C O N T E N T S

Tuesday 10^th January 2012

Issue No 91

C O N T E N T S



Unopposed Motions
Calling List
Single Bills & Inner House Motions
Starred and Unstarred Motions
Outer House Rolls
Inner House Rolls
High Court of Justiciary

UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on 9^th January 2012

PD2118/11 Jeanette Barr v Inverclyde Council	Thompsons
PD1409/11 David Cowe &c v The National Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Society	Lefevre Litigation
PD1409/11 David Cowe &c v The National Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Society	bto
PD1373/10 Stewart Crilley v Patrick James Christie	Balfour + Manson LLP
PD2136/11 Chloe Evans v Renfrewshire Council	Simpson & Marwick
PD2797/10 Walter Graham v Wood Group Engineering (North Sea)	Drummond Miller
PD2246/11 Thomas Somerville v Craig of Campbelltown Ltd	Digby Brown
PD1480/11 Jane Stephenson &c v Meridian Shipping Svs Pte Ltd &c	Drummond Miller
A221/11 Maureen Leslie v Rupinder Jain	Cannons Law LLP
PD2083/10 Agnes Armstrong v Cape Building Products Ltd	Thompsons
PD2897/10 Kevin Beattie v June McCrum	Digby Brown
PD2817/10 Catherine Black v Glasgow City Council	Digby Brown
PD2144/08 William Duncanson v Harland & Wolff Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD1780/11 Dermott Egan v Greater Glasgow Health Board	RF Macdonald
PD2101/10 Donald Fullarton v Cartsburn Investments Ltd	Thompsons
PD2731/10 Andrzej Krafcyzk v AXA Insurance UK Plc	Thompsons
PD3011/10 Hannah Leckie &c v UCS	Simpson & Marwick
PD3011/10 Hannah Leckie &c v UCS	Thompsons
PD2114/11 Stuart Macaskill v Victoria Sinclair &c	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD1713/11 Michael Orchard v Esure Insurance Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
PD1843/11 Thomas Ritchie v Bibby Distribution Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD2179/11 Angela Swan v Lothian NHS Board	Digby Brown
A355/10 Bridget Addison v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A270/10 Catherine Band v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A517/11 Annabelle Bell v Alliance Medical Ltd	Morton Fraser LLP
A315/10 Rosemary Black v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A318/11 Lyn Blackhall &c v Frank Skiffington &c	Thompsons
A289/10 Elizabeth Bowie &c v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A472/10 David Brumpton &c v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A356/10 David Bryce v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A517/08 Linda Campbell v Lothian NHS Board	Anderson Strathern LLP
A337/10 Anne Cartledge v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A334/10 Edward Chisnal v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A332/10 Hugh Clancy v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A478/10 Margaret Clark &c v Merck & Co &c	Burness LLP
A329/10 Ian Cliffe v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A367/10 Jean Clive v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A366/10 Robert Cochrane v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A340/10 Linda Connolly v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A451/10 Alice Conroy &c v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A452/10 Sandra Dawson &c v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A99/10 Robert Dempster v James Watt Cruickshank	Balfour + Manson LLP
