No. 182 – Tuesday 8^th June

C O N T E N T S

Unopposed Motions

Calling List

Single Bills

Starred and Unstarred Motions

Outer House Rolls

Inner House Rolls

High Court of Justiciary

UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on 7^th June 2010

A2957/01 Jeannie McMillan v Alison Nicholls &c	Drummond Miller
A253/09 Sheila McNeill v AXA Corporate Solutions Services UK Ltd	Thompsons
PD712/09 Ashley Bell v Ralph Louden	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD1406/08 Martin Brennan v Digisource GB Ltd &c	Allan McDougall & Co
PD2229/09 Gerard Cavanagh v John Lewis plc	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD1636/08 Edward Galligan v Norwich Union Insurance Ltd &c	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD264/10 Colin Hunter v O-I Manufacturing UK Ltd	Thompsons
PD1386/09 Hazel Johnston v Whyte & Mackay Limited	Allan McDougall & Co
PD1450/09 Tanya Laurenson v EUI Ltd	Thompsons
PD1031/10 Alexander McCormack v Glasgow City Council	Edinburgh City Council
PD669/10 David McNeil v The Chief Constable Strathclyde Police	Digby Brown
PD2885/09 Douglas Moir v Rhu Refractories UK Ltd	Digby Brown
PD314/10 Richard Reynolds v Mitie PFI Ltd	Digby Brown
PD1941/09 Andrew Stevens v Edward Gunn	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD2146/09 Donald Thomson v First Glasgow Ltd	Allan McDougall & Co
PD1159/09 Mark tinker v Balfour Beatty Construction Ltd	Allan McDougall & Co
A422/05 Dem-Master Demolition Ltd v McLay Leonard Ltd	HBJ Gateley Wareing (Scotland) LLP
A750/08 Katherine Hannah v NHS Tayside	Balfour + Manson LLP
A849/08 Raven Highlands Ltd v Thomas Pollock &c	Burness LLP
PD83/09 Kenneth Atkinson v West Lothian Council	Thompsons
PD1350/09 Anthony Christie v Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance plc	Lefevre Litigation
PD2781/09 Alexander Davidson v Burntisland Shipbuilding Co Ltd	Digby Brown
PD1156/09 William Douglas v Stephen House	Allan McDougall & Co
PD701/10 Michelle Duncan v M & D (Leisure) Ltd	Thompsons
PD321/09 Terry Elder v Daniel Macleod &c	Thompsons
PD1989/08 Carol Gibson v Greater Glasgow Health Board	Thompsons
PD2906/09 Steven Howe v CIS General Insurance Ltd	Thompsons
PD2551/09 Ronald Innes v Midlothian Council	Aitken Nairn
PD1111/08 Stanley Lawrence v Odfjell Drilling (UK) Ltd &c	Thompsons
PD998/10 Elizabeth Lochrie v Asda	HBM Sayers
PD1230/10 John McCarney v Carillion Construction (Contracts) Ltd	HBM Sayers
PD1381/08 Carol Morrison &c v Carillion Construction (Contracts)	Thompsons
PD1006/09 Catherine Murray &c v Scottish & Newcastle Ltd	Thompsons
PD2751/09 Patrick O’Donnell v William Denny & Bros Ltd	Thompsons
PD1662/09 Ciaran O;Neill v Fife Council	Thompsons
PD1941/08 George Pollock v John McMillan &c	Digby Brown
PD32/10 Jean Walker &c v Zurich Insurance Co	Simpson & Marwick
A725/04 Richard Ainsworth v City of Edinburgh Council	Simpson & Marwick
A643/06 Stanley Calderwood v Argyll & Clyde Health Board	RF Macdonald
A39/10 Malcolm Cole v Silvermills Estate & Land Ltd &c	Morton Fraser LLP
A845/09 William Corbett v Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance plc	bto
A35/10 Frederick Elder v Grampian Health Board	Morton Fraser
A110/10 Susan Foster v Graeme Henderson	Simpson & Marwick
A279/09 Sharon Gallacher v Greater Glasgow Health Board	RF Macdonald
A167/10 Robert Gracie v Provident Insurance Ltd	Thompsons
A531/09 Alexander Greenless v Allianz Insurance plc	HBM Sayers
A6/10 Hercules Property UK Ltd v Homebase Ltd	bto
A880/09 Roger Jones &c v William Gray &c	Andersons Solicitors LLP
A275/07 Tracey Lee v Greater Glasgow Health Board	Balfour + Manson LLP
