Issue 141 Tuesday 20th March
C O N T E
N T S
|
|
Page No. |
|
|
|
|
2 6 |
|
|
7 9 |
|
|
10 |
|
|
10 13 |
|
|
14 17 |
|
|
18 |
The
following motions were granted, unopposed, on Monday 19th March
2012.
|
A722/07
Margaret Gibbons-Loveday v Fife Acute Hospitals |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
A570/11
Alun Grassick &c v RS Hill (Joiners & Building Con) |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
A137/09
Helen McGlone v NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Board |
RF
Macdonald |
|
|
A1804/03
Stewart Milne Group Ltd v WSP North Ltd |
CMS
Cameron McKenna (Scotland) LLP |
|
|
A518/11
Catherine Wills &c v Colin Whittle &c |
CMS
Cameron McKenna (Scotland) LLP |
|
|
A519/11
Catherine Wills &c v Colin Whittle &c |
CMS
Cameron McKenna (Scotland) LLP |
|
|
PD1723/11
Kim Allardyce v Ageas Insurance Ltd |
Andersons
Solicitors LLP |
|
|
PD2041/11
Peter Bannan v Hill Hire Plc |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD468/11
Com Bradley v High Scott &c |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1144/11
Harold Clive v Robert Waugh |
Gonnar
& Co |
|
|
PD52/12
Peter Ednie v R Todd & Co ltd |
Lawford
Kidd |
|
|
PD1210/11
Brian Ewan v Frank Burnett Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD6/12
Alison Gifford v NHS Shetland |
NHS
Scotland Central Legal Office |
|
|
PD523/11
James Goodman v Sidlaw Group Ltd &c |
Lawford
Kidd |
|
|
PD2378/11
Kenneth Hay v Clyde Fasteners Ltd |
Morisons
LLP |
|
|
PD2415/11
Linda Henderson v Scott Adams |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD247/12
James Hood v Advocate General |
Russell
Jones & Walker |
|
|
PD822/11
Alison Hunter v Bydand Leisure Ltd |
Watermans
Solicitors |
|
|
PD33/12
Janet Kerrigan v Home Retail Group Plc |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2442/11
Karin Kinnaird v Stephen Maginnis &c |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD2308/11
Heidi Macdonald v Lifescan Scotland Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD811/11
George Marshall v Halliburton |
Lefevre
Litigation |
|
|
PD2543/11
Peter McClean v Gemma McCoag |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD266/12
Carla McInroy v Tayside Health Board |
Anderson
Strathern |
|
|
PD1663/11
Scott McKerchar v Hamdani Motors Ltd |
Russell
Jones & Walker |
|
|
PD815/11
John McNamee v Lightbody Group Ltd |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
|
PD1125/11
Gavin Miller v Jennifer Kirk |
Russell
Jones & Walker |
|
|
PD1740/10
Christopher Muldoon v TQR Ltd |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD245/12
John Murray v Insurepair (Glasgow) Ltd |
Russel
& Aitken LLP |
|
|
PD1900/11
William Orr v TMS Motor Spares Ltd |
Brodies
LLP |
|
|
PD2264/11
Paul Singh v Zurich Insurance Plc |
Russel
& Aitken LLP |
|
|
PD1580/11
Georgina Steed v Lee Mullen &c |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD2429/11
William Stevenson v Wyvern Structures Ltd &c |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1715/11
Jennifer Turner v Wm Morrison Supermarkets Plc |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD1624/08
Andrea Webster v Henkel Ltd |
Digby
Brown LLP |
|
|
PD191/12
Jennifer Whent v Katherine Russell |
HBM
Sayers |
|
|
PD2069/11