A313/10 Donald Dickson v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A312/10 Christine Donaghey v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A309/10 James Donald v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A307/10 Florence Donnelly v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A272/10 John Forsyth v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A304/10 Grace Fullerton v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A488/10 Robert Galloway &c v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A302/10 Robin Gilmour v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A299/10 William Girvan v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A296/10 Agnes Gordon v Pfizer Inc &c	Biggart Baillie
A347/10 Bernard Guillot v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A276/11 Homebase Ltd v Forrest Developments Ltd &c	The Alistair Dean Law Practice Ltd
A208/10 Malcolm Howat &c v J & E Shepherd &c	Morton Fraser LLP
A765/10 Jacqueline Johnston v Direct Line Insurance	Balfour + Manson LLP
A808/10 Alexander Lauder &c v Messrs A & J Robson &c	Brodies LLP
A450/10 Gordon Love &c v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A477/10 Robert Martin &c v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A396/10 John McCracken &c v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A485/10 Robert Nicol &c v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A449/10 Carolyn Reid &c v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
A349/11 George Steer &c v Carin Schiller or Sykes	Balfour + Manson LLP
A101/10 Desmond Stewart v James Watt Cruickshank	Balfour + Manson LLP
A486/10 Robert Young v Merck & Co Inc &c	Burness LLP
F93/10 Tracey Ellen Rogan v William Houliston	HBJ Gateley (Scotland) LLP
PD1358/11 Mary Beck v Tradewise Insurance Services Ltd	HBM Sayers
PD1171/11 Ronald Chiverton v Rafal Skubij &c	Balfour + Manson LLP
PD1144/11 Harold Clive v Robert Waugh	Brodies LLP
PD2437/11 Claudia Cunningham v CIS General Insurance Ltd	Anderson Strathern LLP
PD2173/11 Grant Dunbar v Neptune Deeptech Symons Ltd	Lawford Kidd
PD1961/11 Michelle Fleming v Tesco Stores Ltd	Thompsons
PD1479/11 Stephen Forrest v Miller Homes Ltd	Thompsons
PD2047/11 Thomas Gardiner v Forth Ports Plc	Allan McDougall & Co, SSC
PD1999/11 Craig Greenhill v Enterprise Plc	Digby Brown
PD2038/11 Douglas Henderson v Fife Council	Digby Brown
PD1865/11 John Hume v The Advocate General &c	Digby Brown
PD1707/11 Cody Jenkins v Michael McCaig	Brodies LLP
PD2757/10 William Kerr v Pfaudler-Balfour Ltd	HBM Sayers
PD986/11 Christine Mayoh v Aviva Insurance Ltd	Thompsons
PD1982/11 Charles McDade v Balfour Beatty Rail Residuary Ltd &c	bto
PD222/11 Diane McGrath (Exec to J McGrath) v Irvine Care Ltd	Thompsons
PD1551/11 Helen McIntosh v Akhtar Hussain &c	Anderson Strathern LLP
PD2998/10 Richard McKeown v Gyplock Ltd &c	Brodies LLP
PD1708/11 Joan McLaughlin v Brenda Jones	Digby Brown
PD1765/11 William McLaughlin v Brenda Jones	Digby Brown
PD2236/11 Robert Milne v Jose Delgado	Harper MacLeod
PD829/11 John Morrison v BAM Nuttall Ltd	HBM Sayers
PD1867/11 Alexander Rankin v Rolls Royce Plc	Thompsons
PD2809/09 Hugh Reilly v Blythswood Shipbuilding Co Ltd &c	Simpson & Marwick
PD2509/10 Mark Sheppard v Sean Quinn	HBJ Gateley (Scotland) LLP
PD1903/11 Felix Smith v George Storrar (Farmers) Ltd	Drummond Miller
PD3110/10 Karen Stewart v The National Farmers Union &c	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD12/11 Kevin Stirton v J K M Property Services Ltd	HBM Sayers
PD1617/08 Lynn Sutherland v Scottish Ambulance Service	Brodies LLP
PD27/11 Margaret Sweeney v West Whitlawburn Community Development Co	Brodies LLP
PD1893/11 Ellen Telford &c v Hiriam Abu-Saleh	Waterman’s Solicitors
PD2245/11 Derek Torrie v Smyth Composites Ltd	Digby Brown