A49/10 John Macdonald v Zurich Insurance Co (UK) Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
A102/09 Robert Magee v West Lothian Council	Simpson & Marwick
A107/10 Sinclair McIvor &c v NHS Highland	RF Macdonald
A106/10 Sinclair McIvor v NHS	RF Macdonald
A361/07 Susan Miller v Greater Glasgow Health Board	Balfour + Manson LLP
A457/09 Anne Moore v South Glasgow Uni Hosp NHS Trust	Balfour + Manson LLP
A578/08 Ashley Springthorpe v Martin Amos	Thompsons
A187/05 Supersave Mini Market &c v Walters Holand Ltd	Campbell Smith
F21/10 Evelyn Telfer v Glenn Telfer	McKay & Norwell
PD657/10 Lawrence Beedie v The National Insurance & Guarantee	Brodies LLP
PD371/10 Hillary Brand v Andrew Saint &c	Digby Brown
PD893/09 Alistair Bryce &c v Suzanne Boylan	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD2960/09 Nicola Burns v John McCall	HBM Sayers
PD337/10 Giulia Canata v Douglas McLean &c	Harper Macleod
PD1015/10 John Carrol v HSBC Insurance (UK)	HBM Sayers
PD463/08 Bryan Carroll v Sabre Insurance Co Ltd	Gildeas
PD430/10 David Cooper v Johnson Controls Ltd	Digby Brown
PD467/10 Tony Douchas v Alan Bastien &c	Thompsons
PD366/09 William Drummond v Balfour Beatty Rail Track Systems Ltd	Thompsons
PD2624/09 Clayton Dyck v ISS UK Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
PD962/09 Thomas Fowler v Taylor Wimpey Developments Ltd	Digby Brown
PD2306/09 Hazel Graham v Costcutter Supermarkets Group Ltd	Lawford Kidd
PD1358/09 Douglas Gullan v CRH Fencing Ltd	Bonnar & Co
PD1547/09 Michael Hampsey v Mackenzie Construction Ltd	HBM Sayers, Glasgow
PD2933/09 Philip Hand v Star Roofing Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
PD306/10 Thomas Heron v Spitit Aerosystems (Europe) Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
PD1044/10 Elizabeth Hume v Resource (UK) &c	bto
PD264/10 Colin Hunter v O-I Manufacturing UK Ltd	Thompsons
PD861/09 David Hutcheon v EUI Ltd t/a Elephant.co.uk	Russel & Aitken
PD474/10 Robert Jop v Hochtief (UK) Construction Ltd	Thompsons
PD118/10 Nicholas Keeffe v Arnold Clark Automobiles Ltd	Thompsons
PD2133/09 Gilbert Knox v UK Insurance Ltd	Thompsons
PD2264/09 Eleanor McAleese v Imrie Fruit & Veg &c	HBM Sayers, Glasgow
PD483/10 John McCallum v Bridon Coatbridge Ltd	Thompsons
PD2165/09 John McCrory v Zurich Insurance plc	Thompsons
PD324/10 Siobhan McKinney v Charlotte McLearie &c	Digby Brown
PD1056/10 Richard McMahon v Zurich Insurance plc	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD1705/09 Julie McMurray v DHL Exel Supply Chain Ltd	Shepherd & Wedderburn
PD1412/09 Margaret McNaughtan v Haining Nursing Home Ltd	Digby Brown
PD967/09 June Nichol v South Ayrshire Council	Simpson & Marwick
PD935/09 David Nimmo v Falkirk Council	Digby Brown
PD1907/09 David Purves v John McDonald &c	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD360/10 Guy Putnam v Brit Insurance Ltd	Thompsons
PD1095/10 Graham Robertson v ADG Metalworker Ltd	HBM Sayers
PD2610/09 Peter Ryder v Highland Cuisine Ltd	HBJ Claims Solutions (Scotland) LLP
PD487/10 Keith Silver v AXA Insurance UK plc	Thompsons
PD2649/09 Jennifer Smith v North Ayrshire Council	Simpson & Marwick
PD323/10 Margaret Soutar v Margaret Hume	Simpson & Marwick
PD189/10 Gwen Taylor v Robert Galloway	Digby Brown
PD1143/10 David Thomson v Interfloor Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
PD1671/09 Marion Traill v West Dunbartonshire Council &c	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD2596/09 Martin Turner v HF Electrical Ltd	Andersons Solicitors LLP
PD477/10 Claire Wallace v Admiral Insurance	Thompsons
PD1559/09 Jonathon Watson v Robert	Tods Murray