Tuesday Wilkinson v John MacPherson |
Andersons
Solicitors LLP |
|
|
PD36/07
Robert Hamilton v Imperial Chemical Industries Plc |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2599/11
David Lindsay v Strathclyde Fire & Rescue |
Thompsons |
|
|
A437/07
Michael Leahy v Dumbarton Health Centre &c |
Thompsons |
|
|
A543/10
David MacIntyre v Morman Mackay |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
F45/11
Craig Mitchell v Holly Mitchell |
Allan
McDougall |
|
|
PD1520/11
Mantai Ho v Ian Mackinnon |
Digby
Brown |
|
|
PD3011/10
Hannah Leckie &c v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2350/11
Pauline Miller v Ageas Insurance Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1833/11
Janet Milligan v Mackays Stores Group Ltd |
Aitken
Nairn |
|
|
F60/10
Harriet Lenman Paul Crockatt |
Balfour
+ Manson |
|
|
A206/10
Keith Day v Highway Insurance Co Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
A392/11
Israel Discount Bank Ltd v CW Surveyors, t/a Clarke Wilson |
bto |
|
|
A570/91
Valerie Jardin v Tayside Health Board |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
|
PD2377/11
John Allen v Freightroute Ltd |
Digby
Brown |
|
|
PD163/11
Rosemary Hutchison v Thomas McCall |
Digby
Brown |
|
|
PD1564/11
Hazel McFarlane v Service Insurance Co Ltd |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1667/11
Lorraine Shaw v Direct Line Insurance Plc |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD1667/11
Lorraine Shaw v Direct Line Insurance Plc |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD109/11
Frank Stubberfield v Scottish Power UK Plc &c |
Thompsons |
|
|
PD2821/10
Helen Wark v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders Ltd &c |
Thompsons |
|
_______________
CALLING
LIST
Tuesday 20th
March
|
1 |
Clifford Robert Bull, 7 Old Glasgow Road,
Stewarton AG Stewart Bell, 19 Whitelee Gate, Newton Mearns |
HBJ Claim Solutions |
|
2 |
Angela Marie Ellis, 1 Ravelston Road, Bearsden,
Glasgow AG Amlin UK Ltd, t/a Summit at Lloyds, St Helens, 1 Undershaft,
London |
Thompsons |
|
3 |
Brigida Fairnie, 21 Campiew Road, Crossing
Gates, Musselburgh, East Lothian AG Lothian NHS Board, Waverley Gate, 2-4
Waterloo Place, Edinburgh |
Thompsons |
|
4 |
Jean Irene Menzies Graham, 66 Townhead Road,
Inverurie, Aberdeenshire AG Aberdeen City Council, Marischal College, |
Digby Brown |
|
5 |
Edna Hughes, 52 King Street, Dumfries AG
Dumfries & Galloway Health Board, Crichton Hall, Glencaple Road, Dumfries |
Anderson Strathern |
|
6 |
Douglas William Jameson, 1 Badger Walk,
Broxburn, West Lothian AG C Moffat Electrical Services Ltd, Block 2,
Unit 2 Victoria Industrial Estate, Airdrie, North Lanarkshire &c |
Thompsons |
|
7 |
David Jenkins, 11 Morris Street, Greenock AG
Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Plc, St Marks Court, Chart Way, Horsham,
West Sussex |
Thompsons |
|
8 |
Helen Kane, 16 Mooreland Gardens, Addiewell,
West Lothian AG West Lothian Council, West Lothian Civic Centre, Howden South
Road, Livingston, West Lothian |
Thompsons |
|
9 |
John Kelly, 11 Endrick Wynd, Helensburgh,
Dunbartonshire AG Babcock Marine (Clyde) Ltd, Rosyth Business Park, Rosyth,
Dunfermline, |
Thompsons |
|
10 |
Patrick McMahon, 45 Melbourne Avenue,
