Issue No187

Monday 9^th June 2008

C O N T E N T S

Unopposed Motions

Single Bills

Starred and Unstarred Motions

Outer House Rolls

Inner House Rolls

High Court of Justiciary

UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on 4^th June 2008 in terms of the Pilot Scheme intimated on the Rolls of Court on Thursday 8^th February 2007

PD1136/07 Margaret Imrie v Murray Paterson

Anderson Strathern

Simpson & Marwick

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on 5^th June 2008 in terms of the Pilot Scheme intimated on the Rolls of Court on Thursday 8^th February 2007

PD1136/07 Margaret Imrie v Murray Paterson	Anderson Strathern	Simpson & Marwick
PD2453/07 James McKeen v Sir Robert McAlpine Ltd	Thompsons	Anderson Strathern
A742/04 Strathclyde Joint Police Board v F Wilson & Son	Simpson & Marwick	Balfour + Manson LLP
PD407/08 Avril Maxwell v Early Learning Centre Ltd	Thompsons	Simpson & Marwick

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on 6^th June 2008 in terms of the Pilot Scheme intimated on the Rolls of Court on Thursday 8^th February 2007

PD426/08 John McClue v A J Clark (Concrete Flooring) Ltd	Digby Brown	Simpson & Marwick
PD832/08 Anne Tully &c v Upper Clyde Shipbulders Ltd	Thompsons
PD425/08 Charles Watson v Fife Council	Digby Brown	Simpson & Marwick

PD2382/07 Lorraine Watt v Aberdeenshire Council

Thompsons

Simpson & Marwick

______________

COURT OF SESSION

Tuesday 10^th June

SINGLE BILLS

FIRST DIVISION

*1	Council for Regulation of Health AG Committee of the Nursing	Brodies
*2	Halifax plc v Malcolm Aldrick	Anderson Fyfe
3	Pet: Cheryl Beattie +1 to admit as solicitors	Law Society of Scotland
4	Olgal Megdalskaya v Secretary of State for Home Dept	McGill & Co

LORD CLARKE

Tuesday 10^th June

Judgment

(Appearance of counsel not required)

Pet: The Infant & Dietetic Association Ltd

for Judicial Review

Maclay Murray & Spens - M Sinclair - C Mullin

LORD MENZIES

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTION

1

Pet: Butterworths Lenses Ltd to wind up

Revenue & Customs

LADY SMITH

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Roberta Durie v Freescale Semi Conductor UK Ltd	Lawford Kidd
2	James Fotheringham &c v Forth Valley Acute Hospitals NHS Trust	Digby Brown
3	Brian Hexley &c v Fife Council	Drummond Miller
4	Hotel Portfolio II UK Ltd &c v The Scottish Ministers	BTO
5	Gregory King v express Newspapers	Balfour + Manson LLP
6	Steven Law v Russel + Aitken	Morton Fraser
7	Macintyres of Edinburgh v Jim Wyse	Maclay Murray & Spens
8	John McEwan v Ayrshire & Arran Acute Hospitals NHS Trust	Russell Jones & Walker
9	Ruth Miller v Nigel Mille & c	Balfour + Manson LLP
10	Benjamin Monteith v Scot Tech Furniture Ltd	Russell Jones & Walker
11	James Murphy v ACA Developments Ltd	Thompsons
12	Elizabeth Murphy v North Ayrshire Council	Morton Fraser
13	John O’Connor v Ian Watt	Digby Brown
14	Harry Presly v Aberdeenshire Council &c	Lefevre Litigation
15	Ruth Riddell v George Anderson & Sons	Simpson & Marwick
16	Royal Bank of Scotland v John Cuthill	Anderson Strathern
17	Royal Bank of Scotland v Paul McLeod	Anderson Strathern
18	J & G Smith &c v James Brown t/a Hamnavoe Farms	Anderson Strathern