COURT OF SESSION

CALLING LIST

Tuesday 8^th June

1	The Accountant in Bankruptcy, 1 Pennyburn Road, Kilwinning the permanent trustee on the sequestrated estates of Alexander John Wilson, 76 Westpark Wynd, Dalry AG Ann Osbourne Wilson, 76 Westpark Wynd, Dalry	Harper Macleod
2	Rhona Adam, 121/3 Grange Loan, Edinburgh and others AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
3	Alexandrina Anderson, 9 Colwood Gardens, Glasgow and others AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
4	Apex Speciality Solutions Ltd, Peterseat Drive, Altens Industrial Estate, Aberdeen AG Donna Douglas, 2 Westdyke Walk, Westhill, Aberdeen	bto
5	Bank of Scotland plc, The Mound, Edinburgh AG Belton Pervez, Solicitors, 430 Victoria Road, Glasgow and others	Andersons Solicitors LLP
6	David Brumpton, Birkhill Avenue, Bishopbriggs, Glasgow and others AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
7	William Bryson, Craigmillar, 10 Crosshill Road, Lenzie, Glasgow and others AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
8	Donna Clark, 7 Camp Place, Callander &c v Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
9	Margaret Clark, 29 Sandport Gait, Kinross and others AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
10	Grant Coll, 85 Leithland Road, Glasgow AG Archibald McCorquodale & Son Ltd, 103 Evanton Place, Thornliebank Industrial Estate, Thornliebank, Glasgow	Digby Brown
11	Ann Dunlop, 184 Carnshalloch Avenue, Datna, Ayrshire AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
12	Deborah Elder, 196 Aitken Road, Glenrothes &c AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
13	Alexandra Fisher, 16 Briarbush Crescent, Macmerry, East Lothian AG Lothian Health Board, Deaconess House, 148 Pleasance, Edinburgh	Thompsons
14	Pamela Forbes, 8 Hunterfield Park, Gorebridge &c AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
15	Kathy-Rose Gordon, 14 Cove Gardens, Cove, Aberdeen AG EUI Ltd, t/a Admiral Insurance, Capital tower, Greyfriars Road, Cardiff	Thompsons
16	L Batley Pet Products Ltd, The Barton, North Tawton, Devon AG North Lanarkshire Council, Civic Centre, Motherwell	Balfour + Manson LLP
17	Peter Little, 18 Baxters Gate, Tranent, East Lothian AG Alexander Lyell, 6 Learmonth Terrace, Edinburgh	Andersons Solicitors LLP
18	Susan Macdonald, 33 Gairbraid Terrace, Bargeddie, Glasgow as executor nominate on the estate of the late Robert MacDonald and others AG Co-operative Group Ltd, New Century House, Manchester and another	Thompsons
19	Heather McIntosh, 68 Langshaw Road, Dundee and others AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
20	Brian McKendry, 8 Vernon Bank, East Kilbride AG Upper Clyde Shipbuilders Ltd (in liquidation), 25 Bothwell Street, Glasgow and another	Thompsons
21	Robert Moncrieff Martin, 11 Atholl Crescent, Edinburgh and others AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
22	James Murray, Campdean, 21 Edgehead Road, Edgehead Village AG Midlothian Council, Midlothian House, 40-46 Buccleuch Street, Dalkeith	Thompsons
23	Hugh William Mustard, 1 West Fenton Cottages, North Berwick, East Lothian AG Scottish Power UK plc, 1 Atlantic Quay, Glasgow &c	Thompsons
24	Robert Nicol, 20 Glebe Park Crescent, Cullen and others AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
25	Moira Paterson, 64 Meadow Crescent, New Elgin, Elgin &c v Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
26	Farquhar Ross, Eisland Cottage, Dunphail, Forres AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
27	James Seaman, 92 Hillside Street, Stevenston, Ayrshire AG Acromas Insurance Co Ltd, PO Box 276, Broadstairs, Kent	Thompsons
28	Archie Thomson, 11 Balfour Avenue, Beith, North Ayrshire AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
29	Frieda Valente, 181 Dalmarnock Road, Glasgow AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation
30	Robert Young, 10 Leynam Ct, Rawley Road, Bowthorpe, Norwich, Norfolk AG Merck & Co Inc, 1 Merck Drive, Whitehouse Station, New Jersey 08889, USA &c	Lefevre Litigation

