Issue No187

 

Monday 9th June 2008

 

 

C O N T E N T S

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Unopposed Motions

 

Single Bills

 

Starred and Unstarred Motions

 

Outer House Rolls

 

Inner House Rolls

 

High Court of Justiciary

 

 

 


UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

 

 

 

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on 4th June 2008 in terms of the Pilot Scheme intimated on the Rolls of Court on Thursday 8th February 2007

 

PD1136/07 Margaret Imrie v Murray Paterson

 

Anderson Strathern

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on 5th June 2008 in terms of the Pilot Scheme intimated on the Rolls of Court on Thursday 8th February 2007

 

PD1136/07 Margaret Imrie v Murray Paterson

 

Anderson Strathern

Simpson & Marwick 

PD2453/07 James McKeen v Sir Robert McAlpine Ltd

Thompsons

Anderson Strathern

 

 

A742/04 Strathclyde Joint Police Board v F Wilson & Son

Simpson & Marwick 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

PD407/08 Avril Maxwell v Early Learning Centre Ltd

Thompsons

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on 6th June 2008 in terms of the Pilot Scheme intimated on the Rolls of Court on Thursday 8th February 2007

 

PD426/08 John McClue v A J Clark (Concrete Flooring) Ltd

 

Digby Brown

Simpson & Marwick 

 

PD832/08 Anne Tully &c v Upper Clyde Shipbulders Ltd

Thompsons

 

 

 

PD425/08 Charles Watson v Fife Council

 

Digby Brown

Simpson & Marwick 

 


 

PD2382/07 Lorraine Watt v Aberdeenshire Council

 

Thompsons

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

 

 

 

______________

 


 

COURT OF SESSION

 

 

Tuesday 10th June

 

SINGLE BILLS

 

FIRST DIVISION

 

*1

Council for Regulation of Health AG Committee of the Nursing

 

Brodies

 

 

 

*2

Halifax plc v Malcolm Aldrick

Anderson Fyfe

 

 

 

3

Pet:  Cheryl Beattie +1 to admit as solicitors

Law Society of Scotland

 

 

 

4

Olgal Megdalskaya v Secretary of State for Home Dept

McGill & Co

 

 

 

 

 

 

LORD CLARKE

 

Tuesday 10th June

 

Judgment

(Appearance of counsel not required)

 

Pet:  The Infant & Dietetic Association Ltd

for Judicial Review

Maclay Murray & Spens - M Sinclair - C Mullin


LORD MENZIES

 

PETITION DEPARTMENT

 

UNSTARRED MOTION

 

1

Pet:  Butterworths Lenses Ltd to wind up

Revenue & Customs

 

 

 

 

 

LADY SMITH

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

Roberta Durie v Freescale Semi Conductor UK Ltd

 

Lawford Kidd

 

 

 

2

James Fotheringham &c v Forth Valley Acute Hospitals NHS Trust

Digby Brown

 

 

 

 

3

Brian Hexley &c v Fife Council

Drummond Miller

 

 

 

4

Hotel Portfolio II UK Ltd &c v The Scottish Ministers

BTO

 

 

 

 

 

5

Gregory King v express Newspapers

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

6

Steven Law v Russel + Aitken

Morton Fraser

 

 

 

7

Macintyres of Edinburgh v Jim Wyse

Maclay Murray & Spens

 

 

 

8

John McEwan v Ayrshire & Arran Acute Hospitals NHS Trust

Russell Jones & Walker

 

 

 

9

Ruth Miller v Nigel Mille & c

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

10

Benjamin Monteith v Scot Tech Furniture Ltd

Russell Jones & Walker

 

 

 

11

James Murphy v ACA Developments Ltd

Thompsons

 

 

 

 

12

Elizabeth Murphy v North Ayrshire Council

Morton Fraser

 

 

 

13

John O’Connor v Ian Watt

Digby Brown

 

 

 

14

Harry Presly v Aberdeenshire Council &c

 

Lefevre Litigation

 

 

15

Ruth Riddell v George Anderson & Sons

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

16

Royal Bank of Scotland v John Cuthill

 

Anderson Strathern

 

 

 

17

Royal Bank of Scotland v Paul McLeod

Anderson Strathern

 

 

 

18

J & G Smith &c v James Brown t/a Hamnavoe Farms

Anderson Strathern

 

 

 

 

 

 


LORD BRACADALE

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

Steven Easterbrook v John Anderson

HBM Sayers

 

 

 

 

2

Leann French v Andrew Usher

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

3

Marie Susanne Gray v The Advocate General for Scotland

Thompsons

 

 

 

 

 

4

John Harvey v Boots the Chemists Ltd

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

5

Robert Horne v MMA Insuance Plc

 