______________

COURT OF SESSION

CALLING LIST

Tuesday 10^th January

Leslie Armstrong, 19 Everest Road, Earlston AG Borders Health Board, Newstead, Melrose

HBJ Gateley (Scotland) LLP

Paul Barclay, 12 Achray Park, Glenrothes AG Ian Thomson Munro, 65 Kinloch Farm, Ladybank, Cupar, Fife

Digby Brown

Dr Linda Mary Boyle, 1 Wildmoosstrasse, 82319 Starnberg, Germany AG Lisa Malone, t/a Equus Riding And Transport, Wards Crossroad, Roseisle, Elgin, Moray

Thorntons Law LLP

Thomas Burns, 1 Shielinghill Place, Crieff, Perthshire AG First Group Plc, a company incorporated registered under the Companies Act and having their Registered Office 395 King Street, Aberdeen

Thompsons

Gary Clifford, 73 Glasgow Road, Muirkirk AG Swallow Design & Store Fitting Ltd, 68 Eastway, Hillend Industrial Estate Park, Dunfermline, Fife

Digby Brown

John Collins, Flat 0/1, 131 Royston Road, Glasgow AG Robert Loudon Builders Ltd (In Liquidation), c/o Colin Murdoch and Donald McNaught, Chartered Accountants, Invocas, James Miller House, 98 West George Street, Glasgow, G2 1PJ, the Joint Liquidators thereof

Digby Brown

William Dailly, 71 Bogside Road, Ashgill, Larkhall AG John N Dunn (Scotland) Ltd, Saltire House, 6B Dunnet Way, East Mains Industrial Esate, Broxburn, West Lothian

Bonnar & Co

Brenda Dalgetty, 19 Forest Bank Court, Crawshawbooth, Rossendale, Lancashire AG Waitrose Ltd, 171 Victoria Street, London, and a place of business in Scotland at 145 Morningside Road, Edinburgh

Russel Jones & Walker

Miss Angela Docherty, 5 Menteith Avenue, Bishopbriggs, Glasgow AG Bar 396 trading as Campus and Campus Sunderland Ltd, 402 Sauchiehall Street, Glasgow

Thompsons

Ian Downie, 6 Hopepark Gardens, Bathgate, West Lothian AG Nuwalls Ltd, Newpark House, Newpark Road, Bellsquarry, Livingston, West Lothian

Lawford Kidd

Lesley Duquemin, 16 Westhouses Road, Mayfield, Dalkeith AG (First) Lightways (Contractors) Ltd, Block C, Lochlands Industrial Estate, Larbert &c

Digby Brown

Michael Alexander Gordon, 3 Broomhill News, Aberdeen AG Subsea 7 (Singapore) PTE Ltd, Southpoint #03-01, 200 Cantonment Road, Singapore

Lefevre Litigation

Allan Grant, 31 Clyde Drive, Craigshill, Livingston, West Lothian AG (First) Co-operative Group Ltd, New Century House, Manchester &c

Thompsons

Daniel Gray, 29 South Street, Mintlaw, Peterhead AG Serina Louise Porter, 30 Crossfolds Crescent, Peterhead, Aberdeenshire

Digby Brown

Alan Grieve, 42 Tyler’s Acre Road, Edinburgh AG Aviva Insurance (UK) Ltd, 8 Surrey Street, Norwich

Thompsons

Alexander Grieve, 3 Solway Place, Glasgow AG John Dewar & Sons Ltd, 1700 London Road, Glasgow

Digby Brown

Linda Grieve, 42 Tyler’s Acre Road, Edinburgh AG Aviva Insurance (UK) Ltd, 8 Surrey Street, Norwich

Thompsons

Michael Leonard, 55 Paisley Road, Renfrew AG The Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park Authority, Carrochan Road, Carrochan, Balloch

Bonnar & Co

Andrew Leslie, 22 Ferryhill, Forres, Morayshire AG the Moray Council, Council Offices, High Street, Elgin

Harper Macleod LLP

Thomas Albert McBride, 16 Inveravon Drive, Motherwell AG C Crimin (Electrical Contractors) Ltd, Tara House, 46 Bath Street, Glasgow

Thompsons

Tracey McGuire, Block 24, Flat 3/1, Swinton Place, Cardonald, Glasgow AG (First) Jean Anderson, 59 Edgam Drive, Cardonald, Glasgow &c

Digby Brown

Ann Miller, 44 Carfin Street, Motherwell, Lanarkshire AG W M Morrison Supermarket Plc, Hilmore House, Gain Lane, Bradford, West Yorkshire

Digby Brown

Nicola Moss, 8 Lytham Close, Standen Gate, Lancaster AG Greater Glasgow & Clyde NHS Board, NHS Greater Glasgow &c