______________

Wednesday 9^th June

SINGLE BILLS

EXTRA DIVISION

1	Farstad Supply AS v Enviroco Ltd	HBJ Gateley Wareing (Scotland) LLP
2	Debbie Williams against a decision of SLCC (leave to appeal)	Anderson Strathern LLP
3	Esther Ramsay v John Gray	Drummond Miller
4	James Cosgrove &c t/a Fisher Tours for leave	Halliday Campbell WS
5	Sahra Ali Elmi against a decision of AIT	Drummond Miller

INNER HOUSE MOTION

1

Royal Bank of Scotland v Mohammed Aslam &c

Party

LORD HODGE

STARRED MOTION

2hrs

Grant Construction Services (Fife) Ltd v Northern Salvage AU

Macroberts

Brodies

LORD GLENNIE

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Note: C Dempster &c for orders under sections 76, 79, 63 re Monitor Prod	Dundas & Wilson
2	Pet: GSL Lift Services Ltd to wind up	HBJ Gateley Wareing (Scotland) LLP
3	Pet: The Point Hotel Ltd to extend administration	Dundas & Wilson CS

LORD BRAILSFORD

UNSTARRED MOTION

1

Ewen Alexander v Skene Investments (Aberdeen) Ltd &c

DLA

LORD MALCOLM

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Note: Andrew McIlquham for recall of restraint order	Crown Office
2	Note: Marshall Ronald for recall of restraint order	Crown Office
3	Pet: Fife Council for section 46 orders	Balfour + Manson LLP
4	Pet: Mahdi Karim for judicial review	Drummond Miller
5	Pet: Michael Quinn for judicial review	Balfour + Manson LLP
6	Pet: Sohail Ahmad for judicial review	Drummond Miller

LORD BANNATYNE

STARRED MOTION

At 9.30am

15mins

Pet: Littleinch Ltd for judicial review

Maclay Murray & Spens

Anderson Strathern

LADY STACEY

STARRED MOTION

25mins

Stephen Thomas v Diageo plc

Bonnar & Co

HBM Sayers

M WISE, Q.C.,

STARRED MOTION

30mins

Boguslaw Wszolek v M MacKenzie Old Pentland

Digby Brown

Anderson Strathern

LORD

STARRED MOTIONS

30mins	David Sharkey v Greater Glasgow Health Board	RF Macdonald	Thompsons
40mins	Marion Traill v West Dunbartonshire Council &c	Thompsons	Andersons Solicitors	Simpson & Marwick
20mins	Steven Truesdale v Vesuvius UK Ltd	Thompsons	Simpson & Marwick
20mins	Derek Ray v Babcock Marine Ltd	Biggart Baillie	Drummond Miller

_____________

OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

LORD HODGE - L. McNamara, Clerk

Thursday 10^th June

By Order

1

CA87/08 Eastford Limited v Thomas Gillespie &c

Semple Fraser

Anderson Fyfe

Procedural Hearing

Between 9.30am and 10am

1	CA92/08 Gary Gillespie v Thomas Gillespie	Semple Fraser	Anderson Fyfe
2	CA143/08 Gary Gillespie v Thomas Gillespie &c	Semple Fraser	Anderson Fyfe
3	CA195/08 Gary Gillespie v Alan Gillespie	Semple Fraser	Anderson Fyfe