LORD BRACADALE

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Steven Easterbrook v John Anderson	HBM Sayers
2	Leann French v Andrew Usher	Simpson & Marwick
3	Marie Susanne Gray v The Advocate General for Scotland	Thompsons
4	John Harvey v Boots the Chemists Ltd	Balfour + Manson LLP
5	Robert Horne v MMA Insuance Plc	A & W M Urquhart
6	Joan Imrie &c v Humphreys & Glasgow Ltd &c	Watermans
7	Thomas Jeffrey v RHM Ltd	Thompsons
8	John King v Thomas Menzies (Builders) Ltd	Morisons
9	Maxine Lewis v Partners for Inclusion Ltd	HBM Sayers
10	Thomas Love v Stud Welding Services (Scot) Ltd &c	Digby Brown
11	George Rodger v Edinburgh Council	Allan McDougall & Co
12	Margaret Ross v Scottish Water	HBM Sayers
13	Janine Rusmussen v AXA Insurance UK Plc	Andersons
14	David Seale v Scottish Water	Allan McDougall & Co
15	Stuart Shields v Fife Fabrications Ltd	Bonnar & Co
16	Graeme Simpson v Stena Drilling Ltd	Balfour + Manson LLP
17	Rosaline Smith v Fife Council	Simpson & Marwick
18	Alexander Stark-Campbell v East Calder Health Centre	R F Macdonald

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTION

1

Pet; Charles M Ingram & Sons for appointment of judicial factor

Maclay Murray & Spens

LORD GLENNIE

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Angus Dundee Distillers Plc v Whyte & Mackay td	HBJ Gateley Wareings (Scotland) LLP
1	BPB UK Ltd v IGL Ltd (in liq)	Pinsent Masons
2	Royal Bank of Scotland v William Huaghey	Balfour + Manson LLP

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTION

1

Pet: Heart of Midlothian Plc to wind up by HSBC Invoice Finance

Shepherd & Wedderburn

LORD MATTHEWS

STARRED MOTIONS

15mins	John Harvey v Boots The Chemist Ltd	Balfour + Manson LLP	Archibald Campbell & Harley
20mins	Gardline Geosurvey Ltd v Unity Fishing Co Ltd	Brodies

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Maxwell MacMillan v British Railway Board (Residurary)	HBM Sayers
2	Brian McGregor v F E Hoad & Sons	Anderson Strathern
3	Stephen McGunnigle v Aulds Delicious v Aulds Delicious Desserts Ltd	Digby Brown
4	Pauline McKenzie v Fife Acute Hospitals NHS Trust	Morisons
5	Pauline McKenzie v Fife Acute Hospitals NHS Trust	R F Macdonald
6	Peter McIntyre v Little Cumbrae Estate Ltd	Andersons
7	Stuart McNeil v Ashleigh (Scotland) Ltd	DLA
8	James Melville v Glasgow City Council	G Lindsay
9	Stephen Mitchell v CIS General Insurance Society Ltd	Allan McDougall & Co
10	Maria Molloy v Peter Brown	Digby Brown
11	James Stratton v Hardies LLP	Simpson & Marwick
12	STVA UK Ltd v Peugeot Citroen Automobiles SA &c	HBJ Gateley Wareings (Scotland) LLP
13	Carol Wright v NHS 24	Anderson Strathern

LORD WOOLMAN

STARRED MOTIONS

20mins

Anne Liddle v Aberdeenshire Council

Ledingham Chalmers

Lefevre Litigation

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Advocate General v Charles Dalziel	Revenue & Customs
2	Lorraine Anthoney v Advocate General	Thompsons
3	Jessie Beaton &c v Lothian NHS Board	Balfour + Manson LLP
4	Mary Bonnar v Fraser Cowie	Digby Brown
5	Andrew Brown v Dolphin Drilling Ltd	MacKinnons
6	Bryan Cameron v W J & J Green	Balfour + Manson LLP
7	John Christie v Grampian Health Board	Andersons
8	William Cochrane v The Albion Bar Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
9	Scott Cumming v The Scottish Ministers	Digby Brown
10	Patricia Nisbet v James Nisbet	Harper Macleod	Pagan Osborne

PETITION DEPARTMENT

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Note: Patrick Pocock for variation of restraint order	Crown Office
2	Pet: Moghaddas Toba for judicial review	McGill & Co
3	Pet: Scottish Ministers for recovery order re Murdo Smith	Civil Recovery Unit

M WISE, QC

STARRED MOTIONS

10mins	Monica Flynn v ICL Tech Ltd	Drummond Miller	HBM Sayers
10mins	Orkney Islands Council v Aren Henderson	Dundas & Wilson	Brodies

