVISION

 

Friday 18th May

 

Starred Single Bill

At 10.00am

 

1

XA99/10 Appeal from the Sheriffdom of Lothian & Borders at in the cause Prim Singh v Ian Truscott

 

Party

Simpson & Marwick

 

 


HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY

 

 

CRIMINAL ADVISING ROLLS

 

Friday 18th May

 

APPEAL CONVICTION

at 10.00am

 

JB v HM Advocate

 

 

 

NOTE OF APPEAL

at 10.00am

 

Raymond Jude v HM Advocate

 

 

 

NOTE OF APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION

at 10.00am

 

Robert Murphy v HMA

 

 

 

__________________