Preliminary Hearing

At 10am

CA72/08 Cramaso LLP v Rt Hon Ian Ogilvie-Grant &c

Anderson Strathern LLP

Brodies LLP

LORD GLENNIE - D.J. Morrison, Clerk

Thursday 10^th June

By Order

Between 9am and 9.30am

1	CA127/07 Glasgow Metro LLP v Robertson Construction Central Ltd	Anderson Strathern LLP	Macroberts
2	CA36/07 Robertson Construction Central v Glasgow Metro LLP	Macroberts	Anderson Strathern LLP

By Order

Between 9.30am and 10am

1

CA185/09 Woodford Land Ltd v Bellway Homes Ltd

Harper Macleod

Gillespie Macandrew

Hearing

At 10am

1

P1374/08 Pet: Spring Salmon & Seafood Ltd to restore to Register

Shepherd & Wedderburn

Russel & Aitken

LORD BRAILSFORD - N. Roberts, Clerk

Thursday 10^th June

By Order

1	A792/08 Ewen Alexander v Skene Investments	Ledingham Chalmers	Balfour + Manson LLP	DLA
2	A253/09 Sheila McNeil v AXA Corp Solutions	Thompsons	HBM Sayers, Glasgow
3	A849/08 Raven Highlands v Thomas Pollock	Burness	Currie Gilmour & Co

LADY STACEY - I. Martin, Clerk

Thursday 10^th June

By Order

1	PD1371/09 Thomas Muir v Terex Equipment Ltd	Digby Brown	HBM Sayers, Glasgow
2	PD1805/09 Margaret Mundie v UK Insurance Ltd	Andersons Solicitors LLP	Simpson & Marwick

LORD TYRE

Thursday 10^th June

By Order

A151/08 Kirstie Anderson &c v Dr GB Morrison &c

Balfour + Manson LLP

MDDUS

FAMILY ACTION

In terms of Rule 49 a proof has been allowed in the following action

1

F45/10 Jane Parker v George Parker

Turcan Connell

Balfour + Manson LLP

M WISE, Q.C.,

Thursday 10^th June

FAMILY ACTION

In terms of Rule 49 a proof has been allowed in the following action

1

F34/10 Ghazala Yousal v Yousaf Hussain

Tods Murray

Thorley Stevenson

By Order

1	A563/05 John Clarke v Archibald Grant	Russel + Aitken	Brodies
2	PD1649/09 Sharon Hyland v Annie Thyne &c	Digby Brown	Brodies
3	PD1160/09 Paul McKendrick v Brian Richmond &c	Bonnar & Co	bto

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

Cases calling by order in terms of Rule of Court 43.7(1)(b)

1

PD1338/09 David Murray v Shell UK Ltd &c

Digby Brown

Morton Fraser

TO BE ALLOCATED

Thursday 10^th June

First Hearing

1	P360/10 Pet: Mehrab Razian for Judicial Review	Drummond Miller
1	P407/10 Pet: Darren Crossley for Judicial Review	Drummond Miller	Anderson Strathern LLP

Second Hearing

2

P491/10 Pet: BG for orders re Child Abduction

Bonar Mackenzie

Thorley Stephenson

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

SECOND EXTRA DIVISION

Thursday 10^th June

By Order (Inner House)

1

XA108/08 Appeal under section 11 of the Tribunals & Inquiries Act 1992 by Sheltered Housing Management Ltd v Lands Tribunal Scotland

Balfour + Manson LLP

Paull & Williamsons

_______________

HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY

Thursday 10^th June

At 9.30am

REFERRAL UNDER SECTION 162(B) OF THE PRISONERS AND CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS (SCOTLAND) ACT 1993

HMA v Simon Christopher Stuart (in custody)

Thursday 10^th June

At 10.15am

CRIMINAL ADVISING ROLL

PETITION TO THE NOBILE OFFICIUM

By

Donald Birrell v HM Advocate

Thursday 10^th June

At 10.15am

CRIMINAL ADVISING ROLL

APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION

By

Thomas Robertson Willies v HM Advocate