Issue: 95 Monday 16^th January 2012

C O N T E N T S

	Page No.
Erratum	2
Unopposed Motions	3 – 9
Single Bills & Inner House Motions	10
Starred and Unstarred Motions	11 – 13
Outer House Rolls	14 – 17
Inner House Rolls	17 - 18

E R R A T U M

The case noted below should not have called on 12 January 2012.

Robert Hannigan, 3 Circus Gardens, Edinburgh AG Tie Limited, City Chambers , High Street, Edinburgh

_______________
UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on Friday 13^th January 2012.

A742/10 Abdul Aziz v R & R Mearns &c	Brechin Tindal Oatts
A654/10 Alan Campbell &c v NHS 24	Anderson Strathern LLP
A590/11 Catherine Gilbert v Greater Glasgow & Clyde NHS Board	Balfour + Manson LLP
A548/11 William Irvine &c v Marshall Wilson Law Group Ltd &c	Russel & Aitken LLP
A842/08 Joan Johnston v BMI Health Care Ltd	Allan McDougall
A16/11 Leslie Cameron v Advocate General	Balfour + Manson LLP
A419/10 Lillian Mayne v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A392/10 John McLaren v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A157/94 Julie McLean v Argyll & Clyde NHS Trust	Lindsays
A391/10 Kathleen McMahon v Merck & Co	Burness LLP
A381/10 Leslie Miles v Merck &Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A400/10 Margaret Milne v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A403/10 June Moffat Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A402/10 Robert Mooney v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A404/10 Helen Morrison v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A264/11 Paul Motion &c v William Binnie &c	Thorntons Law LLP
A420/10 Robert Murray v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A421/10 Alice Neill v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A422/10 Ann Page v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A401/10 Patricia Pinterich v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A423/10 Catherine Preston v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A424/10 Donald Reid v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A399/10 Robert Rendall v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A256/10 Ronald Richards v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie LLP
A425/10 Charles Robertson v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A426/10 William Robertson v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A428/10 Ross Rutherford v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A287/10 Annie Sandilands v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie LLP
A487/10 Mary Shaw &c v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie LLP
A429/10 James Shearer v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A431/10 Robert Stark v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A285/10 Alastair Strang v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie LLP
A283/10 John Swan v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie LLP
PD1987/11 Janice Benson v Tradex Insurance Co Ltd	Digby Brown LLP
PD316/11 Alasdair Bush v Carrillion Construction &c	Glasgow City Council
PD2409/11 Dougie Caines v Donna Thomson &c	Brodies LLP
PD138/11 John Collins v AXA France Iard	Digby Brown LLP
PD32/11 Alexander Cram v Acromas Insurance Co Ltd	Ledingham Chalmers LLP
PD436/11 Lisa Docherty v East Park School, t/a East Park	Balfour + Manson LLP
PD1164/11 Charles Grindlay v Topps Tiles Plc	Digby Brown LLP
PD742/09 Carolann Hardie v Michael Patter &c	Anderson Solicitors LLP
PD1864/11 Deirdre Hart v City of Edinburgh Council	City of Edinburgh Council