A & W M Urquhart

 

 

 

6

Joan Imrie &c v Humphreys & Glasgow Ltd &c

Watermans

 

 

 

 

 

7

Thomas Jeffrey v RHM Ltd

Thompsons

 

 

 

 

8

John King v Thomas Menzies (Builders) Ltd

Morisons

 

 

 

 

9

Maxine Lewis v Partners for Inclusion Ltd

HBM Sayers

 

 

 

 

10

Thomas Love v Stud Welding Services (Scot) Ltd &c

 

Digby Brown

 

 

 

 

11

George Rodger v Edinburgh Council

Allan McDougall & Co

 

 

 

12

Margaret Ross v Scottish Water

HBM Sayers

 

 

 

 

13

Janine Rusmussen v AXA Insurance UK Plc

Andersons

 

 

 

 

14

David Seale v Scottish Water

Allan McDougall & Co

 

 

 

15

Stuart Shields v Fife Fabrications Ltd

Bonnar & Co

 

 

 

16

Graeme Simpson v Stena Drilling Ltd

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

17

Rosaline Smith v Fife Council

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

18

Alexander Stark-Campbell v East Calder Health Centre

 

R F Macdonald 

 

 

 

 

PETITION DEPARTMENT

 

UNSTARRED MOTION

 

1

Pet;  Charles M Ingram & Sons for appointment of judicial factor

 

Maclay Murray & Spens

 

 

 

 


LORD GLENNIE

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

 

1

Angus Dundee Distillers Plc v Whyte & Mackay td

HBJ Gateley Wareings (Scotland) LLP

 

 

 

1

BPB UK Ltd v IGL Ltd (in liq)

Pinsent Masons

 

 

 

2

Royal Bank of Scotland v William Huaghey

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

PETITION DEPARTMENT

 

UNSTARRED MOTION

 

1

Pet:  Heart of Midlothian Plc to wind up by HSBC Invoice Finance

Shepherd & Wedderburn

 

 

 

 

 

 

LORD MATTHEWS

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

15mins

John Harvey v Boots The Chemist Ltd

Balfour + Manson LLP

Archibald Campbell & Harley

 

 

20mins

Gardline Geosurvey Ltd v Unity Fishing Co Ltd

Brodies

 

 

 

 

 


 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

Maxwell MacMillan v British Railway Board (Residurary)

 

HBM Sayers

 

 

 

2

Brian McGregor v F E Hoad & Sons

 

Anderson Strathern

 

 

 

3

Stephen McGunnigle v Aulds Delicious v Aulds Delicious Desserts Ltd

 

Digby Brown

 

 

 

4

Pauline McKenzie v Fife Acute Hospitals NHS Trust

 

Morisons

 

 

 

5

Pauline McKenzie v Fife Acute Hospitals NHS Trust

 

R F Macdonald 

 

 

 

 

6

Peter McIntyre v Little Cumbrae Estate Ltd

 

Andersons

 

 

 

 

7

Stuart McNeil v Ashleigh (Scotland) Ltd

DLA

 

 

 

 

8

James Melville v Glasgow City Council

 

G Lindsay

 

 

 

9

Stephen Mitchell v CIS General Insurance Society Ltd

Allan McDougall & Co

 

 

 

10

Maria Molloy v Peter Brown

Digby Brown

 

 

 

11

James Stratton v Hardies LLP

 

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

 

12

STVA UK Ltd v Peugeot Citroen Automobiles SA &c

HBJ Gateley Wareings (Scotland) LLP

 

 

 

13

Carol Wright v NHS 24

Anderson Strathern

 

 

 

 

 

LORD WOOLMAN

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

20mins

Anne Liddle v Aberdeenshire Council

 

Ledingham Chalmers

Lefevre Litigation

 

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

Advocate General v Charles Dalziel

Revenue & Customs

 

 

 

2

Lorraine Anthoney v Advocate General

Thompsons

 

 

 

 

3

Jessie Beaton &c v Lothian NHS Board

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

4

Mary Bonnar v Fraser Cowie

Digby Brown

 

 

 

5

Andrew Brown v Dolphin Drilling Ltd

 

MacKinnons

 

 

 

 

6

Bryan Cameron v W J & J Green

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

7

John Christie v Grampian Health Board

Andersons

 

 

 

 

8

William Cochrane v The Albion Bar Ltd

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

9

Scott Cumming v The Scottish Ministers

Digby Brown

 

 

 

10

Patricia Nisbet v James Nisbet

Harper Macleod

 

Pagan Osborne

 

 

PETITION DEPARTMENT

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

Note:  Patrick Pocock for variation of restraint order

Crown Office

 

 

 

 