Clydebank AG Robert Kane, 1 Jagger Gardens, |
HBJ Claim Solutions |
|
11 |
Elizabeth Mayne, 5/1 Calder Gardens, Edinburgh
AG The City of Edinburgh Council, City Chambers, |
Digby Brown |
|
12 |
Liam Means, 24 Specklewood Court, Dundee AG
Discovery Flexibles Ltd, Kemback Street |
Allan McDougall |
|
13 |
Alan Middleton, 9 Kingdom Caravan Park, Pitteuchar,
Glenrothes, Fife AG Colin Mainds, Mapleview, Golf Course Road, Whiting Bay,
Arran &c |
Gillespie Macandrew |
|
14 |
Motor Components , LLC, Elmira Heights,
NY14903, New York, United States of America &c AG Craig Walker, 47 Moss
Side Road, Cowdenbeath |
Burness LLP |
|
15 |
James Murie, 140 Culduthel Park &c AG Hugh
Thom, 15 Ardgith Road, Ellon, Aberdeenshire |
Digby Brown |
|
16 |
National House Building Council, NHBC House,
Davy Avenue, Knowlhill AG David John Allison, 130 Irvine Road, Largs,
Ayrshire &c |
Tods Murray LLP |
|
17 |
Sarah Patrick, 23 Mid Barrwood Road, Kilsyth,
Glasgow AG Craig McCallion, |
Digby Brown |
|
18 |
Tommaso Pia, 32 Christiemiller Avenue,
Edinburgh AG QBE Insurance (Europe) Ltd, Plantation Place, |
Digby Brown |
|
19 |
Ian David Russell, 71 Charles Street,
Penicuik, Midlothian AG Colin Mainds, Mapleview Golf Course Road, Whiting
Bay, Arran, &c |
Gillespie Macandrew |
|
20 |
Catherine Scott, 117 North Grange Avenue,
Prestonpans, East Lothian AG Southern Cross Home Properties Ltd, 47A Drummohr
Gardens, Wallyford, East Lothian |
Digby Brown |
|
21 |
Atlanta Smith, 20 Harbour Street, Boddam,
Peterhead AG Paul Smith, 20 Harbour Street, Boddam, Peterhead |
Balfour + Manson LLP |
|
22 |
James Hamilton Sneddon, 31 Sutherness Drive,
Parkview Estate, Glasgow AG Somewatch Ltd, 9 The Square, Stockley Park,
Uxbridge, Middlesex &c |
Allan McDougall |
|
23 |
David Thoms, 29 Forfar Road, Dundee AG Day
International (UK) Ltd, 15a Old Glamis Road, |
Digby Brown |
|
24 |
Kenneth Thomson, 14 Wishaw Low Road, Clelland,
Motherwell AG Liverpool Victoria Insurance Co Ltd, County Gates, |
Thompsons |
|
25 |
Elizabeth Wallace, 19 Foyers Crescent,
Springburn, Glasgow AG The University of Glasgow, |
Thompsons |
|
26 |
Anthony Wiggall, 55 Pinewood Park Deans, Livingston,
West Lothian AG West Lothian Council, West Lothian Civic Centre, Howden South
Road, Livingston, West Lothian |
Thompsons |
_______________
FIRST
DIVISION
INNER
HOUSE STARRED MOTION
at
|
1 |
West Lothian Council for permanence order HR
re PR |
Morton Fraser |
Drummond Miller |
|
PETITION
DEPARTMENT
UNSTARRED
MOTION
|
1 |
Note: B
Nimmo for orders re Scotpigs Ltd |
Maclay Murray & Spens LLP |
|
|
LORD HODGE
PETITION
DEPARTMENT
UNSTARRED
MOTION
|
1 |
Pet:
Peter Scott & Co Ltd to approve accounts |
Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP |
|
|
LORD
GLENNIE
Wednesday 21st
March
Judgment
(No
appearance of Counsel necessary)
P1344/11 RM for Judicial
Review
Drummond Miller Office
of the Advocate General
LADY CLARK
OF CALTON
STARRED
MOTION
|
25mins |
David Clark v Forth Valley Health Board |
Campbell Smith WS LLP |
|
|
UNSTARRED
MOTIONS
|
1 |
Note:
Andrew Baillie &c for recall restraint order |
COPFS |
|
|
|
2 |
Pet:
Mbulaiteye Kirya for judicial review |
Office of the Advocate General |
|
|
|
3 |
Pet:
David McLaughlan for suspension and interdict |