PD2084/11 William Logan v Greentower Farms Ltd	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD278/11 Jaqueline Matthews v Aviva Insurance UK Ltd &c	Lefevre Litigation
PD76/11 Robert Mitchell v Mahle Engine Systems UK Ltd	Lefevre Litigation
PD2973/10 Stuart Morris v Arnold Clark Automobiles Ltd	Allan McDougall
PD2716/09 Philip Morrison v Sajad Assadi &c	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD2046/10 Harry Old v Tayside Contracts	Allan McDougall
PD3126/10 Ian Prott v Jonathan Mackenzie	Thompsons
PD2063/11 Hazel Ralston v Ark Housing Association Ltd	Digby Brown LLP
PD2423/10 William Richmond v NSD Realisations Ltd	Andersons Solicitors
PD924/11 Ben Robertson v North East Stevedoring Co Ltd	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD1550/10 Marion Sharkey v Steven Barrie &c	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD2074/11 Craig Sinclair v Jonathan Voigt &c	Biggart Baillie LLP
PD265/11 Gary Smith v Dumfries & Galloway Council	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD451/11 Dan Travis v The Royal Lyceum Theatre	Brechin Tindal Oatts
PD1988/11 Martyn Tunstall v John Cox	Digby Brown LLP
PD2089/11 Karen Wall &c v John Pickthall	Thorntons Law LLP
PD2108/11 Mark Watson v Link Logistics (Scotland) Ltd	Brechin Tindal Oatts
A534/10 George White v George White &c	Lindsays
F41/11 Margarita Crighton v Alan Crighton	Turcan Connell
PD1240/09 Duncan Campbell v East Ayrshire Council	Thompsons
PD2120/10 Raymond Dickson v Prescot (No. 1) Ltd	Thompsons
PD2210/11 James Docherty v Lithgows Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD941/11 Walter Donald v Caledonian Logistics Ltd	Thompsons
PD2181/11 Mark Garvey v Norbord Ltd	Thompsons
PD540/10 John Lynn v Joseph Leckie & Sons Ltd	Thompsons
PD2477/10 Martin McGrory v Reigart Contracts Ltd	Thompsons
PD1834/11 Graham McNee v Chivas Bros Ltd	Digby Brown LLP
PD508/11 Andrew McWilliams v Equity Syndicate Management Ltd	Thompsons
PD1668/11 Robert Saunders v The Board of Trustees National Museums	Thompsons
PD2821/10 Helen Wark v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD85/11 Robert Wilkin v Lithgows Ltd &c	Thompsons
A643/10 Martin Nicolson v NES Engineering Ltd	Russel & Aitken LLP
A644/10 Steven Nicolson v NES Engineering Ltd	Russel & Aitken LLP
PD1722/10 Helen Campbell &c v William Mortimer	Digby Brown LLP
PD332/11 Wilma Cunningham &c v Cartsburn Investments &c	Thompsons
PD2368/11 Margaret Easton v Direct Line Insurance Plc	Brodies LLP
PD1183/11 Desmond Henderson v Alexander Dennis Ltd	HBM Sayers
PD2567/11 Cecil McIntosh v Pelikan Hardcopy Scotland Ltd	Thompsons
PD167/11 Albert Moore v BIS Salamis (M&I) Ltd &c	Digby Brown LLP
PD1975/11 Karen Stewart v Direct Line Insurance Plc	Harper MacLeod
PD1603/11 Ella Byers v Lothian NHS Board	Thompsons
PD2294/10 Heather Gillespie v JFF Realisations	Thorntons Law LLP
PD2954/09 Sandra Graham v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd	Balfour + Manson LLP
PD1591/11 Raymond Ibison v Burnsmith Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD1150/11 Amanda Kopel v Stewart Winter &c	Digby Brown LLP
PD2138/11 Katherine Mitchell &c v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders Ltd	Thompsons
PD2127/11 David Moncrieff v ADT Fire & Security Plc	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD2534/11 Shona Will v McDonalds Restaurant Ltd	Thompsons
PD299/11 Alexander Williams v First Scotrail Ltd	Thompsons
A527/10 EFH Technologies Ltd &c v Rythium Technology FZC TR	Morisons LLP
A759/10 Abdul Majeed v Mahmood Rahman &c	Flexlaw Solicitors
PD154/11 Keith Ross v Charles Bradley	Digby Brown LLP