2

Pet:  Moghaddas Toba for judicial review

McGill & Co

 

 

 

3

Pet:  Scottish Ministers for recovery order re Murdo Smith

Civil Recovery Unit

 

 

 

 

 

 

M WISE, QC

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

10mins

Monica Flynn v ICL Tech Ltd

Drummond Miller

 

HBM Sayers

 

 

10mins

Orkney Islands Council v Aren Henderson

Dundas & Wilson

Brodies

 

 

 


 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

1

Briggs Marine Contractors Ltd v Pelamis Wave Power Ltd

HBJ Claims Solutions

(Scotland) LLP

 

 

 

2

Oliver Brooks v Rhodar (Scotland) Ltd

HBM Sayers

 

 

 

 

3

Ronald Buick v James Scott Ltd &c

Thompsons

 

 

 

 

4

Colin Campbell v Weston Transport Ltd

Andersons

 

 

 

 

5

Kerry Clarke v Daniel Rafferty

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

6

Ronald Courtney v Scottish Water

HBM Sayers

 

 

 

 

 

 

7

John Currie v Scotia BBS Ltd

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

8

Thomas Currie v Waste Services Ltd

Digby Brown

 

 

 

9

Geraldine Dowd v Board of Management of J Wheatley College

Digby Brown

 

 

 

 

10

Thomas Downie v Gordon Rankin

Lawford Kidd

 

 

 

11

Hugh Dow v Ailsa Shipbuilding Co Ltd

Thompsons

 

 

 

 

12

Hugh McCallion v Sturrock Power Holdings Ltd &c

 

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

13

James Reid v Lothian Health Board

Drummond Miller

 

 

 

14

Orkney Islands Council v Arch Henderson LLP

Dundas & Wilson

 

 

 

15

Andrew Ross v Norwich Union Insurance Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

 

 

16

David Watson &c v Robison & Davidson Ltd

Andersons

 

 

 

 

 

17

Patricia Welsh v George Welch

 

Andersons

 

 

 

18

Joseph West v Castlehill LLP

HBM Sayers

 

 

 

 

19

John Wilson v William Dalgarno

 

Lefevre Litigation

 

 

 

20

Nicol Wood v Global Santafe North Sea Ltd &c

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

 

21

Ryan Wood v Ian McCallum &c

Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

22

Peter Young v Domestic Plumbing & Heating (Scotland) Ltd

Digby Brown

 

 

 

 

 


LORD

 

STARRED MOTION

 

10mins

Aberdeen City Council v Balgownie Slaters &c

A & W M Urquhart

 

 

Russel +Aitken

 

10mins

Tracey Armstrong v Alison Baylis

Russel +Aitken

 

Harper Macleod

 

10mins

Mark Maciver v Ronald Bosman

Simpson & Marwick 

 

Andersons

 

 

 

10mins

Mark Maciver v Ronald Bosman

Simpson & Marwick 

Andersons

 

 

 

1hr

Pauline Gilmartin v Dundee City Council

Simpson & Marwick 

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

 

1hr

Pamela McMaster v Robert McMaster

Pagan Osborne

Anderson Strathern

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______

 

 

 


OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

 

 

LORD MACKAY OF DRUMADOON – K Todd, Clerk

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

By Order

at 9am

 

P2463/07 Pet:  Grant O’Connor for Judicial Review

Balfour + Manson LLP - M Sinclair

 

By Order (Adjustment)

 

A1411/03 Scottish Widows Services Ltd v Cundall

Johnston & Partners

Pinsent Masons - Brodies

 

By Order

 

A455/04 David Melvin v Wilfred Scholes

Drummond Miller - HBJ Gateley Wareing (Scotland) LLP

 

 

 

LADY SMITH – C. Richardson, Clerk

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

By Order (Adjustment)

 

1

A832/06 Duffield Morgan Ltd v Sportsgrounds Ltd

Russel +Aitken

McGrigors

 

 

 

 


 

LORD BRODIE - C Fyffe, Clerk

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

Judgment

(Appearance of counsel not required)

 

A168/07 Peter Matthews v Hunter & Robertson Ltd

Anderson Strathern - BTO

 

 

 

LORD BRACADALE - P Fiddes, Clerk

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

By Order

 

P2272/06 Pet:  Scottish Charity Regulator v The ME Foundation

Shepherd & Wedderburn - Turcan Connell

 

 

 

LORD GLENNIE – A. Finlayson, Clerk

 

ORDINARY ACTION

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

Continued Motion

at 9am

 

P669/06 Note:  J Reid &c Ltd v Arakin Ltd for

renumeration & sist liq

McGrigors - Party Litigant

 

 


 

LORD BRAILSFORD

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

Continued By Order

At 2.00pm

 