Civil Legal Assistance Office |
|
|
|
4 |
Note: Martin
Wilson for recall of registration of rest order |
COPFS |
|
|
LORD
BRAILSFORD
STARRED
MOTION
|
25mins |
Bettina Breitenbuchwer v Cornelia Wittke |
Maclay Murray & Spens |
Party |
|
LORD
MATTHEWS
Wednesday 21st
March
Judgment
(No
appearance of Counsel necessary)
A579/10 David Smith v
James Crombie &c
Lindsays HBJ Gateley
LORD
STARRED
MOTION
|
30mins |
Joan Pentland-Clark v Patrick Wilson &c |
Party |
Thorntons Law |
Balfour + Manson LLP |
LORD
STARRED
MOTIONS
|
1hr |
David Hamilton v Donald Farmer |
Maclay Murray & Spens |
Simpson & Marwick |
|
|
30mins |
Ronald Maxwell v Lothian Health Board |
Allan McDougall |
|
|
|
30mins |
Allan Herd v Scottish Ambulance Service |
Digby Brown |
|
|
_______________
LORD
MENZIES L McNamara/DJ Morrison, Clerk
Thursday 22nd
March
Preliminary
Hearing
At
|
1 |
CA12/12
Simon Hutchison v Lynsey McLean |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
Drummond
Miller LLP |
|
Procedural
Hearing
Between
10am and
|
1 |
CA32/10
Prosafe Offshore Ltd v Ronald Young |
Paull
& Williamsons LLP |
Maclay
Murray & Spens LLP |
|
LORD HODGE
DJ Morrison, Clerk
Thursday 22nd
March
Preliminary
Hearing
At
|
1 |
CA7/12
Calgacus Capital Ltd v Irish Bank Resolution Corp Ltd |
McGrigors
LLP |
Burness
LLP |
|
By Order
At
|
1 |
A584/08
Eliot Swan v Lanarkshire Health Board |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
RF
Macdonald |
|
LORD
GLENNIE Luz Sexto, Clerk
Thursday 22nd
March
FAMILY
ACTION
In terms
of Rule
|
1 |
F24/11
Aveen Hassan v Taha Hassan |
Mowat
Hall Dick |
Drummond
Miller |
|
LADY CLARK
OF CALTON L. McNamara, Clerk
Thursday 22nd
March
FAMILY
ACTION
In terms
of Rule
|
1 |
F10/12
Cheryl Kelly v John Kelly |
Stuart
& Stuart |
Blacklocks |
|
LORD
MALCOLM K Todd, Clerk
By Order
At
|
1 |
A584/11
Gleneagles Hotel Ltd v Gleneagles Conservatories Ltd |
Dundas
& Wilson |
Shepherd
& Wedderburn |
|
LORD
PENTLAND C Fyffe, Clerk
Thursday 22nd
March
By Order
|
1 |
XA124/11
Dawn Developments Ltd against a decision of the Scottish Ministers |
McGrigors
LLP |
Brodies
LLP |
SGLD |
|
|
|
Simpson
& Marwick |
Tods
Murray LLP |
|
|
2 |
PD413/08
Grant Davidson v Meriden Logistics Ltd &c |
Andersons
Solicitors LLP |
Simpson
& Marwick |
bto |
JUDGE
WISE, Q.C., - C Stark, Clerk
Thursday 22nd
March
PERSONAL
INJURY ACTIONS
Cases
calling By Order in terms of Rule of Court 43.6(7)
|
1 |
PD2119/11
Joyce Miles v City of Edinburgh Council |
Russell
Jones & Walker |
City
of Edinburgh Council |
|
TO BE
ALLOCATED
Thursday 22nd
March
Debate on Petition
& Answers
|
2 |
P386/11 Pet:
Scottish Ministers for Recovery Ord re Zeenat Mohammed |
Civil Recovery Unit |
Blacklocks |
Party Litigant |
Hearing
|
1 |
P85/12
Oluwanife Rotimi for judicial review |
Drummond
Miller |
Office
of the Advocate General |
|
Continued
Hearing
|
2 |
P32/11 Pet:
Susan Sneddon for Judicial Review |
Gillespie MacAndrew |
Lindsays |
|
By Order
At
|
1 |
A138/09
Doris Small v Dr John Pope |
Brodies
LLP |
bto |
|
SECOND DIVISION
Thursday 22nd
March
By Order
At
|
|
XA107/10
Salvesen v |
Gillespie
Macandrew |
Balfour
+ Manson LLP |
SGLD |
Summar
Roll (2 days)
|
|
XA137/11
Assessor for Lanarkshire v Telereal Trillium |
Morton
Fraser |
Simpson
& Marwick |
|
_______________