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

1	Briggs Marine Contractors Ltd v Pelamis Wave Power Ltd	HBJ Claims Solutions (Scotland) LLP
2	Oliver Brooks v Rhodar (Scotland) Ltd	HBM Sayers
3	Ronald Buick v James Scott Ltd &c	Thompsons
4	Colin Campbell v Weston Transport Ltd	Andersons
5	Kerry Clarke v Daniel Rafferty	Simpson & Marwick
6	Ronald Courtney v Scottish Water	HBM Sayers
7	John Currie v Scotia BBS Ltd	Simpson & Marwick
8	Thomas Currie v Waste Services Ltd	Digby Brown
9	Geraldine Dowd v Board of Management of J Wheatley College	Digby Brown
10	Thomas Downie v Gordon Rankin	Lawford Kidd
11	Hugh Dow v Ailsa Shipbuilding Co Ltd	Thompsons
12	Hugh McCallion v Sturrock Power Holdings Ltd &c	Simpson & Marwick
13	James Reid v Lothian Health Board	Drummond Miller
14	Orkney Islands Council v Arch Henderson LLP	Dundas & Wilson
15	Andrew Ross v Norwich Union Insurance Ltd	Thompsons
16	David Watson &c v Robison & Davidson Ltd	Andersons
17	Patricia Welsh v George Welch	Andersons
18	Joseph West v Castlehill LLP	HBM Sayers
19	John Wilson v William Dalgarno	Lefevre Litigation
20	Nicol Wood v Global Santafe North Sea Ltd &c	Balfour + Manson LLP
21	Ryan Wood v Ian McCallum &c	Simpson & Marwick
22	Peter Young v Domestic Plumbing & Heating (Scotland) Ltd	Digby Brown

LORD

STARRED MOTION

10mins	Aberdeen City Council v Balgownie Slaters &c	A & W M Urquhart	Russel +Aitken
10mins	Tracey Armstrong v Alison Baylis	Russel +Aitken	Harper Macleod
10mins	Mark Maciver v Ronald Bosman	Simpson & Marwick	Andersons
10mins	Mark Maciver v Ronald Bosman	Simpson & Marwick	Andersons
1hr	Pauline Gilmartin v Dundee City Council	Simpson & Marwick	Balfour + Manson LLP
1hr	Pamela McMaster v Robert McMaster	Pagan Osborne	Anderson Strathern

_______

OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

LORD MACKAY OF DRUMADOON – K Todd, Clerk

Wednesday 11^th June

By Order

at 9am

P2463/07 Pet: Grant O’Connor for Judicial Review

Balfour + Manson LLP - M Sinclair

By Order (Adjustment)

A1411/03 Scottish Widows Services Ltd v Cundall

Johnston & Partners

Pinsent Masons - Brodies

By Order

A455/04 David Melvin v Wilfred Scholes

Drummond Miller - HBJ Gateley Wareing (Scotland) LLP

LADY SMITH – C. Richardson, Clerk

Wednesday 11^th June

By Order (Adjustment)

1

A832/06 Duffield Morgan Ltd v Sportsgrounds Ltd

Russel +Aitken

McGrigors

LORD BRODIE - C Fyffe, Clerk

Wednesday 11^th June

Judgment

(Appearance of counsel not required)

A168/07 Peter Matthews v Hunter & Robertson Ltd

Anderson Strathern - BTO

LORD BRACADALE - P Fiddes, Clerk

Wednesday 11^th June

By Order

P2272/06 Pet: Scottish Charity Regulator v The ME Foundation

Shepherd & Wedderburn - Turcan Connell

LORD GLENNIE – A. Finlayson, Clerk

ORDINARY ACTION

Wednesday 11^th June

Continued Motion

at 9am

P669/06 Note: J Reid &c Ltd v Arakin Ltd for

renumeration & sist liq

McGrigors - Party Litigant

LORD BRAILSFORD

Wednesday 11^th June

Continued By Order

At 2.00pm

1	A72/07 BC Property Holdings Ltd v Fiona Gibbons &c	Shepherd & Wedderburn	Party
2	A74/07 Strathclyde Associated Prop Holdings Ltd v Fiona Gibbons	Shepherd & Wedderburn	Party
3	A75/07 Strathclyde Associated Property Holdings v Fiona Gibbons	Shepherd & Wedderburn	Party