1

A72/07 BC Property Holdings Ltd v Fiona Gibbons &c

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn

Party

 

2

A74/07 Strathclyde Associated Prop Holdings Ltd v Fiona Gibbons

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn

Party

 

3

A75/07 Strathclyde Associated Property Holdings v Fiona Gibbons

 

Shepherd & Wedderburn

Party

 

 

 

LORD MATTHEWS – R. MacPherson, Clerk

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

By Order

 

A652/05 Michelle Hynes v Julie Mallon

Morton Fraser - MDDUS

 

 

 

LORD WOOLMAN -  L. MacLachlan, Clerk

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

By Order

 

A220/05 Viewpoint Housing Assoc Ltd v City of Edinburgh Council

HBM Sayers - Simpson & Marwick 

 

 

 

M WISE, QC

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

By Order (Adjustment)

 

A253/05 James Reid v Lothian Health Board

Drummond Miller - R F Macdonald 

 

Hearing under section 15K of the Debtors (Scotland) Act 1987

 

A418/08 Alexander Davidson v Colin Davidson

Drummond Miller

 

 

 

TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

First Hearing

 

1

P801/08 Pet:  Monica Chizororo for judicial review

 

Drummond Miller

OSAG

 

1

P906/08 Pet: Maghaddas Toba for judicial review

 

McGill & Co

C Mullin

 

Proof

 

½

day

A87/08 Margery Alcock &c v Gillian Alcock

Gillespie Macandrew

 

 

 

Procedure Roll

 

1

A117/06 C J Laing & Son Ltd v Malkiat Singh Diu &c

 

Brodies LLP

McClure Naismith

 

 

 

 

 

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

 

 

FIRST EXTRA DIVISION

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

Summar Roll (1 Day)

 

A183/08 Reclaiming Motion - Lord Drummond Young - in the cause -

GBF Financial Management Co AG Steven Worrallo &c

Shepherd & Wedderburn - McKay & Norwell

 

 

 

 

SECOND EXTRA DIVISION

 

Wednesday 11th June

 

Advising

(appearance of counsel not required)

 

Appeal by James Swanney against a decision of the General Medical Council

Party Anderson Strathern -

 

 

 

 

______________

 


HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY

 

 

 

Tuesday 10th and Wednesday 11th June

at 10am

 

PROCEEDINGS UNDER CONTEMPT OF COURT ACT 1981

 

HM Advocate v (1) IPC Media, (2) Jackie Hatton/Karen Livermore, (3) Anna Kingsley/Jackie Brown

 

 

Wednesday 11th June

at 10am

 

SECTION 76

 

HM Advocate v Raymond Carl Peers

(in custody)

 

 

ADJOURNED DIET FOR SENTENCE

 

HM Advocate v Derek John McLean

(in custody)

 

 

ADJOURNED DIET FOR SENTENCE

 

HM Advocate v David Iain McKenzie

(in custody)

 

 


 

EXTRA DIVISION - 1st APPEAL COURT - 3 JUDGES

 

CRIMINAL APPEAL ROLL

 

Wednesday 11th June

at 10.30am

 

PROCEDURAL HEARINGS IN APPEALS AGAINST CONVICTION

 

1

Robert O’Hara (21/6/77) (custody)

Hamilton Burns & Co, Glasgow

XC417/05

 

 

2

Robert Murray (2/8/77) (custody)

McClure Naismith

XC423/05

 

 

CROWN APPEAL IN TERMS OF SECTION 65 THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE (SCOTLAND) ACT 1995

 

3

Ernest Richards (26/10/58)

Bell & Russell

XC185/08

 

APPEAL IN TERMS OF SECTION 74 THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE (SCOTLAND) ACT 1995

 

4

Ernest Richards (26/10/58)

Bell & Russell

XC98/08

 

 

 

EXTRA DIVISION - 1ST COURT - 3 JUDGES

 

CRIMINAL APPEAL ROLL

 

Wednesday 11th June

At 10.00am

 

APPLICATIONS FOR EXTENSION OF TIME AFTER REFUSAL BY A SINGLE JUDGE

 

 1

 

Alexander Law (8/6/61) (in custody

 

McClure Collins, Edinburgh

XC273/08


 

 2

Alan Harvey (27/8/82) (in custody)

McClure Collins, Edinburgh

XC306/08

 

 

 

EXTRA DIVISION – 2ND APPEAL COURT – 3 JUDGES

 

CRIMINAL APPEAL ROLL

 

Wednesday 11th June

At 10.30 am

 

APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION

 

1

Shehzada Hanif (19/9/620 (bail)

 

C Shead, Balfour + Manson LLP

XC63/06

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

______________