_______________
Tuesday 17^th January

SINGLE BILLS

SECOND DIVISION

1	Mei Ying Chen for leave to appeal The Upper Tribunal (AIT)	Drummond Miller LLP
*2	Mathew Henderson v Foxworth Investments Ltd &c	Burness	Halliday Campbell
3	Douglas Saunderson for leave to appeal Upper Tribunal	Office of the Advocate General

Inner House Motion

4	Josephine Cannon against a decision of the Add Supports Needs Tribunal	Party
5	Edinburgh City Council for leave to appeal decision of EAT	City of Edinburgh Council

EXTRA DIVISION

Tuesday 17^th January

Advising

(No appearance of Counsel necessary)

East Lothian Council for permanence order

Allan McDougall

Bonar Mackenzie

LADY SMITH

STARRED MOTION

30mins

David Kirkham v James McDonald &c

Brodies

Party

UNSTARRED MOTION

1

Brian Daly v Sister Bernard Mary Murray

Simpson & Marwick

LORD HODGE

STARRED MOTIONS

15mins	Martin Bain v The Rangers Football Club Plc	Balfour + Manson LLP	Anderson Strathern
30mins	Wilmington Trust Co v Rolls Royce Plc	Maclay Murray & Spens	Biggart Baillie

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTION

1

Pet: John Ross for orders re Keltec Petroleum Services Limited

Ledingham Chalmers

LADY CLARK OF CALTON

Tuesday 17^th January

By Order

1

P1382/11 Pet: AT for enforcement of Resident Order

Sheehan Kelsey Oswald

LORD BRAILSFORD

PETITION DEPARTMENT

CONTINUED MOTION

1

Pet: Joyce Paterson for suspension and interdict

MBM Commercial LLP

LORD MALCOLM

STARRED MOTION

15mins

Bryce Lithgow v John Clarkson Plumbers Ltd

Digby Brown

LORD TYRE

UNSTARRED MOTION

1

Carla Rea &c v D J Falls & Co

HBM Sayers

LORD STEWART

PETITION DEPARTMENT

STARRED MOTION

20mins

Malcolm MacKinnan v Pamela MacKinnon

Morton Fraser

Anderson Strathern

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Pet: Amir Beroghani for Judicial Review	Office of the Advocate General
2	Pet: Jumoke Babatunde for Judicial Review	Drummond Miller LLP
3	Pet: Muhammad Baseer for Judicial Review	Drummond Miller LLP
4	Pet: Reza Mohammadi for Judicial Review	Drummond Miller

LORD

STARRED MOTION

1hr

Thomas Kaney v Cape Insulation Ltd

Thompsons

Brodies LLP

_______________

OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

LORD MENZIES – L McNamara, Clerk

Wednesday 18^th January

Continued Preliminary Hearing

1

CA133/11 Morston Whitecross Ltd v Falkirk Council

Morton Fraser

Brodies LLP

LADY SMITH – Z Conway, Clerk

Wednesday 18^th January

By Order

At 10.00am

1	A611/09 Patricia Anderson v Shetland Islands Council &c	Bonnar Mackenzie	HBM Sayers	Ledingham Chalmers
2	PD1124/11 Colin Brown v City Link Ltd	Balfour + Manson LLP	Simpson & Marwick

LORD HODGE – D Morrison Clerk

Wednesday 18^th January

By Order

Between 9.00am and 9.30am

1

P1394/11 Pet: Medical and Professional Financial Management Ltd Admin

McClure Naismith

LORD GLENNIE – C Richardson, Clerk

Wednesday 18^th January

By Order

1	PD1045/11 Peter Dunlop v Persimmon Homes (West Scotland) Ltd &c	Digby Brown	Simpson & Marwick
2	PD1740/10 Christopher Muldoon v T W R Ltd	Thompsons	HBM Sayers
3	A72/11Alison Foley v Furniture Property No 1 Ltd	Allan McDougall & Co, SSC	HBM Sayers

LADY CLARK OF CALTON – A Corr, Clerk

Wednesday 18^th January

By Order

1

A265/11 Susan Thain v Grampian Health Board

Allan McDougall & Co, SSC

R F McDonald

LORD MALCOLM – K Todd, Clerk

Wednesday 18^th January

Preliminary Hearing

Between 9.30am and 10.00am

1

CA149/11 Royal Bank of Scotland plc v James O’Donnell &c

HBJ Gateley Wareing (Scotland) LLP

MBM Commercial

LORD TYRE – L Sexto, Clerk

Wednesday 18^th January

By Order

1

A50/10 Scottish Water v Scottish & Southern Energy plc

bto

Anderson Strathern LLP

TO BE ALLOCATED

Wednesday 18^th January

First Hearing

1	P1363/10 Pet Hassan Mahmud Al-Khatib for judicial review	McGill & Co	Office of the Advocate General
1	P7/11 Pet Adegbemisola Adeleke for judicial review	Drummond Miller	Office of the Advocate General
1	P950/10 Pet Aamir Hasnain Chaudry for judicial review	Drummond Miller	Office of the Advocate General

Procedure Roll

1	A747/09 Gordon McWilliam v Royal Mail Group Ltd	Brodies LLP	Morton Fraser LLP
1	A226/04 Carla Rea &c v D J Falls & Co	Party	HBM Sayers

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

FIRST DIVISION

Wednesday 18^th January

By Order

At 10.00am

1

CA115/10 Reclaiming motion - Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland v Lloyds Banking Group plc

Simpson & Marwick

Maclay Murray & Spens

By Order

At 10.30am

1	XA45/11 Appeal under Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 by South Lanarkshire Council against a decision of The Scottish Information Commissioner	Simpson & Marwick	Anderson Strathern LLP
2	XA64/11 Appeal by Andrew Sneddonfela for Leave to appeal against a decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal	Morton Fraser	Maclay Murray & Spens

SECOND DIVISION

Wednesday 18^th January

Summar Roll (2 days)

1

CA14/11 Reclaiming motion (Lord Menzies) in the cause Regus (Maxim) Ltd v Bank of Scotland plc

Balfour + Manson LLP

Shepherd & Wedderburn

EXTRA DIVISION

Wednesday 18^th January

Judgment

(No appearance of Counsel necessary)

XA156/07 Apollo Engineering Ltd (in liq) v James Scott Ltd

MacRoberts

_______________