LORD MATTHEWS – R. MacPherson, Clerk

Wednesday 11^th June

By Order

A652/05 Michelle Hynes v Julie Mallon

Morton Fraser - MDDUS

LORD WOOLMAN - L. MacLachlan, Clerk

Wednesday 11^th June

By Order

A220/05 Viewpoint Housing Assoc Ltd v City of Edinburgh Council

HBM Sayers - Simpson & Marwick

M WISE, QC

Wednesday 11^th June

By Order (Adjustment)

A253/05 James Reid v Lothian Health Board

Drummond Miller - R F Macdonald

Hearing under section 15K of the Debtors (Scotland) Act 1987

A418/08 Alexander Davidson v Colin Davidson

Drummond Miller

TO BE ALLOCATED

Wednesday 11^th June

First Hearing

1	P801/08 Pet: Monica Chizororo for judicial review	Drummond Miller	OSAG
1	P906/08 Pet: Maghaddas Toba for judicial review	McGill & Co	C Mullin

Proof

½ day

A87/08 Margery Alcock &c v Gillian Alcock

Gillespie Macandrew

Procedure Roll

1

A117/06 C J Laing & Son Ltd v Malkiat Singh Diu &c

Brodies LLP

McClure Naismith

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

FIRST EXTRA DIVISION

Wednesday 11^th June

Summar Roll (1 Day)

A183/08 Reclaiming Motion - Lord Drummond Young - in the cause -

GBF Financial Management Co AG Steven Worrallo &c

Shepherd & Wedderburn - McKay & Norwell

SECOND EXTRA DIVISION

Wednesday 11^th June

Advising

(appearance of counsel not required)

Appeal by James Swanney against a decision of the General Medical Council

Party Anderson Strathern -

______________

HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY

Tuesday 10^th and Wednesday 11^th June

at 10am

PROCEEDINGS UNDER CONTEMPT OF COURT ACT 1981

HM Advocate v (1) IPC Media, (2) Jackie Hatton/Karen Livermore, (3) Anna Kingsley/Jackie Brown

Wednesday 11^th June

at 10am

SECTION 76

HM Advocate v Raymond Carl Peers

(in custody)

ADJOURNED DIET FOR SENTENCE

HM Advocate v Derek John McLean

(in custody)

ADJOURNED DIET FOR SENTENCE

HM Advocate v David Iain McKenzie

(in custody)

EXTRA DIVISION - 1^st APPEAL COURT - 3 JUDGES

CRIMINAL APPEAL ROLL

Wednesday 11^th June

at 10.30am

PROCEDURAL HEARINGS IN APPEALS AGAINST CONVICTION

1	Robert O’Hara (21/6/77) (custody)	Hamilton Burns & Co, Glasgow	XC417/05
2	Robert Murray (2/8/77) (custody)	McClure Naismith	XC423/05

CROWN APPEAL IN TERMS OF SECTION 65 THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE (SCOTLAND) ACT 1995

3

Ernest Richards (26/10/58)

Bell & Russell

XC185/08

APPEAL IN TERMS OF SECTION 74 THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE (SCOTLAND) ACT 1995

4

Ernest Richards (26/10/58)

Bell & Russell

XC98/08

EXTRA DIVISION - 1^ST COURT - 3 JUDGES

CRIMINAL APPEAL ROLL

Wednesday 11^th June

At 10.00am

APPLICATIONS FOR EXTENSION OF TIME AFTER REFUSAL BY A SINGLE JUDGE

1

Alexander Law (8/6/61) (in custody

McClure Collins, Edinburgh

XC273/08

2

Alan Harvey (27/8/82) (in custody)

McClure Collins, Edinburgh

XC306/08

EXTRA DIVISION – 2^ND APPEAL COURT – 3 JUDGES

CRIMINAL APPEAL ROLL

Wednesday 11^th June

At 10.30 am

APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION

1

Shehzada Hanif (19/9/620 (bail)

C Shead, Balfour + Manson LLP

XC63/06

______________