Harper MacLeod

Ali Akbar Najafian, 13 Royal Crescent, Glasgow AG Donald Black Laird, The Murrays, Pathhead, Midlothian

Balfour + Manson LLP

John Neil, 1 St Mungo Place, Hamilton AG (First) British Steel Corporation Ltd, 30 Millbank, London &c

Bonnar & Co

Stephen Reid, 16 Greenbank, Blantyre AG AXA Insurance UK Plc, 5 Old Broad Street, London

Thompsons

Ian Robertson, 4 Maclean Crescent, Alva AG (First) Helen Fraser, Maraig, Alloa Road, Carronshore, &c

Simpson & Marwick

Audrey Corbett Scott, Kilchumein House, Fort Augustus AG Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Plc, St Mark’s Court, Chart Way, Horsham, West Sussex

Thompsons

Sandra Thompson, 32 Blacklands Crescent, Kilwinning, Ayrshire AG Primark Stores Ltd, Unit 46, Rivergate Centre, Irvine

Thompsons

Kim Lauren Martin or Whyte, Strathallan House, Grant Road, Grantown on Spey AG Craig Thomas Whyte, Castle Grant, Grantown on Spey

bto

______________

Wednesday 11^th January

SINGLE BILLS

FIRST DIVISION

Pet: Lord Advocate for Vexatious Lit re James Duff

Office Of The Advocate General

Party

INNER HOUSE MOTION

Abdul Aziz v Gillian Leslie Whannel

Wilson Terris & Co SSC

LORD MENZIES

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTION

Pet: Dunedin Enterprise Invest Trust Plc - Cancel Premium

Dundas & Wilson CS

LORD HODGE

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

Note: Perrin (Goods & Services Glasgow) Ltd for remuneration

bto

Pet: Alexander D Pilmoor as Trustee of Roy Jones for orders

Balfour + Manson LLP

LORD GLENNIE

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Pet: George Campbell for Judicial Review	Office of the Advocate General
2	Pet: Frank Kelly for Judicial Review	Office of the Advocate General
3	Pet: Nabil Leghmara for Judicial Review	Drummond Miller
4	Pet: Olcay Tasci &c for Judicial Review of decision of Upper Tribunal	McGill & Co
5	Pet: James Thomson for Judicial Review	Office of the Advocate General

LADY CLARK OF CALTON

STARRED MOTIONS

15mins

Naghmana Chaudry v West Dunbartonshire Council

Party

15mins

Emily Brewster v ICE Factor Ltd

Thompsons

HBM Sayers

LORD BRAILSFORD

STARRED MOTION

2hrs

David French v Lothian Health Board

Drummond Miller

RF Macdonald

LORD STEWART

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

A412/11 Clydesdale Bank Plc v T Leith Developments &c

HBJ Gateley (Scotland) LLP

A413/11 Clydesdale Bank Plc v T Leith Developments &c

HBJ Gateley (Scotland) LLP

LORD

STARRED MOTIONS

15mins

Rachel MacLeod v Margaret Taylor &c

Digby Brown

Brodies

10mins

Mary Stewart v DP & L Group Ltd &c

HBM Sayers

Brodies

2hrs

John Smyth v Van Oord (UK) Ltd &c

Simpson & Marwick

Brodies

___________________

OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

LORD MENZIES – L. McNamara, Clerk

Thursday 12^th January

Continued Preliminary Hearing

Between 10.30am and 11.00am

CA98/11 Lightways (Contractors) Ltd v North Lanarkshire Council

Biggart Baillie

Simpson & Marwick

Motion

At 11.00am

P1102/11 Note: J Cartwright for order

Dundas & Wilson

Burness LLP

LORD BRODIE - C. Stark/Z Conway, Clerks

Thursday 12^th January

By Order

A542/09 Maria MacDonnell v Alan Finlayson &c

Digby Brown

HBJ Claims Solutions (Scotland) LLP

LORD GLENNIE - C. Truby, Clerk

Thursday 12^th January

Continued Procedural Hearing

At 9.00am

A731/10 Naxos Rights International Ltd v Project Management &c

MacRoberts

Simpson & Marwick

LORD KINCLAVEN

Thursday 12^th January

Judgment

(No appearance of counsel necessary)

P1134/10 AAQ v Secretary of State for the Home Department

Drummond Miller – Office of the Advocate General

LADY CLARK OF CALTON – A. Corr, Clerk

Thursday 12^th January

By Orders

F215/08 George Parker v Jane Parker

Balfour + Manson LLP

Simpson & Marwick

F45/10 Jane Brownlie or Chapman or Parker v George R H Parker

Simpson & Marwick

Balfour + Manson LLP

LORD BRAILSFORD - K. Cumming, Clerk

Thursday 12^th January

By Order

A705/09 Fiona Kirk v Dr Ambigai Jeyabalan

Biggart Baillie

Simpson & Marwick

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling in terms of Rule of Court 43.7(1)(b)

PD1843/11 Thomas Ritchie v Bibby Distribution Ltd &c

Thompsons

Simpson & Marwick

LORD MALCOLM - K. Todd, Clerk

Thursday 12^th January

Preliminary Hearing

Between 9.00am and 9.30am

CA103/11 BNP Paribas Jersey Trust Corp Ltd &c v Watts & Partners

Brodies LLP

Burness LLP

By Order

Between 9.30am and 10.00am

A278/07 Scottish Premier League Ltd v Lisini Pub Management Co Ltd

Harper Macleod

Anderson Fyfe

LORD TYRE – L. Sexto, Clerk

Thursday 12^th January

By Order

A717/10 Gerard Devaney &c v Harvie Diamond &c

Brodies LLP

HBJ Gateley (Scotland) LLP

Maclay Murray & Spens

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling in terms of Rule of Court 43.7(1)(b)

PD1734/11 Josephine Allan v Gary Weightman

Thompsons

Andersons

PD1732/11 Josephine Allan v Gary Weightman

Thompsons

Andersons

PD1733/11 Josephine Allan v Gary Weightman

Thompsons

Andersons

LORD STEWART – C. Richardson, Clerk

Thursday 12^th January

PERSONAL INJURY ACTION

Case calling in terms of Rule of Court 43.7(1)(b)

PD1931/11 Patrick Scully v East Renfrewshire Council

Digby Brown

Reid Cooper

TO BE ALLOCATED

Thursday 12^th January

Continued First Hearing

P443/11 Pet: Howard Wallace &c for Judicial Review

Maclay Murray & Spens

Allan McDougall & Co, SSC

Procedure Roll

2	A582/10 Stuart Devine &c v Kenneth Pattullo &c	Drummond Miller	Simpson & Marwick	Brodies LLP
2	PD903/11 Mary Stewart &c v DP & L Group Ltd &c	HBM Sayers	Brodies LLP	Thorntons Law LLP
2	A104/10 Drumpellier & Mount Vernon Estates Ltd v Mark Me	Brodies LLP	Party
1	A49/10 John MacDonald v Zurich Insurance Company (UK) Limited	Thompsons	Simpson & Marwick

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

FIRST DIVISION

Thursday 12^th January

Summar Roll

XA134/11 Appeal from Sheriffdom of Grampian Highlands & Islands at Aberdeen – in the cause - SS v MS

Simpson & Marwick

Beveridge & Kellas

EXTRA DIVISION

Thursday 12^th January

Procedural Hearing

at 10.00am

PD1795/08 Reclaiming Motion Janette Murphy v East Ayrshire Council

Lefevre Litigation

Andersons Solicitors LLP

Summar Roll (2 days)

XA44/11 Appeal by the Scottish Ministers against a decision of the Mental Health Tribunal

SGLD

Mental Health Tribunal

Murray Beith Murray

__________

HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY

CRIMINAL ADVISING ROLL

Thursday 12^th January

At 10.15am

NOTE OF APPEAL

Ross Junior Millar v HM Advocate

__________